Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Also, this little back and forth...

 

 

Catholic Memes pre-conclave:

601521_167293856753698_1309158818_n.jpg

 

The Jesuit Post:

 

1846_544431528921924_1770430315_n.jpg

 

 

 

aand Catholic Memes after the election of Francis..

"Told you so"

72489_169785039837913_2123080994_n.jpg

 

 

Edited by BigJon16
Posted

dude, that doesn't need its own thread.  I think when one looks into it closely it appears he was highly resistant towards Summorum Pontificum and his liturgical sense is far different than Benedict's; however, it also appears that he was actually in the same camp as Ratzinger in the 2005 conclave and when the camps had the clear sense that the camp Ratzinger was in was going to win, they threw their weight behind Bergoglio hoping to sway that whole camp.

 

I'm actually getting the sense that he's going to strongly focus on Rome itself, and be very hands off throughout most of the world.  A few things I'm reading about him seem to indicate that's the kind of ecclesiological position he'd prefer, so for better or worse you'll probably get it, it'll be a good thing if he actually does intensely focus on Rome and the curia and tries to clean it out, but we will likely see a more loose dealing with the rest of the world... which means Summorum Pontificum isn't going to be dismantled, but it's unlikely to be enforced by a heavy hand... not that that was happening anyway.

 

Anyway, I don't see a real reason to run around trying to sound some kind of alarm on what he did with SP in Buenos Aires.  Making a note of it, and discussing it in light of what do we think the future of the SP liturgical direction will be is certainly a worthwhile endeavor, and in such an endeavor we ought to be realistic about Bergoglio's history, I'm certainly all for being realistic and getting to know him as well as we can realistically so we can get a sense of what direction he's likely to be leading us (always allowing for the fact that the papacy can change a man), but there are many mixed signs from him that have generated far too many overly simplistic alarms being sounded.

 

on a sad note, I think Marini's days as Papal liturgist are numbered.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I have grown quite fond of Monsignor Marini over the years. I hope his career is very fruitful.

Posted

dude, that doesn't need its own thread.  I think when one looks into it closely it appears he was highly resistant towards Summorum Pontificum and his liturgical sense is far different than Benedict's; however, it also appears that he was actually in the same camp as Ratzinger in the 2005 conclave and when the camps had the clear sense that the camp Ratzinger was in was going to win, they threw their weight behind Bergoglio hoping to sway that whole camp.

 

Actually there is a lot of discussion on the Catholic-blogosphere over the status of the TLM in Buenos Aires. Many recent threads sought to ease concerns by mentioning that then Cardinal Bergoglio had permitted the TLM 48 hours after Summorum Pontificum, however when you look into the details you realize it wasn't a TLM but a hybrid Latin mass. Like I said, big disucssion on most parts of the Catholic net but in others it may be a sensitive topic.

 

Anyway, I don't see a real reason to run around trying to sound some kind of alarm on what he did with SP in Buenos Aires. Making a note of it, and discussing it in light of what do we think the future of the SP liturgical direction will be is certainly a worthwhile endeavor, and in such an endeavor we ought to be realistic about Bergoglio's history, I'm certainly all for being realistic and getting to know him as well as we can realistically so we can get a sense of what direction he's likely to be leading us (always allowing for the fact that the papacy can change a man), but there are many mixed signs from him that have generated far too many overly simplistic alarms being sounded.

 

Well brother, we study history so we can predict the future. There are clear enough patterns to know where we are headed. That's all I'm saying, don't mean to offend anyone because of it.

 

on a sad note, I think Marini's days as Papal liturgist are numbered.

 

Oh c'mon now Aloysius! The signals are mixed, right? We don't know the future! So cheer up old chap!

Basilisa Marie
Posted

My Eastern Orthodox biblical studies professor thinks that Pope Francis' humility and the fact that he referred to himself as the bishop of Rome and didn't mention the word "pope" once in his Urbi et Orbi blessing is a good sign for possible Eastern/Western relations.  :)  I hope so!  

Posted

My Eastern Orthodox biblical studies professor thinks that Pope Francis' humility and the fact that he referred to himself as the bishop of Rome and didn't mention the word "pope" once in his Urbi et Orbi blessing is a good sign for possible Eastern/Western relations.   :)  I hope so!  

Yes, it could be helpful. Al's post where he talks about how Pope Francis looks as if he is going to focus on Rome and leave other local Churches alone would be very popular with Eastern Orthodox Christians. I think the statements issued by both the Ecumenical Patriarch and the Russian Patriarch show that cooperation between Catholics and Orthodox on moral and other issues (e.g., helping the poor) is possible.

KnightofChrist
Posted

Not quite my brother:
 
http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/topic/127707-pope-permitted-traditional-latin-mass-48hrs-after-summorum-pontificum-not-quite/

 

Hybrid? Perhaps, perhaps not!
 
An excerpt from The Moynihan Letters Blog, by Robert Moynihan, PhD.
 

However, I have since received a large number of other emails containing very different information. Here is one from a respected Catholic philosopher and writer whom I trust a great deal:
 
Dear Robert,

I read with passionate interest all the reports you sent us since Benedict XVI (to my deep regret) stepped down. I thank you for them; they were remarkably well done, informative and expressing your love for the Church.
But I was deeply grieved today in reading that you write that Francis I is hostile to the Tridentine Mass. This must be a terrible misinformation likely to do a lot of harm to many of your readers.
 
Archbishop Bergoglio, upon receiving the information that Benedictine XVI (at my repeated requests) had granted a universal indult, designated the Church Michel Angelo as the one place where the traditional Mass would be said. Its pastor, Padre Ricardo Dotro (I might get the name wrong) a well-trained liturgist, was going to say it to those who wished it. It was well-attended; hundred of people with their old missals, even some younger people, ladies wearing Mantillas, and modestly dressed, six candles on the altar, Mass ad orientem, kneeling for communion on the tongue.
 
I fear you were misinformed. Because the Mass had not been said for 40 years, all the younger priests could not say it. This was well-calculated; if no one can say that mass, that it certain to bury it. But it survived.
 
I wish you would correct this. Many of your devoted readers will be, like me, deeply grieved, unless you do. In the joy of Habemus papam and thanking you for your great work, I am, dear Robert, yours in caritate Christi.
 
(end of letter)
 
So, at this point, I will step back from the entire question to give a judgment regardless of anything that happened in the past, and it is this: in my view, we should have no concerns whatsoever about the continued celebration of the traditional Latin Mass under our new Pope, Francis.
 
I do not believe Francis will do anything to undermine the freedom Pope Benedict granted to the traditional Latin Mass in 2007.
 
And, even more, I agree with what one reader writes: “Unlike Pope Benedict, I would not be at all surprised to see Pope Francis publicly offer a traditional Latin Mass some day. He has a deep devotion to Our Lady of Fatima, is said to practice the Five First Saturday Devotions, and prays 15 decades of the Rosary each day. I believe that, after he meets with Pope Emeritus Benedict, reads the 300-page dossier on the Vatileaks scandal, and reads the rest of the Third Secret of Fatima, he will be a different man than he was as archbishop, then cardinal, in Argentina.”
 
Pope Francis strikes me as a man who, once he learns something is the Lord’s will, will simply make it his own.

KnightofChrist
Posted

Yes, it could be helpful. Al's post where he talks about how Pope Francis looks as if he is going to focus on Rome and leave other local Churches alone would be very popular with Eastern Orthodox Christians. I think the statements issued by both the Ecumenical Patriarch and the Russian Patriarch show that cooperation between Catholics and Orthodox on moral and other issues (e.g., helping the poor) is possible.

On Wednesday, 20 March, he will hold an audience with fraternal delegates representing the heads of the various Eastern rite Churches so there will not be a General Audience.

 

Source: http://themoynihanletters.com/from-the-desk-of/letter-47-to-mary

 

inperpetuity
Posted

I don't think that we have anything to fear from a Pope who is obviously committed to the Truth. Also from "The Moynihan Letters":

First Homily

Here is the complete text of that first homily this afternoon, March 14, in the Sistine Chapel where yesterday he was elected Pope, spoken without a prepared text:

“When we walk without the cross…”

by Pope Francis

In these three readings, I see that there is something in common: it is movement.

In the first reading, movement in walking; in the second reading, movement in the building up of the Church; in the third, in the Gospel, movement in confession.

To walk, to build up, to confess.

To walk. “House of Jacob, come, let us walk in the light of the Lord.”

This is the first thing that God said to Abraham: Walk in my presence and be without reproach. To walk: our life is a journey and when we stop it is no good. To walk always, in the presence of the Lord, in the light of the Lord, seeking to live with that irreproachability which God asked of Abraham, in his promise.

To build up. To build up the Church. Stones are spoken of: the stones have substance; but living stones, stones anointed by the Holy Spirit. To build up the Church, the bride of Christ, on that cornerstone which is the Lord himself. This is another movement of our lives: to build up.

Third, to confess. We can walk as much as we wish, we can build many things, but if we do not confess Jesus Christ, it is no good. We will become a humanitarian NGO, but not the Church, bride of the Lord.

When one does not walk, one halts. When one does not build on stone what happens? That happens which happens to children on the beach when they make sand castles, it all comes down, it is without substance. When one does not confess Jesus Christ, I am reminded of the expression of Léon Bloy: “He who does not pray to the Lord prays to the devil.” When one does not confess Jesus Christ, one confesses the worldliness of the devil, the worldliness of the demon.

To walk, to build/construct, to confess. But the matter is not so easy, because in walking, in building, in confessing, at times there are shocks, there are movements that are not properly movements of the journey: they are movements that set us back.

This Gospel continues with a special situation. The same Peter who has confessed Jesus Christ says to him: “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God. I will follow you, but let us not speak of the cross. This has nothing to do with it. I will follow you with other possibilities, without the cross.”

When we walk without the cross, when we build without the cross, and when we confess Christ without the cross, we are not disciples of the Lord: we are worldly, we are bishops, priests, cardinals, popes, but not disciples of the Lord.

I would like that everyone, after these days of grace, should have the courage, truly the courage, to walk in the presence of the Lord, with the cross of the Lord; to build up the Church upon the blood of the Lord that was shed upon the cross; and to confess the only glory: Christ crucified. And in this way the Church will move forward.

I hope for all of us that the Holy Spirit, through the prayer of the Virgin Mary, our Mother, may grant us this grace: to walk, to build up, to confess Jesus Christ crucified. So may it be.

====================================

Posted

The Sistine Chapel is a lovely building. I just wish the cardinals would wear more ornate miters.

I think that they shy away from that and fancy vestments during the Great Fast. It's something about the season that makes them want to wear simple miters, or at least that's what they tell me. ;)

 

I'm hungry to read everything this man has written. Hope to come across some good stuff.

I have been in contact with some publishers and I know that some of them are scrambling to get his books published. Several of them are working to get a book each published (in Spanish right now) in the US in the next month or so, and also within that same time period you'll see some books on the man who became Pope (including one on the transition from Benedict to Francis - Benedict's retirements and Francis' election), all in English. I bet there will be translations in the following months, though they'll be done quickly so we'll have to see how great they are. I know that Random House has the rights to one book (the top of the list in Apo's link), I think Ignatius and OSV each have a book to be released, and I'll let you know about more as I hear about them myself.

 

Yes, it could be helpful. Al's post where he talks about how Pope Francis looks as if he is going to focus on Rome and leave other local Churches alone would be very popular with Eastern Orthodox Christians. I think the statements issued by both the Ecumenical Patriarch and the Russian Patriarch show that cooperation between Catholics and Orthodox on moral and other issues (e.g., helping the poor) is possible.

I think that this was also a movement that I began to notice near the end of Benedict's time as Pope and I recognized it more and more as I reflected on the end of his papacy. I thought it was reflected most substantially in his retirement, which I still find a fascinating move by Benedict.

FutureSister2009
Posted

483697_169874703162280_371106000_n.png

 

My Three Popes. :love:

 

JPII and Benny are like HEY!! And Papa Frankie is just like Hi. So cute

Nihil Obstat
Posted

 

Hybrid? Perhaps, perhaps not!
 
An excerpt from The Moynihan Letters Blog, by Robert Moynihan, PhD.
 

I very much want to believe that everything in that letter is true. :)

Posted

on a sad note, I think Marini's days as Papal liturgist are numbered.

It's quite possible he'll be happy to go. If he's not permitted to orchestrate the liturgies he is used to under Benedict, he may not even want the job.

Posted

http://www.patheos.com/blogs/deaconsbench/2013/03/historic-for-first-time-since-schism-ecumenical-patriarch-will-attend-popes-installation-mass/

 

The Ecumenical Patriarch of Constantinople Bartholomew I will attend Pope Francis’s inaugural Mass. The Ecumenical Patriarchate Press Office informed AsiaNews about the decision, noting that this is the first time such an event occurs since the Catholic-Orthodox split in 1054, an important sign for Christian unity.

 

The ecumenical patriarch will be accompanied by Ioannis Zizioulas, metropolitan of Pergamon and co-president of the Joint International Commission for Theological Dialogue between the Roman Catholic and the Orthodox Church, as well as Tarassios, Orthodox Metropolitan of Argentina, and Gennadios, Orthodox Metropolitan of Italy.

 

Relations between Catholics and Orthodox have been improving since the Second Vatican Council through mutual visits, acts of friendship and theological dialogue.

====================

more at the link.

Posted

Awesome news Lil Red!

ToJesusMyHeart
Posted

Papa Francis said his first mass as pope in the novus ordo, in Latin. 

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sdWZWDqhCdA

Posted

Michael Voris breaks silence on Pope Francis' election, comes out in support of his pontiff:

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6qFmX2c25fQ&feature=player_embedded[/media]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...