blazeingstar Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 Last week I was at a radical feminist conference where I spoke on a panel on women and religion. The panel proceeding mine was led by a group of lesbian asylum seekers who had become refugees on account of their sexuality and were now speaking of the discrimination (both homophobic and racist) they now experience in their place of refuge. One of them was a woman whom our group had successfully clawed back from a deportation flight only a few weeks ago. We had women flooding the airline with e-mails and phone calls about the danger she would be in back in her home country, and when the Border Agency officials conducted her to the aircraft the airline personnel refused to take her on board. To my surprise, tears came leaking out of my eyes when I heard that the flight had left without her, because I honestly hadn't expected the protest to do anything. I have never felt relief like that, or elation - the sensation that awful stuff happens but sometimes you can actually do something to stop it. Last week she stood in front of our group and talked about how the (male) officials processing her asylum case had demanded video footage of her and her girlfriend having sex to 'prove' that she was a real lesbian. They will accept this as evidence where they won't accept testimony from community groups. Hers isn't an isolated case. Desperate refugee women are being exploited by certain officials to provide porn, basically - and as she pointed out, it is only possible for them to do this because the social climate makes it possible. It occurs to me that if there had been an outcry as vocal as the outcry against gay marriage, this might not be happening. Then it was time for my panel, and I spoke about my experiences as a Catholic feminist, as I had been invited to do. Many of the women in that room were very anti-Catholic (including a fellow panelist, an ex-Catholic turned atheist). I did not feel hugely welcome, but at least I was there, speaking - at the invitation of the atheist organiser, no less. Sometimes it is uncomfortable for me to speak but no one is muffling my voice. Sometimes the snap judgments that people make are hurtful and unfair. But no government gatekeeper is asking me to degrade and demean myself in order to 'prove' what I am so that I will be entitled to basic safety. That is the difference. It staggers me when people don't see it. I have had sneering remarks about my ashes before. I'll live. I'm sorry that those women faced that. However, There are plenty of CHRISTIANS who cannot be Christian in today's world. I am very close to the immigrant community from Indonesia. They are in a very hard spot being in the northeast as they are seen as dirty, unwanted, and even with a master's degree in a needed occupation have trouble getting work. But, as my friend's mom states it's better than death. My friend often cries beucase all she wants is to go back to visit...not to stay..but to hold her cousin in her arms. However, even FB communication has to be minimal Again, to claim that only homosexuals face this treatment is very nieve and uneducated. There are hundreds of thousands of persecuted Christians in the world...if we want to talk about the global persecution of peoples.
beatitude Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 I'm sorry that those women faced that. However, There are plenty of CHRISTIANS who cannot be Christian in today's world. I am very close to the immigrant community from Indonesia. They are in a very hard spot being in the northeast as they are seen as dirty, unwanted, and even with a master's degree in a needed occupation have trouble getting work. But, as my friend's mom states it's better than death. My friend often cries beucase all she wants is to go back to visit...not to stay..but to hold her cousin in her arms. However, even FB communication has to be minimal Again, to claim that only homosexuals face this treatment is very nieve and uneducated. There are hundreds of thousands of persecuted Christians in the world...if we want to talk about the global persecution of peoples. I didn't claim that only gay people face this treatment. I am involved with Aid to the Church in Need and various other Christian groups in the Middle East (and for what it's worth, I think they would raise a few eyebrows at the things that Catholics on Phatmass try to construe as persecution or suffering). I am not trying to set up some kind of competition between gay people worldwide and Christians worldwide (not least because I am aware that gay Christians exist). I gave specific examples of female refugees being asked to provide pornography for the titillation of male officials as an example of how homophobia in this society compounds an already precarious situation. I also feel quite confident that a post about the hardships faced by persecuted Christians wouldn't lead people here to immediately start mentioning other persecuted groups. Any of the threads about gay experiences on Phatmass, however, seem to very quickly devolve into, "But my workplace is so liberal and gay people get insurance benefits and people say mean things about Catholicism!" or, as in this case, spark an alternative 'coming out' thread. Why is it impossible to face up to discrimination against gay people without having to add qualifiers?
blazeingstar Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 (edited) I didn't claim that only gay people face this treatment. I am involved with Aid to the Church in Need and various other Christian groups in the Middle East (and for what it's worth, I think they would raise a few eyebrows at the things that Catholics on Phatmass try to construe as persecution or suffering). I am not trying to set up some kind of competition between gay people worldwide and Christians worldwide (not least because I am aware that gay Christians exist). I gave specific examples of female refugees being asked to provide pornography for the titillation of male officials as an example of how homophobia in this society compounds an already precarious situation. I also feel quite confident that a post about the hardships faced by persecuted Christians wouldn't lead people here to immediately start mentioning other persecuted groups. Any of the threads about gay experiences on Phatmass, however, seem to very quickly devolve into, "But my workplace is so liberal and gay people get insurance benefits and people say mean things about Catholicism!" or, as in this case, spark an alternative 'coming out' thread. Why is it impossible to face up to discrimination against gay people without having to add qualifiers? I didn't say what was happening there was right, but just that there is very real elements of persecution to those in the US who identify with a religion, and very real hatred. FYI there are many female religious communities in the united states that have a soft ban on airline travel for their sisters because of several demeaning and disgusting TSA incidents where they were overtly sexualized. No, not the same as porn, but again, a very scary thing for any sister, young or old. It's because that in general, in most of the northeast homosexuals are NOT persecuted, but rather welcomed. It's because a photographer CAN say that they will not do Catholic weddings but cannot say they will not do homosexual weddings. I know, I've been shopping for wedding photographers. Many refuse to shoot inside a Catholic Church because of their beliefs....yet there have been several Catholic/Christian photographers run out of business because they don't want to shoot a homosexual civil ceremony. Why is that ok? I'm pretty sure that'd define the Christian/Catholics as the persecuted ones, not the homosexuals. I'm sorry that you fail to see that this isn't just a big boo-boo and hurt feelings, but a deeper tide. Catholics were called extremists for their BASIC beliefs towards life and liberty and told they had no place in New York State. I mean, really? That's ok with you? The governor of the state saying that Catholics don't belong there? Just because a politician from another state said something about homosexuals dosn't mean we don't have a REAL problem. Quite frankly, in some places it is a big deal to make it known that one is a practicing Catholic...and it can be very intimidating when they have been demonized. Edited March 6, 2014 by blazeingstar
Lilllabettt Posted March 6, 2014 Author Posted March 6, 2014 I have had sneering remarks about my ashes before. I'll live. So. That's ignorant. I wonder if anyone has ever responded to your struggle that way. "You'll live." Isn't that edifying. Honestly, the level of arrogance and lack of awareness required to mock another person's experience is astonishing. This is the special compassion and tolerance of liberal kool-aid. But drink down ideology of any kind and you will spout forth nonsense with zero whiff of irony. Micro-aggression of the day Guy reading autobio aloud: "My parents are a contradiction. Basically good and loving, yet adhering catholics."
Lilllabettt Posted March 6, 2014 Author Posted March 6, 2014 Never mind --- the Boss propped my OP, my day is made. All nanny goats feel free to spin your wheels.
NotreDame Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 Beatitude / Blazingstar... It's funny to see you two arguing because when I go through threads quickly it's tough to tell you apart because your names both start with "B" and you both have sunsets as your profile pics. I always need to take a double-take to be sure who is who.
beatitude Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 (edited) So. That's ignorant. I wonder if anyone has ever responded to your struggle that way. "You'll live." Isn't that edifying. Honestly, the level of arrogance and lack of awareness required to mock another person's experience is astonishing. I compared the sneering I experienced for wearing ashes to the situations of other women who have literally faced the possibility of death (and still are facing it, should they be deported). It's true enough. Nasty as specific people's unkindness can be to deal with, I will live. With the title of your thread you are clearly encouraging people to draw a parallel between your experiences of going to campus with an ashen cross on your forehead and the experiences that Fran spoke about recently - the damage and pain that being closeted in her church community did to her, the fear of rejection in the place that matters to her most. For a hardly insignificant number of gay people, 'coming out' can mean no longer being welcome in their homes or even being left homeless. It seems to take a great lack of awareness to insinuate, as you have with the title of this thread, that your experiences of going to class with the ashen cross are remotely comparable. Whether it's arrogant or not, I don't know. I'm not in your head, I can't see your reasons for making a conflation, I am not about to pass judgment on your motives. However, I do find it irritating that you seem to want to use any post that doesn't accept/endorse the comparison as proof that you're this misunderstood martyr. This is the special compassion and tolerance of liberal kool-aid. But drink down ideology of any kind and you will spout forth nonsense with zero whiff of irony. I don't know what this means. Edited March 6, 2014 by beatitude
FutureCarmeliteClaire Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 (edited) http://imgur.com/wvqKwVW Edited: because for some reason I can't post a direct image. Edited March 6, 2014 by FutureCarmeliteClaire
blazeingstar Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 I compared the sneering I experienced for wearing ashes to the situations of two other women, one of whom has literally faced the possibility of death (and still is facing it, should she be deported). It's true enough. Nasty as specific people's unkindness can be to deal with, I will live. With the title of your thread you are clearly encouraging people to draw a parallel between your experiences of going to campus with an ashen cross on your forehead to the experiences that Fran spoke about recently - the damage and pain that being closeted in her church community did to her, the fear of rejection in the place that matters to her most. For a hardly insignificant number of gay people, 'coming out' can mean no longer being welcome in their homes or even being left homeless. It seems to take a great lack of awareness to insinuate, as you have with the title of this thread, that your experiences of going to class with the ashen cross are remotely comparable. Whether it's arrogant or not, I don't know. I'm not in your head, I can't see your reasons for making a conflation, I am not about to pass judgment on your motives. However, I do find it irritating that you seem to want to use any post that doesn't endorse your comparison as proof that you're this misunderstood martyr. I don't know what this means. First off, I didn't start the thread, nor did I get ashes. I don't think that people "misunderstand" Catholics/Christians at all, they know exactly what we stand for, and they unequivocally hate it. Just wanted to mention about immigration--I checked with my cousin...for a heterosexual couple without a child who's relationship is coming into question, proof of sexual activity is sometimes requested...so it's not *that* unreasonable that it would also be asked of a homosexual couple. Its actually why she's living in Germany with her English husband...she wouldn't do it. It's invasive and horrible and if you don't like it then change the law for ALL couples. Your arrogance is in that you won't see that there are persecuted Christians/Catholics in the world who may still suffer here in the US. As I stated, I have immigrant friends from Indonesia who face death due to their Catholicism in Indonesia, and here in the US face unemployment. However, unemployment is better than death. You also seem to have no idea that becoming Catholic in the bible belt or Morman country can do the EXACT same thing that you are talking about. One of my youth minister friends who married a phillipino only recently (in the past 5 years) has had contact with is evangelical family after he became Catholic decades ago. Do we need to campaign for awareness of that? I was very involved and loved my first workplace, I had great friends who I ate lunch with every day, and even did things with on the weekends....however after 2 years of great relationship and keeping my conservative beliefs to myself, it suddenly got out that I was a practicing Catholic. Then and there I lost those friends and life was never the same at that job. So yes, I get it, and yes, it does happen. So tell me, ye keeper of who can have what emotions, how that is any different than what happened to Fran. Because I can "change" being Catholic...well no, quite frankly, I can't I'm Baptized and Confirmed...I can "feel" I'm not Catholic or convince myself I'm not, but I always will be Catholic, so I choose to live those beliefs...and take the consequences of them. I am not declaring proof that I'm a maryter but that there is a growing tide of anti-Christian, Anti-catholic behavior. That it IS acceptible in New York for the acting GOVERNOR to say that Catholics are not welcome in his state, and that it is acceptable for photographers to deny Catholics photography but it is NOT acceptable to do the same to homosexuals. You simply aren't acknowledging the deepening parallel between the intolerance for Christianity/Catholicism and being homosexual.
Anastasia13 Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 It's perfectly possible to be opposed to gay rights for moral reasons. It's just not possible to be opposed to them for any respectable moral reasons. I understand that Catholic argument against gay rights. It's just not anything that ought to be respected. That's why I left the faith. I'm not going to fight to limit somebody else's rights for reasons that I know deep down are farcical. Perhaps you should have considered being a libertarian instead. You can have your Catholic view of homosexual sex and tell the government to get out of people's pants.
CrossCuT Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 (edited) You simply aren't acknowledging the deepening parallel between the intolerance for Christianity/Catholicism and being homosexual. I think its circular. A lot of Catholics/Christians do not tolerate homosexuals, so in turn they are like w t f and then dont tolerate Catholics/Christians. So maybe if we all just started sipping the happy kool-aid we would all be better. I also believe that people are mildly perturbed at the comparison in general which is all Beatitude is saying. You really cant compare the two on the same level. Sorry Edited March 6, 2014 by CrossCuT
Anastasia13 Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 You simply aren't acknowledging the deepening parallel between the intolerance for Christianity/Catholicism and being homosexual. Both can get you killed in Saudi Arabia.
CrossCuT Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 Lilllabettt must just come into contact with a high number of huge [mod]unfriendly pholks (look the fiddler missed something!) - BG[/mod]. I was quite open about my Lenten obligations in my coworker circle and they were totally fine with it.
PhuturePriest Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 Lilllabettt must just come into contact with a high number of huge [mod]unfriendly pholks (look the fiddler missed something!) - BG[/mod]. I was quite open about my Lenten obligations in my coworker circle and they were totally fine with it. She has stated her college is one of the most intolerant universities in the country (As said by her atheist professor).
blazeingstar Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 I think its circular. A lot of Catholics/Christians do not tolerate homosexuals, so in turn they are like w t f and then dont tolerate Catholics/Christians. So maybe if we all just started sipping the happy kool-aid we would all be better. I also believe that people are mildly perturbed at the comparison in general which is all Beatitude is saying. You really cant compare the two on the same level. Sorry Umm yeah, you can. The GOVERNOR of a state said that Catholics are not welcome, yet no firestorm on him. In New England there are publcized cases of photograhers going out of business for not shooting homosexual weddings/families, however, there are numerous photographers who won't shoot Catholic weddings because of their beliefs. Why is it sad that lesbians could be killed for being sent back to their home country, but not Catholics? The fact is, that ateast in my part of the country, it is becoming hostile. It is sad that you won't accept that. Your ignorance won't really affect my life. It won't affect the fact that my friend has a hard time in the grocery store with her 5 children even when they are perfect angels because people call her nasty names and mock her. (saying things in front of her children like she has a freeway vagina or that "its not a clown car, it's a uterus") It doesn't change the fact that people in the office regularly degrade and mock Catholics, it dosn't change reality for my co-worker who was harassed out of the office for simply being a member of a local baptist church that protested gay marriage, your opinion of how "easy" we're treated really has nothing to do with my reality. So great, I'm glad you live in such a happy, innocent world. So great. Thats how you want to see things.
Maggyie Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 She has stated her college is one of the most intolerant universities in the country (As said by her atheist professor). It's also one of the best in the country, so keep in mind these people will be heavily involved in running society (specifically, our education system) in the decades to come.
beatitude Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 First off, I have been involved with refugee and asylum rights for years. Never, never have I come across a single case of a heterosexual couple being pressured into providing porn so that their asylum case might be processed. With heterosexual couples, letters from well-respected members of the community testifying to the couple's relationship will suffice. This also isn't about 'immigration', it is about asylum. Vulnerable women whose lives are often on the line are being asked by male officials to hand over these tapes when they're alone in a strange place, they have no family (or their family may have harmed them), they may not understand their legal rights properly, they may not speak the language, they have nowhere to turn. Your earlier comparison between this disgusting coercion and nuns being harassed by the TSA, and now between this and the experiences heterosexual immigrant couples, is example of exactly the kind of comparison and equivocation that staggers me so much. It is not the same, especially as these lesbian asylum seekers don't exactly have the option to skip off to Germany to live there instead, and their lives are at risk. Your arrogance is in that you won't see that there are persecuted Christians/Catholics in the world who may still suffer here in the US. As I stated, I have immigrant friends from Indonesia who face death due to their Catholicism in Indonesia, and here in the US face unemployment. However, unemployment is better than death. Are they unemployed for no other reason than that they're Catholics? You also seem to have no idea that becoming Catholic in the bible belt or Morman country can do the EXACT same thing that you are talking about. One of my youth minister friends who married a phillipino only recently (in the past 5 years) has had contact with is evangelical family after he became Catholic decades ago. Do we need to campaign for awareness of that? Was he kicked out on the streets by his family with nowhere to go? If so, then yes, we certainly do need to campaign for awareness around this. The fact is that there are homeless shelters specifically for LGBT youth for this very reason, and those shelters are always packed to the rafters. An evangelical family might disown their Catholic offspring, but this is not such a huge phenomenon that we need emergency shelters to help Catholic kids and young adults who have nowhere else to sleep. I was very involved and loved my first workplace, I had great friends who I ate lunch with every day, and even did things with on the weekends....however after 2 years of great relationship and keeping my conservative beliefs to myself, it suddenly got out that I was a practicing Catholic. Then and there I lost those friends and life was never the same at that job. So yes, I get it, and yes, it does happen. So tell me, ye keeper of who can have what emotions, how that is any different than what happened to Fran. Because I can "change" being Catholic...well no, quite frankly, I can't I'm Baptized and Confirmed...I can "feel" I'm not Catholic or convince myself I'm not, but I always will be Catholic, so I choose to live those beliefs...and take the consequences of them. I have never tried to say who can have what emotions. I have criticised the comparisons that people make on the basis of those emotions. There is a difference. There is a glaring difference between the two situations you're comparing here, and one that anyone who values their faith should be able to see - feeling frightened of rejection in your workplace is not the same as feeling frightened of rejection in your spiritual home, which all of us should be able to turn to as our rock and our anchor no matter what the situation elsewhere, including our workplaces. I am sorry that you lost friends among your coworkers, it's a horrible upsetting experience to have, but no, it's not the same as facing hostility in the place that matters most to you in the entire world and that you want to be a part of until you die. If you are rejected in your workplace, you can expect support from the Catholic faithful. You can take it for granted. If a gay Catholic is rejected in the workplace, they might not be able to take it for granted that the people in the parish will be backing them - if they even dare to talk about it there. I am not declaring proof that I'm a maryter but that there is a growing tide of anti-Christian, Anti-catholic behavior. That it IS acceptible in New York for the acting GOVERNOR to say that Catholics are not welcome in his state, and that it is acceptable for photographers to deny Catholics photography but it is NOT acceptable to do the same to homosexuals. Could you please provide an example of one photographer (you have said there are 'many', so a few names and details shouldn't be difficult to provide) who has denied their services to a Catholic wedding on the grounds that they don't believe in serving Catholics? If such a photographer exists, then it would be perfectly possible to sue them and win under anti-discrimination laws. The NY governor made no mention of Catholics. The phrase he used was 'extreme conservative Republicans'. He still shouldn't have said what he said, but it's hardly an example of him singling out Catholics. It's an example of nasty partisan attitudes. When we need those homelessness shelters for Catholic youth, we can talk about the 'deepening parallel' between discrimination against gay people and intolerance of Catholics. (It's also worth noting that intolerance and discrimination aren't the same thing - discriminating against you as a Catholic in that workplace would have meant them finding pretexts to sack you or make you leave.) Right now the parallel isn't there. I am sure most of us could think of times when we've faced unkindness over our Catholicism, but this doesn't mean that all of us are keen to play Oppression Olympics with gay people, who until relatively recently had their sexuality listed as a mental disorder and even classified as illegal.
NotreDame Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 Lilllabettt must just come into contact with a high number of huge [mod]How many of you quoted this post anyhow? This is a pain to edit.-BG[/mod]. I was quite open about my Lenten obligations in my coworker circle and they were totally fine with it. If you are on the coasts, especially in urban communities, you run into what Lillabet and I run into. If you've never lived in those areas or worked around this set, then what she (and I occasionally describe) might seem very foreign to you. I know that if you are in/from Texas, Kansas, or Oklahoma, you'll probably have a different experience.
Aloysius Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 as far as Luigi's retort to what BG perceived as my snarkiness but was really just my oh-so-cleverness, I was of course just pointing out that this thread definitely was about this topic from the beginning. anyway, there is definitely alienation and non-acceptance that comes with being an Orthodox Catholic in today's society, no question. but as we discovered on another thread, drawing comparisons between wholly different kinds of alienation/discrimination tends to rustle some jimmies, and rustle them good. we should not be dismissive of anyone's struggles (Oh no, I used the word dismissive, I might have to use that thirty more times before this thread is over!), but we should also be very careful about the analogies we draw about them. just remember, anytime you feel persecuted, derided, alienated or ridiculed because of your faith, Our Lord told you to rejoice for that. of course we should also work to stop that from happening, the increasing hostility towards orthodox Catholicism is troubling, though at the risk of unhelpful comparisons, I don't think it's quite "as bad" as it was. say. for Catholics in Ireland for hundreds of years, for black people in the civil rights era, or for homosexuals now. but that doesn't matter, these comparisons don't matter, the fact that people are being shunned or discriminated against for their religion is awful. unfortunately many people can't see any distance between the Church's view of homosexuality and the views of hateful people like the Westboro Baptists, etc, which is why they get hostile because they don't see those distinctions that are extremely important, and are caught up in these culture wars getting just as heated and worked up at moments when they shouldn't (such as when seeing ashes on your forehead) as any diehard culture warrior who refuses to say Happy Holidays. It is great that you are not afraid to wear your ashes and let everyone know your faith at work even though you are ridiculed, derided, or alienated. perhaps that fellow undercover Catholic you met will be inspired.
NotreDame Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 Both can get you killed in Saudi Arabia. This is a very good point. Nobody has persecuted homosexuals more than marxism, facism and islam. Homosexuals historically have been the safest in the cradle of western civilization with it's Christianity and belief in the individual. It's only the freedom offered from our Christian cultures that has allowed them to be this out in the open in the first place.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now