uruviel Posted January 1, 2006 Posted January 1, 2006 You cannot say what people will like, it's not logical to debate about what people will like, it's a matter of taste, opinoin and perception. I appreciate LOTR more than HP, I dont like HP all that much but that's my opnion. See we can only say what our opnions are, and you can't say, I think ppl will like this if they like this, or whatever. You can't say.
Fixxxer Posted January 1, 2006 Posted January 1, 2006 [quote name='sraf' date='Jan 1 2006, 03:08 AM'] Oh yeah, and [b]Fixxxer[/b] - may I reccommend Jean Renoir's biography of his father, Pierre-Auguste Renoir - "Renoir, My Father" ? It's totally non-fiction and a fascinating read. [right][snapback]842387[/snapback][/right] [/quote] : i have read the books and seen the movies. i wouldnt have time to read that with all the books from my school to read
Smile_Jesus_loves_you Posted January 2, 2006 Posted January 2, 2006 (edited) my opion is like thet of our pope, not bad only misleading... i like everything but harry, and of course not the bad guys, but harry is immature and i highly doubt he will change.... like thourghout the books he has gained no maturity at all!!!! ok there you go. Edited January 2, 2006 by Smile_Jesus_loves_you
Smile_Jesus_loves_you Posted January 2, 2006 Posted January 2, 2006 [quote name='sraf' date='Jan 1 2006, 03:08 AM']No, it's not the same. If you like LotR you will probably understand or tolerate HP better or you may be just more used to what magic in fiction entails, but I've met some people who love LotR but can't stand HP, or vice-versa. [right][snapback]842387[/snapback][/right] [/quote] i can agree with you there because tolkien is know to be a better writer, though dry to some and he wrote books with true deep moral in them from a true deep moral point og veiw that i do not believe rowling has. i'm sorry but he was a strong, solid catholic and there for i think him is a better writer, and has i better plot line hers is to typical...
Smile_Jesus_loves_you Posted January 2, 2006 Posted January 2, 2006 [quote name='Fixxxer' date='Dec 18 2005, 10:15 PM']I wont read anything thats has a witch a wizard, anything magic in it or anything not real in it. I'm a super catholic [right][snapback]830349[/snapback][/right] [/quote] i don't like how you stated that, i am one of the most catholic people i know and i love fantasy. it can be good, think of c.s. lewis and j.r.r. tolkien. i don't think it's fair to rule such things out.
Diamond Posted January 2, 2006 Posted January 2, 2006 I'm a huge Harry Potter fan. Honestly, I don't know that many people against it. I'm not a Catholic myself, but my parent's best friend is a Catholic priest. I've talked with him about it and he doesn't think it's destructive, at least not in my case. I think Harry Potter appeals to the same wired-in complex that makes the story of Jesus so emotionally attractive to us. God gave us that so we could appreciate works that accentuate the rift between good and evil. Harry Potter may not be directly Christian (although if Dumbledore returns in any form, it very well could be) but it's excellent literature and still gives me that good vs. evil feeling. I don't feel they're wrong in any way. Most detractors I've encountered are elderly and uninformed about the books. I've yet to encounter anyone who has read the books and thinks they're wrong.
uruviel Posted January 2, 2006 Posted January 2, 2006 I can definitely agree with you, smile_Jesus_loves_you, I appreciate Tolkien much more, I think he had that insight, that moral virtue, and omg he was such a talented writter, he was an amazing artist, and I look up to him. I don not believe his writting is dry, he goes into SUCH detail, and beinga wirtter myself, know how hard it may be to have a full picture in your mind, and describe it the way Toikien does. He was so blessed, and Rowling has talent that's true, I don't think she meant any harm by writting them, but I don't like her insight on it all. That is 100% true, Harry is VERY immature as I read them I was waiting for him to mature and it's just not happeneing. I always said I never liked harry, I always like Ron and Hermione. But thats how Rowling wants to display the characters. You would think that a boy with such expericnces as his own would have learned from his mistakes and matured, but Rowling didn't make it that way. CS Lewis, the Chronicles of Narnia, those had the MOST meaning of Christ, such as the lion offering himself for not-innocnet beings, his rising back, was the resuraction, his fighting for us, was God's fight with us against the devil, or the white witch, Peter, was St. Peter. When the Lion left in the end, it is just linked to the Ascension. You see? This stories have insight and morals and links to Christ. I don't see that in Rowlings writtings, of course it has a sense of good and evil, and good conquers, but it's not like Lewis or Tolkien, do you get it?
Diamond Posted January 2, 2006 Posted January 2, 2006 Of course it's not like Lewis or Tolkein. I LOVE the Lord of the Rings Trilogy, The Hobbit, The Chronicles of Narnia and C.S. Lewis' other writings. However, I think J.K. is just as great an author in her own right. The most amazing thing about her is the way she weaves these clues together. We've seen hints come to fruition so many times in her books. Wait for Book 7-I garuntee it will knock you over with several surprises that are all hinted at in the first 6 books. Everything you read from her is good on 2 different levels: as a story, and as something to really read intensely, attempting to draw hints from it. As a huge fan of Tolkien and Lewis, those are my thoughts.
uruviel Posted January 2, 2006 Posted January 2, 2006 Yes, she is very tallented, she has a great sense of knowing how to create personalities and idea's, and clues and hints, (personally, I think Harry will die in the end, Ron and Hermione might fall in love, idk, thats kinda perdictable) Anyways, we have already established that they are all tallented, but I still have to say that I appreciate Toklien and though I've never read Narnia, I respect Lewis more than Rowling because of they're insight and moral value's, Tolkien was christian, Rowling was at least Athiest, or agnostic. This is also just how I perceve the books, and interpret them, and this is all my opnion.
goldenchild17 Posted January 9, 2006 Posted January 9, 2006 Horribly written books, never saw the movies(don't plan to). Simply a portrayal of the dark side of magical stories. No reason to involve myself with them when I have books like C.S. Lewis' series, and for that matter Tolkien(although I really didn't like LOTR in the least bit).
Vivacristorey Posted January 13, 2006 Posted January 13, 2006 [quote name='White Knight' date='Oct 27 2004, 04:36 PM']I can't believe people like this..... Harry Potter is immoral, I'll take Lord of the Rings Trilogy anyday lol. [right][snapback]398114[/snapback][/right] [/quote] our highschool newspaper had an article on this... they said that the only way it could lead someone into sin is if they already were not formed well and didnt have a good basis in their faith. also, the lord of the rings has TONS of magic in it, but no one's accusing them? thirdly, really good points are made in the books beyond the outer covering... dumbledore says to harry in all the books that his greatest power is love, and that evil forgets that and that he can not. its not his powers that will save him, dumbledore reminds him, but love because that is the ultimate power. also, the themes of friendship, loyalty, and each person's personal vocation is very real. friendship because the characters, just like any real group of teenagers, have friendship problems every once in a while and have to work them out through selfless love in working things out, humility in accepting that they're not perfect, and also honesty when it's tempting to lie or cheat. loyalty because harry battles his feelings and emotions to be loyal to his friends, family, and the right thing to do. many times he messes up, and that's what makes some people uncomfortable. This character is so close to the average teenager that it's scary, but its true that we all mess up so that shouldn't be our basis for calling the books "evil" Also, Harry has a choice to make: whether or not to go destroy evil. He chooses his vocation (as presented by a prophesy) to destroy evil (in the form of lord voldemort) showing that no matter how many mistakes we make, we must always follow our vocation. he finds peace in that he's doing what he's meant to do in his life, he's found his purpose and shows supernatural peace. sometimes we have to dig past the outer covering and look for the virtues and ideas presented. ~*sarah*~
Vivacristorey Posted January 13, 2006 Posted January 13, 2006 just to let you know, i've read all the books and they didnt HELP me in my faith, but they definitely gave me something fun to do sittting on the beach or something. My family all loves the books and my religion teacher was telling me that why so many people are attracted to them is the same reason so many people are attracted to star wars and the lotr and the chronicles of narnia: its the fight of good vs. evil that is, whether we admit it or not, inscribed on our souls. thats why ppl who are professing athiests love these stories, because they say exactly what's inscribed on their souls since they were created : that the battle of good vs. evil is going on, and the good guys will win. also i think that they're FICTION as said many times. it's not a book about Christ misleading people about him like the divinci code. it's not a book that says "dont believe in Christ. practice magic. call on the devil. its' fun." NO we must remember that if you are already not formed well obviously you will reject the books because you cant handle it because you aren't convinced of your faith. it's very personal to the person. the spiritually mature will be able to read it, find the deeper meanings, and cherish those lessons with a true Catholic Christian spirit. Now im not saying that if you just dont like them you're not spritually mature. I personally cant stand lotr. the chronicles of narnia are great, but i cant do lotr. but im not going to condemn it just because i dont like it or just because it has magic in it and magical creatures. no, itthey're very good books for the soul and very catholic. i just dont personally like them because of my literary taste. thats all. thanks for listening, reading, or skimming. whichever you did made me feel heard out. ~*sarah*~
*lil girl 4 jesus* Posted February 7, 2006 Posted February 7, 2006 seriously, i just started reading the books and i am in love with them. they are a great, well written series! alot of my friends parents have problems with them, but i can't find anything that would make you go spiraling down into a pit of evil and sorcery the minute you open them! which is what alot of people i know think.
heavenseeker Posted February 7, 2006 Posted February 7, 2006 the movies are good but the books stink.
Tindomiel Posted February 7, 2006 Posted February 7, 2006 I like fantasy (fantasy is in many ways very compatible with Catholicism: y'all should see GK Chesterton's and CS Lewis' ideas on this matter), but I think there are dangers associated with Harry Potter... if only because some readers may be immature enough to think they can emulate Harry Potter by getting into the occult. And Harry himself really acts like a snot a lot of the time. But I don't think there's anything wrong with the book by itself. You just have to read it with a mature attitude.
goldbug16 Posted February 25, 2006 Posted February 25, 2006 [quote name='Tindomiel' date='Feb 7 2006, 03:55 PM']I like fantasy (fantasy is in many ways very compatible with Catholicism: y'all should see GK Chesterton's and CS Lewis' ideas on this matter), but I think there are dangers associated with Harry Potter... if only because some readers may be immature enough to think they can emulate Harry Potter by getting into the occult. And Harry himself really acts like a snot a lot of the time. But I don't think there's anything wrong with the book by itself. You just have to read it with a mature attitude. [right][snapback]879276[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I agree. I have started reading them and they arent evil or even bad, but you do have to look at the with a mature attitude. I thought the first one one was almost enjoyable. Unfortunatrly she puts in a bit too much disobedience and grossness, but other than that i would say they are OK.
Catholic Knight Posted February 25, 2006 Posted February 25, 2006 There are some people who re-read the Harry Potter books numerous times. How many times have they read the Bible? Pax, CK
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now