Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Book is here!  :bounce: :bible: :bounce:

 

I will avert my eyes if necessary ;)  

 

BUT I'm glad you did give us the hint, Tricia, because it could be a surprise to someone if not prepared... and I had wondered from seeing the trailer above....

 

My general feeling regarding uh... questionable material ... is that if it is appropriate to the story line and handled well, it can be appropriate in a book for older YA readers and adults.  (I get grumpy when I feel that scenes are added merely to sell books.... a big issue with MANY adult books last 20 years or so.... if it is integral to the story, it's part of the story; if 'graphic' stuff is in there as a trophy for the writer, shame on the writer.  My 2 cents.)

 

And I haven't read yet, so I dunno!!!!   But I know what I will be doing for part of this weekend!!!!!!!  

 

Hot coffee and a book!!!!!! Wheeee!  :eat: :bible: :eat:   (Please... WE NEED A COFFEE EMOTICON!)

xTrishaxLynnx
Posted

Yeah, definitely. I just want to make sure nobody thinks it's worse than it actually is so they don't change the book of the month. The book does say they have sex, but it's not like 50 Shades of Grey or anything. :P

 

 

It says a bit more than that, but I see your point; no, it certainly isn't anything like what I've heard 50 Shades of Grey is, but that's not really a good gauge against which to compare the appropriateness of young adult novels, either.

 

Also, that wasn't the only part that was questionable. Honestly, when I listened to the preview of it on Audible I almost said something then because that alone made it seem like maybe it wasn't the best choice for a book club involving young members. I realized, though, that I may be a bit overcautious with this sort of thing and figured I'd leave it up to the parents of the younger members to keep tabs on what their kids are reading and it isn't for me to judge what's appropriate, particularly for people I don't really know.

ChristinaTherese
Posted

I'm not exactly in your category of young members, Tricia, but I appreciate the heads up.

Posted

So discussion begins at the end of February? 

 

Edit: Additionally, the first trailer for the movie came out today.  It does a pretty good job of summarizing the book, without any real big plot-twisty-ruining spoilers, for anyone who isn't sure what the book is about: 

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ItBvH5J6ss

 

Oh dear, WHAT did I get myself into?! D:

 

In other news, I recognized the song playing in the background. "We're on our way" by Radical Face (Ben Cooper). He also wrote this little gem that became quite popular a few years back

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P8a4iiOnzsc

 

I really love his music and recommend anyone to check it out. :)

 

Idunno... I had thought earlier, but it should start when people have had a chance to read the book.   Mine won't ARRIVE until Saturday.

 

IceNine, when do you want the book discussion to start?

 

I don't know, maybe . . .  somewhere around the 20th? I think that would give people a chance to read it and enough time to discuss before moving onto March, if indeed people want to read another book.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

A couple things - 

 

I feel like reading about something is somehow different than watching it in a movie. It's a young adult book, and when I read it I considered it PG-13. Parents always have the right and responsibility to monitor what their kids read, but I don't think the content was inappropriate for most high schoolers, which is what I consider YA lit to be generally geared toward anyway. 

 

John Green has said that the reason why he included that "scene" was to underscore the idea that even disabled or ill people are still sexual beings. Does he succeed in sending that message and/or did he do it in the right way? That'd be an interesting discussion. I didn't find it to be truly explicit, but maybe others do. 

 

John Green studied to be a Christian minister for a while. He spent some time as a chaplain at a hospital I think (non-denom, if I recall correctly). He's not a minister anymore, and I'm not sure what his current religious views are, but he definitely reminds me of how many of my non-denominational Christian friends act and see the world, in a lot of ways. I think this plays a role in the way he portrays religion (and religious questions!) in the book. 

Anywho. I can't wait until y'all finish! :) 

Posted

I'm also in an 'I can't wait till I finish & I can't wait to talk to all of you' space!

 

Partly because of some stuff in my own life that is relevant to the early part of the book... and probably to the whole thing.  I can't wait to compare notes!!!!!!!!   And I have some stuff to share with all of you... and you may have some for me.  :bounce:

 

I also suspect that, uh, regarding the sensitive material.... nothing I've seen so far would be a surprise to any of the YAs I know... especially any who attend regular school vis-a-vis being homeschooled.  I doubt this would break new ground for most 21st century kids.... not sure, but my suspicion...  

 

From what my life experience has been, kids are kids and will share what they have learned... so most of this will not give any new info to a typical YA.... (but I haven't gotten to the scene yet, so you never know!)

Posted

A word of caution: "Don't read good books; only read the best."

Posted

Wah! I'm hoping I will have the time to read the book this week! I'm rather busy at the moment though! If you guys start a discussion I might just have to go read the book and then jump into the discussion when I finish!

Posted

IceNine suggested we start around the 20th, which will let everyone get it and get it read.

 

YOU don't have an excuse to slight your homework, Chryso.  ;)

 

 

Happy reading, everyone!!!!

Posted

I'll have to head to the library after work! My sister selfishly decided to take her copy to college with her. :P

Posted

So....it arrived the day before yesterday and I finished it in a coffee shop with tears rolling down my face yesterday afternoon.

 

I have to thank peeps because I would never of read it without it being mentioned here and I can't wait for the discussion.

 

(when do we start that?)

PhuturePriest
Posted

I still don't have my copy yet. I think the person that got it is one of those awful human beings who keeps it for the full two weeks, not taking into account that other people might want to read it, too.

Posted

I think we start talking about it on the 20th.... and hopefully the person returns it on TIME, Miles!

Posted

I need to borrow it from a friend who loaned her book to another friend so hopefully the other friend returns it (she is a fast read at least.)

Posted

I've now got my copy!

The library had a crazy long waiting list so I thought I wouldn't be able to take part...but my sister had an Amazon mix-up when she ordered her copy and ended up with two. I managed to find the spare one so I'll start reading soon when I'm done with my current book. :)

Posted

Ten days!!!!!   :)  :bible: :bible: :bible:

Posted

My friend is bringing it tomorrow to school, if she remembers...

Posted

I still don't have my copy yet. I think the person that got it is one of those awful human beings who keeps it for the full two weeks, not taking into account that other people might want to read it, too.


Seriously? Same here. SOMEONE (I don't know who) has had that book out of the school library for a few weeks. I might have to get a ride across town to go to the public library this weekend.
Posted

I got it and am loving it!

Posted

it's a pretty quick read y'all should be fine

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...