Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Do You Have Food Neophobia?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Excellent. The both of you are literally perfect in every conceivable way, and should be canonized no later than immediately. I will contact Cardinal Amato post-haste.

 

When did I ever say we were perfect?  I even said we only scored a 97%, which, mathematically is not perfect.   Or maybe you're doing common core math.  In that case, 100% is perfect, 97% is not. Kapash?  

 

We've come to a workable conclusion.  One dosn't have to be perfect to do that.  Just saying that I in no way feel unprepared or undeserving of marriage because of my opinions on the matter.

 

And obvously, much to other poster's chagrin, I am married while they who do everything "perfectly" are not.  Oh well.

Posted

Welp, if someone maintains that they are not going to change, have no need to change, and that everyone should be ok with that proposal, it does tend to imply certain conclusions.

Posted

Welp, if someone maintains that they are not going to change, have no need to change, and that everyone should be ok with that proposal, it does tend to imply certain conclusions.

 

So I'm supposed to go around changing so I'l be "more perfect"....yeah, I'll skip it.  I've gotten to where I am by being exactly who I am.  Perfection has nothing to do with the way I live, it dosn't really enter my mind on a day to day basis.  Not wanting/feeling the need to change has nothing to do with perfection for me, and everything to do with simply not needing to change and ensuring I get things my way.

Posted

So I'm supposed to go around changing so I'l be "more perfect"....yeah, I'll skip it.  I've gotten to where I am by being exactly who I am.  Perfection has nothing to do with the way I live, it dosn't really enter my mind on a day to day basis.  Not wanting/feeling the need to change has nothing to do with perfection for me, and everything to do with simply not needing to change and ensuring I get things my way.

So then we are right back where we started. In my opinion this is not really an appropriate attitude. And yes, of course you do not care, no need to say it.

Posted

So then we are right back where we started. In my opinion this is not really an appropriate attitude. And yes, of course you do not care, no need to say it.

 

LOL, I just find it vastly amusing how you can't seem to accept that my attitude works for me.  I'm glad that you're not running the world else I wouldn't of been able to even think about marriage, never mind be married and waiting to have children.

Posted

LOL, I just find it vastly amusing how you can't seem to accept that my attitude works for me. I'm glad that you're not running the world else I wouldn't of been able to even think about marriage, never mind be married and waiting to have children.

Lots of bad things 'work' on a practical level. Politics and business prove that well enough. An honest practice of our faith requires that we go far deeper than that.
Posted

Lots of bad things 'work' on a practical level. Politics and business prove that well enough. An honest practice of our faith requires that we go far deeper than that.

 

LOL

 

Well, you do what works for you, I'll do what works for me.  I think your view of things is rather narrow and limited to only what you believe.  You can't seem to fathom how I choose to live my life, how I work with my husband, or how I plan to raise children.  I'm sure you probably have some belief that this will preclude me getting into Heaven....which I find amusing in itself.  I figure that God knows who I am, I give Him his due and we're all hunky dory at the end of the day.

Posted

So I'm supposed to go around changing so I'l be "more perfect"....yeah, I'll skip it.

 

Umm.... yes. As a matter of fact everyone is called to go around changing to be more perfect. It's called growing in holiness and virtue.

Posted

LOL

Well, you do what works for you, I'll do what works for me. I think your view of things is rather narrow and limited to only what you believe. You can't seem to fathom how I choose to live my life, how I work with my husband, or how I plan to raise children. I'm sure you probably have some belief that this will preclude me getting into Heaven....which I find amusing in itself. I figure that God knows who I am, I give Him his due and we're all hunky dory at the end of the day.

You project a heck of a lot.
Posted

I should add, that growing in holiness and virtue heavily involves daily menial tasks like parenting, preparing meals, household chores, work, and family intimacy. It's certainly not limited to prayer life, spiritual reading, and the liturgy.

PhuturePriest
Posted

I should add, that growing in holiness and virtue heavily involves daily menial tasks like parenting, preparing meals, household chores, work, and family intimacy. It's certainly not limited to prayer life, spiritual reading, and the liturgy.

 

Forgive me, but it seems as if you are suggesting your spiritual life applies to everything you do, and that is quite simply crazy talk. Catholicism is for Sundays, fool.

Posted

No, it doesn't. But there is a difference between a picky eater and a phobic eater. 

 

Think of your worst fear. Spiders, heights, clowns, dUSt, whatever. That fear, anxiety, stress, panic is exactly what I feel when faced with 90% of foods. I've had tantrums even as a teenager because my mother said "eat this" and I physically cannot make myself do it anymore than I could pick up a tarantula. My parents tried the "eat or you starve" thing and I would just starve. A picky eater would eventually eat out of hunger. A phobic eater wouldn't. Phobias are by nature irrational and it's a very powerful thing. There's a huge difference between picky eating and phobic eating that hasn't been acknowledged much until recently - sadly there's a lot of ignorance and unfair judgement still, as evidenced by some people in this thread. 

 

sorry, I didn't mean to be dismissive. I just don't know if it helps for everything to be classified as a disorder. It's also weird to me I guess that it's called a phobia. Are you actually afraid of the food, or of eating the food? Can other people eat those foods around you?

 

I also wonder how much our society contributes to these disorders. For example, are there people who live in slums that suffer from OCD and contamination fears? I wonder how such a phobia may arise in the case of food, and if there's typically a comorbid disorder involved. I know a bit about psychological disorders.

 

maybe its classification as a phobia is also weird to me. Doesn't jive with what I've learned about phobias.

Posted

Well, you do what works for you, I'll do what works for me.

 

This is ethical pragmatism in a nutshell, and "ethical pragmatism" is just an industrial-sounding name for moral relativism.

 

So, yes:

 

 

 

I'm sure you probably have some belief that this will preclude me getting into Heaven....

 

...because moral relativism by any name is objectively wrong, according to the Church, every pope who ever lived, Jesus, God, and everyone else worth listening to (including Nihil).

Posted

Forgive me, but it seems as if you are suggesting your spiritual life applies to everything you do, and that is quite simply crazy talk. Catholicism is for Sundays, fool.

 

Nice way to lighten the mood, FP. ;)

 

sorry, I didn't mean to be dismissive. I just don't know if it helps for everything to be classified as a disorder. It's also weird to me I guess that it's called a phobia. Are you actually afraid of the food, or of eating the food? Can other people eat those foods around you?

 

I also wonder how much our society contributes to these disorders. For example, are there people who live in slums that suffer from OCD and contamination fears? I wonder how such a phobia may arise in the case of food, and if there's typically a comorbid disorder involved. I know a bit about psychological disorders.

 

maybe its classification as a phobia is also weird to me. Doesn't jive with what I've learned about phobias.

 

I understand this. Personally, it's not a fear of the food, but of having to put it into my body, of having to feel it in my mouth. Imagine people who are asked to eat while blindfolded, then eat some wretched eight-legged thing or something, and finally are told what they just ate. It's not uncommon for someone to vomit if the animal they consumed is strongly taboo as a food item in their culture/personal psychology.

 

I do understand also the perspective that food phobias (really eating phobias) are absurd, or a "first-world problem". I do very much doubt that such phobias existed back when food was scarce, or that they exist in countries where food is still scarce today. So I do think that they are typically comorbid psychological disorders. My mother used to speculate lots about my eating issues. Her primary theory was that, when my parents divorced, I felt that I lost control over my external environment, so I compensated by exerting extreme control over my internal one (i.e., what went into it and what did not). Since my eating issues began when my parents divorced, that made sense to her.

 

But my parents divorced when I was 4, and around the same time one of my spinster aunts who had no idea how to feed a child shoved a banana down my throat and choked me. So maybe that was the cause. I still can't be in a room with an open banana today without gagging violently.

 

In my experience (and so also in my opinion), my issue is in fact neurological. I think I really don't experience textures the same way others do. But my mother's theory may have some merit, because as I've gotten older and alternately gained more control over my life while also accepting not having control as okay (because of my faith), my eating issues have gotten significantly better. My mother CANNOT BELIEVE many of the things I'll eat today! She still sits at the table with me sometimes and just stares at me while I eat, with wide eyes and mouth agape. LOL.

 

But some issues do remain...

 

I'm glad we're talking about this now in a way that seeks mutual understanding, rather than in a confrontational fashion! Maybe FP's humor was all that was needed. ;)

PhuturePriest
Posted

Maybe FP's humor was all that was needed. ;)

 

This is the most sensible thing that has ever been said on Phatmass.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

When did I ever say we were perfect?  I even said we only scored a 97%, which, mathematically is not perfect.   Or maybe you're doing common core math.  In that case, 100% is perfect, 97% is not. Kapash?  

 

We've come to a workable conclusion.  One dosn't have to be perfect to do that.  Just saying that I in no way feel unprepared or undeserving of marriage because of my opinions on the matter.

 

And obvously, much to other poster's chagrin, I am married while they who do everything "perfectly" are not.  Oh well.

 

Humblebrag, n., v.  

 

1. Subtly letting others now about how fantastic your life is while undercutting it with a bit of self-effacing humor or "woe is me" gloss.

2. To bring up one's accomplishments in conversation and contextualize them as a harrowing burden or the product of an accident or fluke. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

Humblebrag, n., v.  

 

1. Subtly letting others now about how fantastic your life is while undercutting it with a bit of self-effacing humor or "woe is me" gloss.

2. To bring up one's accomplishments in conversation and contextualize them as a harrowing burden or the product of an accident or fluke. 

 

I know pretty much everything I say either directly mentions or somehow relates to Harry Potter, but regardless of doing it once again, I honestly think Gilderoy Lockhart is a perfect example of this. :P

Posted

This is ethical pragmatism in a nutshell, and "ethical pragmatism" is just an industrial-sounding name for moral relativism.

 

So, yes:

 

 

...because moral relativism by any name is objectively wrong, according to the Church, every pope who ever lived, Jesus, God, and everyone else worth listening to (including Nihil).

 

 

And now I'm really laughing.  What a stretch, you're a funny person curiousing.....glad you're so sure of my fate, its hysterical.  Maybe we should just call you Padre Pio

Posted

And now I'm really laughing.  What a stretch, you're a funny person curiousing.....glad you're so sure of my fate, its hysterical.  Maybe we should just call you Padre Pio

 

The superior and condescending tone of your posts is rude and divisive. I do not find heresy—or you—funny. I think you need to examine your conscience with regard to how you speak to others. You turn every thread you enter into an argument from which you appear to invariably emerge righteous in your own mind.

 

I have blocked all your posts so that I can no longer see them, and I sincerely hope that the moderators will take action about your tone.

Posted

sorry, I didn't mean to be dismissive. I just don't know if it helps for everything to be classified as a disorder. It's also weird to me I guess that it's called a phobia. Are you actually afraid of the food, or of eating the food? Can other people eat those foods around you?

 

I also wonder how much our society contributes to these disorders. For example, are there people who live in slums that suffer from OCD and contamination fears? I wonder how such a phobia may arise in the case of food, and if there's typically a comorbid disorder involved. I know a bit about psychological disorders.

 

maybe its classification as a phobia is also weird to me. Doesn't jive with what I've learned about phobias.

 

Speaking for myself, I am afraid of eating the foods. Other people can eat the foods around me, as long as there is no risk of it touching my food - if a food I don't eat touches my food then it's 'contaminated'. I struggle to touch foods I don't eat - I can do it but it's quite stressful. Again, it makes me feel 'contaminated' somehow. 

 

While it would be hard to judge the question you pose with the example of slums and OCD since people living in deprived areas would be unlikely to get any professional help/diagnosis, there are some interesting examples of culture-bound syndromes (fan death is a particular favourite of mine). Food issues can come up due to other problems - OCD and ASD come to mind, but that applies more specifically to avoidant/restrictive food intake disorder (we do have fun naming these things) than to food neophobia. 

 

Since I don't have a copy of the DSM V this is from the DSM-IV TR on specific phobias:

 

 

A. Marked and persistent fear that is excessive or unreasonable, cued by the presence or anticipation of a 

specific object or situation (e.g., flying, heights, animals, receiving an injection, seeing blood). 
B. Exposure to the phobic stimulus almost invariably provokes an immediate anxiety response, which may take 
the form of a situationally bound or situationally predisposed Panic Attack. Note: In children, the anxiety 
may be expressed by crying, tantrums, freezing, or clinging. 
C. The person recognizes that the fear is excessive or unreasonable. Note: In children, this feature may be 
absent. 
D. The phobic situation(s) is avoided or else is endured with intense anxiety or distress. 
E. The avoidance, anxious anticipation, or distress in the feared situation(s) interferes significantly with the 
person's normal routine, occupational (or academic) functioning, or social activities or relationships, or there 
is marked distress about having the phobia. 

 

That definitely fits how I feel about food, and judging from what others who have shared their experiences it fits theirs too. 

 

I think it does help for disordered behaviour to be classified as a disorder when, as the above classification says, causes a significant impediment to normal functioning. I can't describe what a relief it was for me when I discovered that food neophobia was a thing - finally I wasn't just a weirdo, there was a reason and a name for this thing that caused me so much distress. Acknowledging and classifying a problem can help treat it. The problem is that there is a tendency for people to put diagnoses on behaviour that is on the normal spectrum. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...