Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I think harry potter is like any fiction. i actually love the books they are really good reading. you just have to realize that there are evils out there that are not fake and witches and wizards who are not just trying to get along in thier lives. But actually worship the devil and want you to go to hell

Posted

harry potter is a well written and entertaining series...

But.

If we look at a work like Lord of the Rings, comparatively the two are very different in their philosophies. In LOTR, Gandalf's magic is a mysterious power given to him by those above him. He is not a human, nor did he 'learn' his magic. In Harry Potter, the power comes from within the person, which is something that we shouldn't believe. Where do our gifts and talents come from? God, of course. Likewise, the discrimination against Muggles is somewhat disturbing once we get past the humor. I think Rowling touches on this by presenting the Malfoys (who love to call people Mudbloods) as such twisted evil meanies.

Posted

I disagree that the power comes from "within the person." The characters have no choice over whether or not they are wizards or not, it's something that is like hair or eye color, just something they are born with.

I can't wait for the rest of the books to come out, mainly cause Rowling has said that her personal beliefs do have some role in them (her main reason for not stating what exactly she believes). I don't want to judge the books at all, until they are all out. Right now, they are totally fine fiction, but if they do get worse well, it'll be right there, easy to tell.

Just remember, don't judge a book by it's cover ;)

Posted

I don't think the books are evil, or bad. But if they do have some sort of effect, I think I have better books to read. :ph34r:


Jamel

Posted

The Harry Potter books are great! I myself love them and think they are very enjoyable. Also I can't tell you how many stories I've heard about kids hating reading and then finding Harry Potter and then reading tons of books.

Harry Potter is like any other fiction book IT'S NOT REAL!!!! Remember that people!!!!

Karinsbestfriend
Posted

I think they are really interesting books, and I find them very entertaining to read. But yea, one does have to remember that of coarse they are just books, there not real.

Posted

I love the Harry Potter books!

Posted

Read one page and hated it. Won't touch it, it is [i]below[/i] me. LOL!

Posted

[quote name='Iacobus' date='Oct 27 2004, 03:33 PM'] Read one page and hated it. Won't touch it, it is [i]below[/i] me. LOL! [/quote]
:rolleyes: Jacob :rolleyes:

Posted

[quote name='Iacobus' date='Oct 27 2004, 03:33 PM'] Read one page and hated it. Won't touch it, it is [i]below[/i] me. LOL! [/quote]
Mister Smarty pants ^_^

Posted

I can't believe people like this..... Harry Potter is immoral, I'll take Lord of the Rings Trilogy anyday lol.

Posted

i love the Harry Potter books. i don't think they're bad in any way, as long as you have the understanding not to let the evil portrayed influence your life.

don't want to see the movies though.. it'll ruin what i see in the books.

Posted

The harry potter books are not evil

Posted

i started to read one, but it was just so pathetic, i quickly put it down and ran off to get my Bible.........

cmotherofpirl
Posted (edited)

Is that how you react to all works of fiction? Didn't you ever read fairy tales?

I enjoyed Harry Potter and his adventures.

Edited by cmotherofpirl
Posted

I looovve the Harry Potter books!!! And it's just fiction! If people are more susceptible to thoughts of witchcraft or the devil and whatnot, then they probably shouldn't read them. But if you know that it's not real, then go ahead! READ!!
I can't wait for the 6th book...

Posted

[quote]Is that how you react to all works of fiction? Didn't you ever read fairy tales?[/quote]

No, the Bible is the best book ever, id rather read it than Harry Potter, dont get me wrong, fairytales are great, but theres no comparison with the Bible, i mean, if u were only allowed to read one book, surely ud pick the Bible over everything else?

Karinsbestfriend
Posted

Well I don't think that Harry Potter is the best book ever. And of coarse the Bible comes first, that isn't even a comparison. But that doesn't mean I don't like the Harry Potters, I still think that they are good. And I can't wait tell the sixth one comes out either!

Posted

Well duh you should pick the Bible above everything else but that doesn't mean you can't read anything else

Posted (edited)

i didnt say that u cant read anything else, i read lots of other books, i just dont like the Harry Potter books

Edited by Noel's angel

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...