Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

this is what bothers me most, everyone reads them and thinks to themselves, wow this is so much better than what all those ppl said becasue its not about satan and it's not gonna lead you to sin! This is a good book. NO We are NOT saying it is EVIL we are saying that though it shows good and evil, I don't think it does any good. I do NOT like harry, he is portrated very immature and never seems to mature. He needs to get over himself but that's not what this is about. I have stated my opinion numerous times. But again, I just can't appreciate Rowlings works as much as CS Lewis's or Tolkiens, I've tried readintg hers with an open mind and thinking about how good this series could be, but I just can't appreceaite it and fall in love with it, I think it's a very juvinile and immature look on life and moral issues. I don't like it for young ones and I wouldn't recoment it. Does anyone agree with me here?

Posted

[quote name='Vivacristorey' date='Jan 12 2006, 07:56 PM']why so many people are attracted to them is the same reason so many people are attracted to star wars and the lotr and the chronicles of narnia:
[right][snapback]854450[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I think that you should not compare Narnia, LOTR, star wars, and HP with each other. I do get what your saying about how Harry Potter has very good morals, I'm really trying to understand and open up to the idea of likeing Harry Potter, but it's difficult. Anyways, LOTR and Narnia have CLEAR signs relating to not only the life of Jesus, such as the sacrifices jesus made for us, but also Tolkien relates allllot of his things upon the book of revalation, in the bible. That's where Catholisism comes in. And HP doesn't have that.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Yes, I am so totally with you!!!





[quote name='uruviel' date='Feb 25 2006, 10:26 PM']this is what bothers me most, everyone reads them and thinks to themselves, wow this is so much better than what all those ppl said becasue its not about satan and it's not gonna lead you to sin!  This is a good book.  NO We are NOT saying it is EVIL we are saying that though it shows good and evil, I don't think it does any good.  I do NOT like harry, he is portrated very immature and never seems to mature.  He needs to get over himself but that's not what this is about.  I have stated my opinion numerous times.  But again, I just can't appreciate Rowlings works as much as CS Lewis's or Tolkiens, I've tried readintg hers with an open mind and thinking about how good this series could be, but I just can't appreceaite it and fall in love with it, I think it's a very juvinile and immature look on life and moral issues.  I don't like it for young ones and I wouldn't recoment it.  Does anyone agree with me here?
[right][snapback]897892[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

the flutehonker
Posted

it's a preference thing i suppose. some people will like the books, and some won't, just as some people prefer vanilla ice cream and some prefer chocolate. i don't think it's a big deal or anything ^_^

*lil girl 4 jesus*
Posted

dude, i love the series!!!!!! it HAS rocked my world.... :yes: :woot:
w000t!! :woot: :woot: :woot: :woot: :D: :D: :D:

sarcasmguy126
Posted

well...i've only seen a few of the movies

the flutehonker
Posted

[quote name='sarcasmguy126' date='Mar 11 2006, 07:32 PM']well...i've only seen a few of the movies
[right][snapback]909103[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


in my opinion...the books OWN the movies :D:

*lil girl 4 jesus*
Posted

OMG totally!!!!! :yes:

Posted

yes well some of us like it. I think it is also a matter of opinion and taste, how you percieve the books, and what you like. I don't like them. I've, again, stated how I don't like the juvanile series. I don't think it has anything to think about spiritually and it doesn't relate to anything in terms of the Christian/Catholic faith as some of you might say that LOTR and TCON have magic as well, yes they have magic. But they have SO very deep meanings of the bible, the Catholic church, Jesus's life, happenings in Jesus's life, they relate to things like that. HP doesn't. I'm not saying it has to to be a good book. I'm saying that in defense for those of you who say it's just as good as LOTR because it has magic as well. Just because it's interesting and fun, doesn't make it good for us.

Posted

[quote name='goldbug16' date='Mar 11 2006, 10:33 AM']Yes, I am so totally with you!!!
[right][snapback]908769[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


Thank you goldbug :P: hehe

sarcasmguy126
Posted

[quote name='uruviel' date='Mar 12 2006, 06:48 PM']yes well some of us like it.  I think it is also a matter of opinion and taste, how you percieve the books, and what you like.  I don't like them.  I've, again, stated how I don't like the juvanile series.  I don't think it has anything to think about spiritually and it doesn't relate to anything in terms of the Christian/Catholic faith as some of you might say that LOTR and TCON have magic as well, yes they have magic.  But they have SO very deep meanings of the bible, the Catholic church, Jesus's life, happenings in Jesus's life, they relate to things like that.  HP doesn't.  I'm not saying it has to to be a good book.  I'm saying that in defense for those of you who say it's just as good as LOTR because it has magic as well.  Just because it's interesting and fun, doesn't make it good for us.
[right][snapback]909668[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

you are absolutely right! i enjoy the movies a whole lot, but are they good for me? no! who needs them, but who doesn't enjoy them? they are entertaining!

Posted

I think the movies are awesome. I tried reading the 1st book, and I just didn't think I needed to waste my time on it. (plus I'm not much of a reader.) I think there are way better books out there.

Posted

yes it's entertaining, but don't you think its a waste of time to read something thats no good for you? Spiritual reading has the best merit, and LOTR is prolly good for you so I wouldn't call it a waste of time. ;)
Movies are ok, I like em.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='brickchick' date='Oct 27 2004, 12:49 PM']but if they do get worse well, it'll be right there, easy to tell.
[/quote]
I don't care to go through 5 pages of responses. So all I will say is that I think the books are not particularly well written or very entertaining at all, and I do think they are bad and that we should not read them. As for the quote above, I believe it is not very often at all that evil is easy to see. I believe Satan often tries to cover evil with nice packaging, and that he can use even the least suspected sources for his evil plans. It is my belief that Harry Potter is one of these means. I don't plan to make judgment on those who read it(I won't even read the rest of the thread to see who here does read it), but that is what I will say on it.

Posted

that's good, I can agree with that. I don't like them, and have stated how I dont aleady. Satan has to make evil appeal, and most of the time it's through pleasure. So he has to give it some appeal and hide it or no one would do it. He's very smart. lol. Harry Potter just isn't a book I would recomend to anyone.

Posted

[quote name='*lil girl 4 jesus*' date='Mar 11 2006, 05:00 PM']dude, i love the series!!!!!! it HAS rocked my world.... :yes: :woot:
w000t!! :woot: :woot: :woot: :woot: :D: :D: :D:
[right][snapback]908990[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

EVERTHING rocks your world :lol:

Proud2BCatholic139
Posted

My friends still want me to go and see the movie, but I still dont' have interest. I think I will laugh.

*lil girl 4 jesus*
Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' date='Mar 16 2006, 11:08 PM']EVERTHING rocks your world :lol:
[right][snapback]913707[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
not EVERYTHING.lets see here........its.......um......... :coagulated milk: !!!!!!!
I.Hate.coagulated milk.

:P:

Posted

[quote name='uruviel' date='Mar 12 2006, 08:48 PM']yes well some of us like it.  I think it is also a matter of opinion and taste, how you percieve the books, and what you like.  I don't like them.  I've, again, stated how I don't like the juvanile series.  I don't think it has anything to think about spiritually and it doesn't relate to anything in terms of the Christian/Catholic faith as some of you might say that LOTR and TCON have magic as well, yes they have magic.  But they have SO very deep meanings of the bible, the Catholic church, Jesus's life, happenings in Jesus's life, they relate to things like that.  HP doesn't.  I'm not saying it has to to be a good book.  I'm saying that in defense for those of you who say it's just as good as LOTR because it has magic as well.  Just because it's interesting and fun, doesn't make it good for us.
[right][snapback]909668[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Well, there is a very interesting point of view presented on this in the book "Looking for God in Harry Potter" The book really made me rethink some of my assumptions about the series. But I still think Harry Potter should be read with a mature approach, simply because, unlike in CS. Lewis, the religious side is much harder to see, and there are the rule-breaking issues. I know little kids tend to imitate favorite characters, and I know many kids wouldn't be mature enough to understand that the [i]growth[/i] in Harry's character is what they should emulate. That, and the growth isn't always totally clear.

Guest Rick777
Posted

I thought the last movie was really good.....it could've been better but still good.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...