Lilllabettt Posted March 6, 2014 Author Posted March 6, 2014 next we will ask "ex-gays" what being gay is like. um, no.
4588686 Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 next we will ask "ex-gays" what being gay is like. um, no. You're far to smart to really think that's a valid retort. What experiential range am I missing that precludes me from understanding the 'Catholic experience?' I was a conservative Catholic for the majority of my life. Please explain exactly what about the Catholic experience radically changed three years ago.
NotreDame Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 It is somewhat ironic that your seemingly one and only retort is to charge people with being tedious. I've used "tedious" less this week than you've used "jim crow"... a LOT less... :bananarap:
4588686 Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 I've used "tedious" less this week than you've used "jim crow"... a LOT less... :bananarap: Ok
NotreDame Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 That's a silly retort since, as you know perfectly well, I was an extremely observant Catholic into adulthood. It's not how you start, bro, it's how you finish. The race isn't over yet, either.
Lilllabettt Posted March 6, 2014 Author Posted March 6, 2014 You're far to smart to really think that's a valid retort. What experiential range am I missing that precludes me from understanding the 'Catholic experience?' I was a conservative Catholic for the majority of my life. Please explain exactly what about the Catholic experience radically changed three years ago. Come on. What has changed is you have changed. You're looking in the wrong end of the telescope - back at the experience instead of through it. Completely different perspective. And this is beside the point, but being a religious conservative at a southern state school is slightly different than being a religious conservative at an elitist new england institution. slightly.
Luigi Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 Oh come on. Sure it's not the exact same. But you can still have all kinds of similar feelings of intimidation and stigmatization. Legal battles aren't the only important ones, ya know. You've hit the nail on the head. Groups that feel ostracized in any way because of variances in cultural norms now go to law. As if the law controls the culture rather than being an expression OF the culture. Which is why we have so many judges overturning so many plebiscites in so many state where the people defined marriage as between one man and one woman - the way it has been (culturally) in this country since its very foundation. The law - specifically laws to define new rights - is the only thing that matters, to certain groups of people.
Luigi Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 Certain groups are also inherently unable to let any given thread be about the given thread - they have to turn all topics to focus on THEM!!!!
Aloysius Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 ... not like the title of the thread was already a reference to another topic or anything... :whistle:
Anastasia13 Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 Certain groups are also inherently unable to let any given thread be about the given thread - they have to turn all topics to focus on THEM!!!! I thought Hasan was straight? Ok, except for that Arabian prince scandal, but we all know the Washington Post lies.
BG45 Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 ... not like the title of the thread was already a reference to another topic or anything... :whistle: Al is snarky? Lent has truly come...
blazeingstar Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 Come on. What has changed is you have changed. You're looking in the wrong end of the telescope - back at the experience instead of through it. Completely different perspective. And this is beside the point, but being a religious conservative at a southern state school is slightly different than being a religious conservative at an elitist new england institution. slightly. Totally, the South, while hostile to Catholics in some degree is open to christianity. In New England, in general, Catholics are very much seen as from the devil. When a co-worker found out that I invited a priest over for dinner and my friend and her 6yo girl, they told me that I should expect her to be abused and that I had better keep a close watch on her. Many priests don't wear their collars in public for fear of being physically accosted....protestants are a bit more tolerated. You have to remember also that the abuse scandal broke in New England, and their is still a phenomenal amount of agression towards the church. Then you also mix in the immagration issues and the fact that most of the most-hated immigrants, Hispanic, identify primarily with the Catholic church, it gets messy. Not for nothing Hassan, but college is not the same as "real" life. In college students experiment with many behaviors and so may in general face criticism, but it's nothing like the professional world. Quite frankly, you jumped ship, so you really don't "understand" what it's like.
IgnatiusofLoyola Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 some reactions from today: "I don't understand you." (not angry, kind of laughing, incredulous) "You actually do the whole thing. like you don't support gay people." (angry) "so no sex?" (incredulous) "That's interesting." (actually interested) "its okay. we're all growing, we're all in different places." (condescending tone) I also got a hug from a fellow secret Catholic. ethics professor was supportive, although advised not being open about it. He said that in his opinion Cambridge is among the least tolerant places on earth, drew a comparison to Pyongyan ( he is a secularist himself, but appreciates dissent). Oh, and its possible to be opposed to abortion rights for moral reasons but its not possible to be opposed to gay rights for moral reasons.:headdesk: so ... no nuclear war, although things with my boss are awkward now. oh well. Thanks for posting this. I'm behind on catching up with this thread. I was genuinely interested to hear what kinds of responses you got. Sorry to hear that things are awkward with your boss.
4588686 Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 Not for nothing Hassan, but college is not the same as "real" life. In college students experiment with many behaviors and so may in general face criticism, but it's nothing like the professional world. Quite frankly, you jumped ship, so you really don't "understand" what it's like. I was also Catholic while I held a job during college and off campus while going to a strongly liberal-leaning school. This is just obnoxious at this point. Nobody has given any substantive response except that I somehow don't understand what it's like to be Catholic because the decades that I spent as a member of the Church don't count and apparently the experience of being Catholic had radically transformed in the last few years. And FYI, while the South is welcoming of Christianity, large swaths of the population do not consider Catholics to Christians. This is why, for example, my Youth Minister was not allowed on our areas council for youth religious leads. The grounds were that the council was for Christians, not pagans.
4588686 Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 (edited) I'm not denying that, at times, conservative Catholics do face mild alienation from segments of the population. That is certainly true. What I find obnoxious is the attempt to draw a strong analogue between this mild alienation and the homophobia and legal discrimination that many gay people face today. Edited March 6, 2014 by Hasan
NotreDame Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 I'm not denying that, at times, conservative Catholics do face mild alienation from segments of the population. That is certainly true. What I find obnoxious is the attempt to draw a strong analogue between this mild alienation and the homophobia and legal discrimination that many gay people face today. I need to find a new word for tedious... or you could just quit making me use it.
blazeingstar Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 I'm not denying that, at times, conservative Catholics do face mild alienation from segments of the population. That is certainly true. What I find obnoxious is the attempt to draw a strong analogue between this mild alienation and the homophobia and legal discrimination that many gay people face today. Except for in my workplace ---and the 3-5 that I've been in homosexuality is openly embraced, all insurance and educational benefits are offered to said couples. What is not acceptable is religion and the practice of which, except for maybe the one "cool" person who follows Islam. Christianity is seen as the product of a delusional, childish mind and Catholics are the cream of the crop as not only are they childish, but they "believe" in childabuse and male oppression. You haven't even commented on the few incidence that I have offered....and the fact still is that the snarkiness in the south and their disbelief that Catholics are Christians is not similar at all to the way that things are. Perhaps things are not so bad in the south. However, in the very liberal Northeast things are different. And just a point of fact, that the Governor of NY has openly attacked Catholic belifs and called them radical....like anti-abortion, anti-gay marriage and pro-wepon and told them that they have no place in NY. Really, when you say that Catholics "only face" mild alienation, you sound ignorant of the many things that are going on in the northeast and all over the United States. Things have gotten worse in the past decade or so, in particular the past 5 years.
CrossCuT Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 ... not like the title of the thread was already a reference to another topic or anything... :whistle: :hehe2:
beatitude Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 I'm not denying that, at times, conservative Catholics do face mild alienation from segments of the population. That is certainly true. What I find obnoxious is the attempt to draw a strong analogue between this mild alienation and the homophobia and legal discrimination that many gay people face today. Last week I was at a radical feminist conference where I spoke on a panel on women and religion. The panel proceeding mine was led by a group of lesbian asylum seekers who had become refugees on account of their sexuality and were now speaking of the discrimination (both homophobic and racist) they now experience in their place of refuge. One of them was a woman whom our group had successfully clawed back from a deportation flight only a few weeks ago. We had women flooding the airline with e-mails and phone calls about the danger she would be in back in her home country, and when the Border Agency officials conducted her to the aircraft the airline personnel refused to take her on board. To my surprise, tears came leaking out of my eyes when I heard that the flight had left without her, because I honestly hadn't expected the protest to do anything. I have never felt relief like that, or elation - the sensation that awful stuff happens but sometimes you can actually do something to stop it. Last week she stood in front of our group and talked about how the (male) officials processing her asylum case had demanded video footage of her and her girlfriend having sex to 'prove' that she was a real lesbian. They will accept this as evidence where they won't accept testimony from community groups. Hers isn't an isolated case. Desperate refugee women are being exploited by certain officials to provide porn, basically - and as she pointed out, it is only possible for them to do this because the social climate makes it possible. It occurs to me that if there had been an outcry as vocal as the outcry against gay marriage, this might not be happening. Then it was time for my panel, and I spoke about my experiences as a Catholic feminist, as I had been invited to do. Many of the women in that room were very anti-Catholic (including a fellow panelist, an ex-Catholic turned atheist). I did not feel hugely welcome, but at least I was there, speaking - at the invitation of the atheist organiser, no less. Sometimes it is uncomfortable for me to speak but no one is muffling my voice. Sometimes the snap judgments that people make are hurtful and unfair. But no government gatekeeper is asking me to degrade and demean myself in order to 'prove' what I am so that I will be entitled to basic safety. That is the difference. It staggers me when people don't see it. I have had sneering remarks about my ashes before. I'll live.
Luigi Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 ... not like the title of the thread was already a reference to another topic or anything... :whistle: She started her own thread rather than hijacking someone else's thread to focus on herself. that's the way you're supposed to do it.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now