beatitude Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 (edited) Public denial of Mary as co-redemptrix. In fairness, this isn't a dogma of the Church and there has always been debate and controversy attached to the use of this title among orthodox theologians - even Pope Benedict wouldn't use it. Back when he was Cardinal Ratzinger, he explained, "The formula 'co-redemptrix' departs to too great an extent from the language of Scripture and of the Fathers and therefore gives rise to misunderstandings." In 1996 the Vatican convened a group of theologians to discuss whether to formally define Mary as co-redemptrix, and they unanimously voted against the use of that term for her. I could be wrong and I'm open to correction, but I don't think Nada has really strayed into the fishpond with this one, not when our Pope Emeritus himself won't use that name. I did my Master's in theology and vaguely remember this debate coming up, and it seems to me more to be an issue of terminology rather than a dispute on doctrine - people on both sides of the divide have the same ideas about Mary but they argue over the best words to use. Personally I'm more than happy to invoke Mary as co-redemptrix, but I know that Fr Faber wasn't, and I can't exactly set myself up to be more orthodox than he was... Edited May 22, 2015 by beatitude
NadaTeTurbe Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 On wikipedia they said : In August 1996, a Mariological Congress was held in Czestochowa, Poland, where a commission was established in response to a request of the Holy See. The congress sought the opinion of scholars present there regarding the possibility of proposing a fifth Marian dogma on Mary as Co-Redemptrix, Mediatrix and Advocate. The commission unanimously declared that it was not opportune, voting 23-0 against the proposed dogma I believe that Mary co-operated with Jesus in the salvation of the world, I don't believe she was co-redemptrix, or, more more precisely, that she should be called co-redemptrix because I find this word to be vague and can lead to errors and difficulties in ecumenism, that's why I'm against it. Mariology is a new thing that I am discovering in my EdR, and I find the word co-redemptrix unclear. On wikipedia they quote, and I agree with them that : Pius XII has thus in Munificentissimus Deus, the bull defining the Assumption dogma, used the alternative expression "the revered Mother of God, [...] joined [...] with Jesus Christ in one and the same decree of predestination [...] as the noble associate of the divine Redeemer".[15] And if it don't clear things... it's just a phishy tag, I can live with that and I know forum who are more severe on this
oremus1 Posted May 22, 2015 Author Posted May 22, 2015 everyone has hijacked my thread this is so unfair
Nihil Obstat Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 everyone has hijacked my thread this is so unfair It happens to most threads and typically you just have to deal with it. If you want to bring it back then go ahead. But calling it unfair makes you sound about ten years old.
KnightofChrist Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 Maybe it was but a joke? lol And really how many of us act like 10 year old's daily anyway.
oremus1 Posted May 22, 2015 Author Posted May 22, 2015 On wikipedia they said : And if it don't clear things... it's just a phishy tag, I can live with that and I know forum who are more severe on this I am phishy too. we can be phish phriends. It happens to most threads and typically you just have to deal with it. If you want to bring it back then go ahead. But calling it unfair makes you sound about ten years old. what if I am about ten years old? what would be wrong with that?
Nihil Obstat Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 I am phishy too. we can be phish phriends. what if I am about ten years old? what would be wrong with that? If you are ten years old then you should not be here. And if you are not ten years old, then a comment like that reeks of trolling.
Basilisa Marie Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 That's got to be a joke. Seriously, Mary as co-redemptrix is sketchy theological territory. And by sketchy I mean far too close to and easy to confuse with heresy.
Winchester Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 everyone has hijacked my thread this is so unfair
PhuturePriest Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 Whoa, whoa, whoa. We are all avoiding the MAJOR issue at hand in this thread. Nada, Zayn was by far the weakest member of One Direction. He was way overvalued and sang far too often, much of the time at the expense of not letting the others sing nearly as much as he did. If Niall left? Yeah, I'd be pretty depressed, but this is just Zayn we're talking about here. One Direction will go on just fine without him until someone else inevitably leaves.
NadaTeTurbe Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 I have to disagree here. Zayn had a strong voices what other had not, especially when they began to sing. Now, they are a little better, but still, Zayn have the best voice. Niall is good, yes. Louis and Harry really don't know how to sing. One Direction without Zayn is no longer One Direction. I mean, can you imagine Night Changes without Zayn ? (also, thank you for posting about the Duggars, I did not know them but I'm looking, and wow, this family is amazing)
IgnatiusofLoyola Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 (also, thank you for posting about the Duggars, I did not know them but I'm looking, and wow, this family is amazing) Nada--There are a number of very disturbing stories that have surfaced in the last day about the Duggars. While some of the stories may be exaggerated, most are based on a 1996 police report that has been published in full online. Some names have been deleted from the police report to protect minors, but the Duggar parents are quoted in the police report. Josh Duggar (the oldest son) has admitted wrongdoing, and resigned from his post as executive director of an Evangelical Christian pro-life lobbying organization. There will be no legal prosecution because the alleged acts were committed when Josh was a minor, and the statute of limitations has passed. The Duggars DO indeed need our prayers and are going through a very rough time. Unfortunately, many people have put the Duggars on a pedestal as perfect, and that is always a mistake.
NadaTeTurbe Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 I have read one article, and they said that the father take the son to the police, wich seems honest for me. He resigned from his post. Of course, this is horrible, and I will be praying for all of them. I am researching and reading. As a former victim of sexual abuse, I am all for the truth on this, but, when I volunteered to help victims of sexual abuse, I heard stories about family telling to their 14 years old son who have commit rape that he have done nothing important and he did not need to feel guilt and this kind of things. So, taking your abuser son to the police, is a good step for me. Then, there's the question of the responsability of the TV - do they know ? this is more complicated. I hope this can be used to put a light on abuse of minors. To be more clear, what amaze me, is the idea of a TV reality show about a 19 children family on the TV during a long time. I think it send a strong pro-life message, the message that kids are a positive things. Last time there was a reportage on big family on the TV here. There was a 9 kids family, a 7 kids family, and a 4 kids family. I mean - there is no perfect number of kids, but I come from a 4 children family, and I think that when you are to the point to think that 4 is big and "maybe too much" (according to the presentator), your society have gone too far in the unacceptance of children. I think that a society who is able to have a TV show about a 19 children family, is a society in wich you can hope for.
PhuturePriest Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 I have to disagree here. Zayn had a strong voices what other had not, especially when they began to sing. Now, they are a little better, but still, Zayn have the best voice. Niall is good, yes. Louis and Harry really don't know how to sing. One Direction without Zayn is no longer One Direction. I mean, can you imagine Night Changes without Zayn ? (also, thank you for posting about the Duggars, I did not know them but I'm looking, and wow, this family is amazing) Night Changes would be much better without Zayn's voice, in my opinion. But One Direction is not the hill I want to die on, so we'll just have to let this one go. They are a very amazing family. I've been watching them for years, and I am very impressed with them. This whole situation is very sad, and unfortunately people are all too happy that they finally have some dirt on the Duggars.
PhuturePriest Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 (edited) I have read one article, and they said that the father take the son to the police, wich seems honest for me. He resigned from his post. Of course, this is horrible, and I will be praying for all of them. I am researching and reading. As a former victim of sexual abuse, I am all for the truth on this, but, when I volunteered to help victims of sexual abuse, I heard stories about family telling to their 14 years old son who have commit rape that he have done nothing important and he did not need to feel guilt and this kind of things. So, taking your abuser son to the police, is a good step for me. Then, there's the question of the responsability of the TV - do they know ? this is more complicated. I hope this can be used to put a light on abuse of minors. To be more clear, what amaze me, is the idea of a TV reality show about a 19 children family on the TV during a long time. I think it send a strong pro-life message, the message that kids are a positive things. Last time there was a reportage on big family on the TV here. There was a 9 kids family, a 7 kids family, and a 4 kids family. I mean - there is no perfect number of kids, but I come from a 4 children family, and I think that when you are to the point to think that 4 is big and "maybe too much" (according to the presentator), your society have gone too far in the unacceptance of children. I think that a society who is able to have a TV show about a 19 children family, is a society in wich you can hope for. Do you have some way I can email you? I tried to message you, but because of your phishy tag I can't. If you're not comfortable posting your email you can just email me at gilansapprentice@gmail.com Edited May 22, 2015 by PhuturePriest
IgnatiusofLoyola Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 (edited) Nada--First off, the police report is from 2006, not 1996. Sorry about that. As you continue to read, the story is very complicated. Yes, the father reported his son to the police, but waited a year to do so. Also, the police officer to whom the father reported did not submit a report to police officials. (This police officer is now in jail on child pornography charges, completely unrelated to this.) From what I have read, the case could have been handled better. As FP posted, some people are happy to finally have "dirt" on the Duggars. I also see a lot of people feeling very disappointed with both the Duggars and the TV network their reality show is broadcast on, because they feel that the Duggars have presented themselves, and have been presented by the network, as "perfect," when they are not. The whole situation is very complicated and sad. Edited May 22, 2015 by IgnatiusofLoyola
NadaTeTurbe Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 Phuture Priest, I emailed you. Ignatius : ... Sad story. Sad because of the child molestation case, sad because it will be used to make generalization about christian big families.
PhuturePriest Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 Phuture Priest, I emailed you. Ignatius : ... Sad story. Sad because of the child molestation case, sad because it will be used to make generalization about christian big families. The thing is, these things happened so long ago and were already handled so there really is no reason to dig this up. The only purpose of it was to make the Duggars look bad, which is very low on behalf of whoever did it. Could it have been handled better? Possibly, but very few people know what to do in these situations, and they handled it to the best of their ability. And, as you said, Josh went himself to confess these things at a police station, and whether that officer decided to report it or not is on the officer, not Josh or the family. They made sure that everyone received counseling, and made Josh leave for three months so everyone could have some time to sort everything out and begin to feel comfortable again.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now