Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I presume you're talking about when he talks about wanting to play chess or knitting when he's revived?  that's the only seemingly "silly" thing... when he says about the front crashing first that's really a standard number 8 joke... there's one time where he says something like "no, we shouldn't take evasive action, that's exactly what they'll be expecting us to take"... same type of thing right there lol, that kind of absurdly logical statement in the middle of a crisis... but I also think the anyone for knitting moment was also classic number 8 style, not number 11 style.

Posted

I presume you're talking about when he talks about wanting to play chess or knitting when he's revived?  that's the only seemingly "silly" thing... when he says about the front crashing first that's really a standard number 8 joke... there's one time where he says something like "no, we shouldn't take evasive action, that's exactly what they'll be expecting us to take"... same type of thing right there lol, that kind of absurdly logical statement in the middle of a crisis... but I also think the anyone for knitting moment was also classic number 8 style, not number 11 style.

Yeah, it was mainly the knitting thing he said that didnt sit well with me. And considering I havent listened to any of the audio adventures means you likely have a point but I refuse to acknowledge it as it would not serve to my inflated sense of pride!

 

I will proceed to cross my arms, furrow my brow, and pout.

Posted

lol... well I felt I had to argue it because I thought the entire minisode was pure gold, above rebuke, pretty definitively one of the best moments in all of doctor who in all of space and time, from its beginning to its end.  from "I'm a doctor, but probably not the one you expected" to "Physician heal thyself", I considered it to be completely perfect and will fight anyone who says it was not.   :fight:

 

anyway give those audios a listen, they are quite good.

Posted

You might be able to convince me to retract my statements from earlier but dont even try to take away my disdain for Clara. 

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

Yeah, it was mainly the knitting thing he said that didnt sit well with me. And considering I havent listened to any of the audio adventures means you likely have a point but I refuse to acknowledge it as it would not serve to my inflated sense of pride!

 

I will proceed to cross my arms, furrow my brow, and pout.

 

 

I presume you're talking about when he talks about wanting to play chess or knitting when he's revived?  that's the only seemingly "silly" thing... when he says about the front crashing first that's really a standard number 8 joke... there's one time where he says something like "no, we shouldn't take evasive action, that's exactly what they'll be expecting us to take"... same type of thing right there lol, that kind of absurdly logical statement in the middle of a crisis... but I also think the anyone for knitting moment was also classic number 8 style, not number 11 style.

 

Gosh I feel we are all incredibly nerdy having this 'debate', but who cares!... the knitting thing, heck a lot of the minisode made references to the 4th Doctor, and the 8th Doctor's prior visits to Karn, and the SIsterhood. The knitting quote probably was a reference to the 4th Doctors scarf, and if I remember correctly in the "The Brain of Morbius" the 4th also made similar jokes about being bored when he was tied up. So it was more of a nod to the 4th Doctor than it being a 11th reference.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KY7idi78amE

Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted

Gosh I feel we are all incredibly nerdy having this 'debate', but who cares!... the knitting thing, heck a lot of the minisode made references to the 4th Doctor, and the 8th Doctor's prior visits to Karn, and the SIsterhood. The knitting quote probably was a reference to the 4th Doctors scarf, and if I remember correctly in the "The Brain of Morbius" the 4th also made similar jokes about being bored when he was tied up. So it was more of a nod to the 4th Doctor than it being a 11th reference.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KY7idi78amE

 

OOOOOOOoooooo very interesting observation! Now I really have to listen to the audios! Add that to my ever growing list of literature and whatnot. Sigh.

KnightofChrist
Posted

David Tennant also has a couple of audio books by Big Finish Audio, (here's a list of the names of episodes) where he plays the Doctor, and others prior to the reboot were he plays other characters.

 

I really hope you will be able to get some of them, the audios are quite good, one's imagination can go a lot further than the special effects on the TV.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lvGoQlZHv5A

 

Other audio book samples...

 

http://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLkou_jrF0nXiUtaesC9mbUVVuh-2I0lmC

 

Posted

I dont know what David Tennant is saying but his voice is so pretty...  :love:

KnightofChrist
Posted

Yeah pretty manly, in a Scottish sort of way,.

Posted

Real men wear skirts.

Posted

Real men wear skirts. Kilt.

 

Fixed it. There is a difference.

  • 2 weeks later...
KnightofChrist
Posted

Wish the one lady had more clothes on, but otherwise this is a really great fandom animation of Doctor Who.
 

http://youtu.be/kt3qZYUPi2Y

  • 6 months later...
Posted

New series just came out...Thoughts?


personally Peter Capaldi was the only reason to watch it.

P.s. Can we still do the spoiler thing? if so how?

Ancilla Domini
Posted

New series just came out...Thoughts?


personally Peter Capaldi was the only reason to watch it.

P.s. Can we still do the spoiler thing? if so how?

 

The episode itself wasn't the best I've seen, but I thought Peter Capaldi was quite good, to be honest.

(Some really funny Strax moments in it.  :hehe2:)

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted (edited)

I read the article and it was very good- it helped me put a finger on some of the creepiness that I couldn't figure out. While I agree that that anti-religion, pro-gay marriage tones are unacceptable, I will say that is not unusual for the BBC (think of Sherlock and Call the Midwife). So while you need to be aware of it, I might not give it too much weight in my final say of the show as it's rather common (at least in what I watch).

 

I once spoke with a man who knew British fans of the show way back in the day- like the 70's. He said that it's main supporters were gay men, it didn't really have a male (or female) heterosexual fan base. And now a large part of the show's supporters are straight girls. (True, Classic and NewWho are different- but I've watched both and worse plot lines and bad special effects aside, they both have the same feel.) Nowadays the show has a very diverse group of fans, but they are all a little odd in the same way. I can't put my finger on it. 

 

However, I disagree with his rating (1 star). I think he should have given it at least a three- possibly a four. I myself would still give it a five, I'm a die-hard, but I accept the fact that not everyone appreciates the show as much as I do. But a one star? That's a low blow. 

Edited by veritasluxmea
Posted

However, I disagree with his rating (1 star). I think he should have given it at least a three- possibly a four. I myself would still give it a five, I'm a die-hard, but I accept the fact that not everyone appreciates the show as much as I do. But a one star? That's a low blow. 

I've been expecting controversy ever since I wrote this review (which was originally three or two stars, but that mockery of the Catholic Church threw in the towel for me).  It's about dang time!

Ancilla Domini
Posted

 

Great review! The episode in the hotel with the monster that feeds off people's faiths really got me. Another thing I remember distinctly from one episode is when the doctor says, "Funny thing is, I don't usually do Easter. I can never find it. It's always at a different time. Although! I remember the original. Between you and me, what really happened was—" and then gets interrupted.

Agree with you on everything in there. Thanks for sharing!

 

(Sorry for not being well-written. I'm rarely eloquent at this time in the morning. :P)

Posted

 

(Sorry for not being well-written. I'm rarely eloquent at this time in the morning. :P)

And I'm just rarely eloquent, period. :mail:

 

Thanks for the review, Not a Mallard!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...