randy_the_clown Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 They don't authorize breathing, walking in doors, or what type of organ to have in the church either, but we do it. And you have not established that the change was deliberate disobedience or if they were simply following #38 of CoSL. I'm sorry, Mother of Phat, but you are simply using broad statements and slick slogans to don't hold up in this situation.
mp15 Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='randy_the_clown' date='Feb 2 2005, 04:11 PM'] How can you be concerned about the future of the Church? Where is your faith? [/quote] I have faith in a lot of things, religious and outside the church. I also know the saying "the gates of hell shall not prevail", but I tell ya I'm not so sure. The devil is currently winning the battle for mankind. If you don't believe me then do as I've said and look around. The evidence aint hard to miss.
randy_the_clown Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote]but I tell ya I'm not so sure. The devil is currently winning the battle for mankind. If you don't believe me then do as I've said and look around. The evidence aint hard to miss. [/quote] MP, I don't know how the devil can win, since he has already lost. Also, don't be so hard on the world, after all, we don't belong here anyway. We were made for something more. I see victories all the time, and it just makes me work harder.
Oik Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 For what I read that Toledo and Dust and myself are saying, we are saying that LT is currently advoating abuse. What we are saying is that it did have abuse (which were corrected). [b]PLEASE READ CAREFULLY[/b] If the abuse occured, it is important to understand what was in the mentality of the program that would allow it. Fruthermore, is this something that might be harmful in teaching the faith. This is why people question the "right teaching" or Orthodoxy of LifeTeen. Hey, it's a legit issue. if yoy don't understand and/or can't hang, stop posting. As For LifeTeen, I went to Saint Timothy's (the Home parish of LifeTeen where Msgr. Dale, the founder of LifeTeen is the Pastor) for three years. I helped out with confirmation and attended LifeTeen retreats. I helped out was a LifeTeen core member for three years at another Parish close by. I have talked with Msgr. Dale a few times about certain litugical pratices. The man knows his stuff! He knows what he is doing. So, any real problems with LifeTeen, rightfully rest on his shoulders, he runs the program. I love LifeTeen. I believe LifeTeen will succeed and become [u]the[/u] ministry to Catholic youth in the United States. But not until it assures its orthodoxy. What has it done that doesn't assure it's Orthodoxy? Institute liturgical abuse. Did it correct those abuses? The head parish in Phoenix did. It even demanded that all LifeTeen parishes do so. That does not in and of it's self secure its Orthodoxy. Look, LifeTeen is almost 20years old! It has had plenty of time to correct any problems. Unfortunatly it has been slow in doing so (the liturgical abuses were corrected in Oct of 2004). I think it could be so much more already.
goldenchild17 Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 I'll stop posting here now. I've said what I've got to say. I see nothing wrong with the program or it's mass. Any problems they had in the past were wrong, but they've been condemned by the program. If this is not good enough for some of you, then there's nothing left to say about it.
mp15 Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 (edited) [quote name='randy_the_clown' date='Feb 2 2005, 04:50 PM'] MP, I don't know how the devil can win, since he has already lost. Also, don't be so hard on the world, after all, we don't belong here anyway. We were made for something more. I see victories all the time, and it just makes me work harder. [/quote] Yea he lost once, but the battle [b]is[/b] raging again. If you do not believe so then I don't know what to say other than don't be so naive. His presence is real. Maybe he is winning because people are so blind as to his presence. People are so self absorbed. It is a tool of his don't you know. The love of ones self over all things. That attitude I see every day from all walks of life. Kinda like the discussion that is going on in this thread. People want to be right, and they will argue it until their blue in the face, and that is precisely what Satan wants. He wants discord between the faithful because it leads away from God not closer to it. Satan has entered our Church, and he is here to wage war for our souls. Unite and it will survive, divide and he will win. Edited February 2, 2005 by mp15
cmotherofpirl Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='randy_the_clown' date='Feb 2 2005, 07:40 PM'] They don't authorize breathing, walking in doors, or what type of organ to have in the church either, but we do it. And you have not established that the change was deliberate disobedience or if they were simply following #38 of CoSL. I'm sorry, Mother of Phat, but you are simply using broad statements and slick slogans to don't hold up in this situation. [/quote] And you are using excuses to justify deliberate alteration of the Mass. There is no excuse for that.
Scofizzle Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 wow what a circular argument we have going here......well I'm no church scholar but let me take a crack at this...... these seem to be some of the main concerns...yes they are all from Mp 15 because this person seems to be especially spiteful towards Life Teen and The Church in America. [quote] Life Teen is yet another example of the decay that is happening within the American Church. It, along with other things, is moving the Church in America closer to Protestantism then ever. Don't believe it? Then your heads are stuck further in the ground than you'll ever realize. The Church in America is dying folks. Better wake up before it's too late.[/quote] There’s just one problem there. I don't know of any protestants who believe in the true presence of Christ in the Eucharist and since the Church in America is dying could you explain why our Parish and the other ones around us are going to either 1) expand all the churches in the area 2) open a new parish if the numbers grow at the current rate. In two years there won't be enough church space in a 30 mile radius for all the Catholics in that area. You want to see a Church that is "dying" look at the Church in England. And besides the Church cannot and will not die anywhere. "On this rock I will build my church and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it." Matthew 16:18 [quote]And why is it that teens need something special for them to get closer to Christ? Why is it that only American teens need something special? Why not the rest of the world as well? Is it maybe because American teens are a little shallow? If it doesn't make them "feel" good then we will lose them from the faith? Maybe instead of changing the Church we should start by changing American culture and family values. [/quote] Life Teen is not only in the US, but 18 other countries. So not just US teens need help in building a relationship with Christ. You can spearhead the changing of American values and I’ll be concerned about the souls of my fellow brothers and sisters in Christ. Here’s the deal some of the things in Life Teen do make you feel good, but you know what when I walk out of confession I feel good. But that does not drive my relationship with Christ. The feel good stuff is great!!!!! Awesome when that happens it can be an eye-opener. It give teens a hint into what Christ’s love is for us. We just have to accept it. (wow I know you’re going to try and attack this) what we do is after that initial conversion we build a relationship with the teens and lead the to the Eucharistic table. That’s what the goal is. Leading teens into a deeper relationship with Christ. [quote] We were doing just fine before Life Teen. If you say that we were not then I would counter by saying that it has more to do with a societal problem rather than a faith one. So in that sense, yes teens are a bit shallow as well as the American culture as a whole. [/quote] The Cathecatical programs around the country were failing. Don’t believe it look at how many 20 something’s whose faith is either dead or had to be taken into their own hands. All the help that we can give...we are obligated to give. [quote] All I'm saying is this; Why the need for a special mass for teens? Parents should be instructing their kids in the faith. If they were doing their parenting responsibilities correctly there wouldn't be a need for life teen.[/quote] There’s the problem. Many parents are not doing their job as the primary Catechists of today's teens. So what do we do? Say forget it and we'll try and change the parents so their next kids will know God? Do you do that for all those kids out there? On average 1/3 of Catholics actually attend Mass or have any Cathecatical formation. So those other 2/3 whose parents aren’t doing their job for one reason or another, what do we do about them? They need to be evangelized, Catechized, and loved. [quote]would say that from my perspective the biggest problem would be the liturgical abuses that are happening. I understand that they have been instructed to stop these but I have a hard time believing that all the abuses have stopped. .[/quote] Were happening would be the correct phrase. In our great city of Houston there are 30 something Life Teen parishes there are none, 0, none that still have teens gathering around the altar. I would be willing to wager that 95% of parishes who implement a Life Teen program have stopped the teens gathering around the altar and any other improper liturgical practices. [quote]My second biggest problem with it is this. What is it going to offer anyone once they reach adulthood? Beyond all the pop culture atmosphere (here today, gone tomorrow) I just can't see it having a lasting effect on a youth's life. It is all warm and fuzzy superficial fluff, like my protestant youth group I belonged to as a teen. It did nothing for my faith. I did get to hang out though, which I suspect is a reason a vast majority of teens like life teen. It just gives them another atmosphere in which they can socialize.[/quote] Life Teen is not just Mass. The Mass is the source and summit of our faith, but most of what Life Teen does happens outside of Mass. Life Nights for example usually happen directly after Mass are used to Catechize. So that our teens can use what they learn in Mass and take it out into the community with hearts of service and love. So they can have in increase in faith and knowledge and learn to love and serve our Lord. [quote]yep, and it has gotten the Roman Rite (more so the American Church) to the point it is today. Don't get me wrong, I do see some encouraging signs in some dioceses, but on the whole it is rotting from within especially in America. Only time will tell however. I hope and pray that the next pontiff is very Orthodox, because if he's not and his tendencies are more liberal then I will be even more concerned about the future of the Church.[/quote] Are you implying that our current Pope is not Orthodox? B/C if so you should re-evaluate your idea of Orthodoxy. The Church in America is strong and growing ever stronger and nothing shall defeat it. As a product of Life Teen and now a youth minister in a Life Teen Parish, I believe with everything in my being that Life Teen is a good and holy organization and ministry. no matter is said about Life Teen I will continue to do my work in the name of Christ. evangelizing, Catechizing, converting, serving and loving. Until either my times comes to leave this earth or I am asked to stop by my beloved Church.
mp15 Posted February 3, 2005 Posted February 3, 2005 (edited) [quote name='Scofizzle' date='Feb 2 2005, 05:27 PM'] wow what a circular argument we have going here......well I'm no church scholar but let me take a crack at this...... these seem to be some of the main concerns...yes they are all from Mp 15 because this person seems to be especially spiteful towards Life Teen and The Church in America. There’s just one problem there. I don't know of any protestants who believe in the true presence of Christ in the Eucharist and since the Church in America is dying could you explain why our Parish and the other ones around us are going to either 1) expand all the churches in the area 2) open a new parish if the numbers grow at the current rate. In two years there won't be enough church space in a 30 mile radius for all the Catholics in that area. You want to see a Church that is "dying" look at the Church in England. And besides the Church cannot and will not die anywhere. "On this rock I will build my church and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it." Matthew 16:18 Life Teen is not only in the US, but 18 other countries. So not just US teens need help in building a relationship with Christ. You can spearhead the changing of American values and I’ll be concerned about the souls of my fellow brothers and sisters in Christ. Here’s the deal some of the things in Life Teen do make you feel good, but you know what when I walk out of confession I feel good. But that does not drive my relationship with Christ. The feel good stuff is great!!!!! Awesome when that happens it can be an eye-opener. It give teens a hint into what Christ’s love is for us. We just have to accept it. (wow I know you’re going to try and attack this) what we do is after that initial conversion we build a relationship with the teens and lead the to the Eucharistic table. That’s what the goal is. Leading teens into a deeper relationship with Christ. The Cathecatical programs around the country were failing. Don’t believe it look at how many 20 something’s whose faith is either dead or had to be taken into their own hands. All the help that we can give...we are obligated to give. There’s the problem. Many parents are not doing their job as the primary Catechists of today's teens. So what do we do? Say forget it and we'll try and change the parents so their next kids will know God? Do you do that for all those kids out there? On average 1/3 of Catholics actually attend Mass or have any Cathecatical formation. So those other 2/3 whose parents aren’t doing their job for one reason or another, what do we do about them? They need to be evangelized, Catechized, and loved. Were happening would be the correct phrase. In our great city of Houston there are 30 something Life Teen parishes there are none, 0, none that still have teens gathering around the altar. I would be willing to wager that 95% of parishes who implement a Life Teen program have stopped the teens gathering around the altar and any other improper liturgical practices. Life Teen is not just Mass. The Mass is the source and summit of our faith, but most of what Life Teen does happens outside of Mass. Life Nights for example usually happen directly after Mass are used to Catechize. So that our teens can use what they learn in Mass and take it out into the community with hearts of service and love. So they can have in increase in faith and knowledge and learn to love and serve our Lord. Are you implying that our current Pope is not Orthodox? B/C if so you should re-evaluate your idea of Orthodoxy. The Church in America is strong and growing ever stronger and nothing shall defeat it. As a product of Life Teen and now a youth minister in a Life Teen Parish, I believe with everything in my being that Life Teen is a good and holy organization and ministry. no matter is said about Life Teen I will continue to do my work in the name of Christ. evangelizing, Catechizing, converting, serving and loving. Until either my times comes to leave this earth or I am asked to stop by my beloved Church. [/quote] Wow thanks; I didn't know I deserved such attention. Don't think real highly of me do you? That's fine; I'm loved by those I care to be loved by anyway. Just re-read my post before this one. Church unity will never happen with Lifeteen around, and as I said, Satan has an awfully large grin on his face because of it. I also never said that JPII was not Orthodox. If you could clear your Self-righteousness from your mind you will see that I never said that. What I did say however is that if the next Pope leans to the left then there will be even further discord within the Church. Nothing more was implied except by you. Have a nice day. Edited February 3, 2005 by mp15
Scofizzle Posted February 3, 2005 Posted February 3, 2005 No I don't think any less of you...I just adressed you because you made all the points everyone was talking about and it makes them easier to find in this long thread. There is no division about Life Teen in my parish. It is a good thing. It is also important to realize that every Life Teen Parish is different in how they do things. We are all just united under one name. I think it is awfully rude to say that because of Life Teen there will never be church unity. B/c even if Life Teen wasnt around there would still be division. also I dont appreciate being called self righteous....this is a debate we are having.......a simple question was asked and an explanation given if the question was indeed posed. I also don't appreciate the tone in which you have addressed me. A civilized debate can take place and would hope that it does.
jezic Posted February 3, 2005 Posted February 3, 2005 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Feb 2 2005, 05:18 PM'] And nowhere in the GIRM was such a practice authorized. As I said before you don't change part of the Mass , and then seek an indult to justify your behavior. Just because the early church did it is no excuse to take matters into your own hands and authority. [/quote] Question though, if lifeteen can't change it because it was written in the GIRM, why did the GIRM leave it out? Is there proof it is from the early church? if it is then how can we condemn it?
mp15 Posted February 3, 2005 Posted February 3, 2005 [quote]I think it is awfully rude to say that because of Life Teen there will never be church unity. B/c even if Life Teen wasnt around there would still be division.[/quote] Ahhhh, which is exactly what I've been saying Satan wants. Satan wins as long as there is division. Division happens when the Church leaders don't lay things out in absolutes. Lifeteen was permitted, abuses and all at first. Now there is probably no going back. Give something or someone an inch, and they will take it a mile. Which is exactly wahat has been happening ever since Vatican II. I will be the first to admit that Vatican II was a deep and profound thing, but the way it has been interpreted up to this point is not. [quote]also I dont appreciate being called self righteous....this is a debate we are having.......a simple question was asked and an explanation given if the question was indeed posed. I also don't appreciate the tone in which you have addressed me. A civilized debate can take place and would hope that it does.[/quote] I'm sorry if you think that I wasn't being civil. I can assure you that I was. You haven't been around this board long enough to see the other side of my civility. Hopefully that will never rear it's ugly head again.
randy_the_clown Posted February 3, 2005 Posted February 3, 2005 (edited) I'll let Scofizzle deal with MP because he is obviously on the verge of a schism if the next Pope doesn't lean his way. (By the way, should I point out that Popes don't lean? They are simply the Church? It is impossible for the central Authority to lean away from itself because that suggests a duality. I understand bad popes, etc... but I assume that MC is talking about doxy and praxis.) Mother of Phat, Can you please engage in any kind of evidence building or debate using reason instead of the simple approach? Please do NOT repeat the following: [quote]And you are using excuses to justify deliberate alteration of the Mass. There is no excuse for that. [/quote] You have said that a number of times. I would submit to you who claim to have personal contact with the founder to give one instance where he deliberately went against the teachings of the church (doxy) or against his bishop in practice (praxis). I think that speaks of the doxy alone. Also, the organization has a representative to the bishops who's sole purpose is to make sure that EVERY periodical that goes out is in line with Catholic teaching. Sounds like 20 years of Orthodoxy to me, unless someone can quote one publication that has come out that has gone against the CCC, Vatican, or USCCB. There was a situation in Atlanta where abuses where taking place with people around the Altar for the EP and the Archbishop said that the diocese was to stop the practice in all cases. He deliberately called LT on his own to say that they were NOT the reason for the decision. EVERY LT parish in the diocese IMMEDIATELY obeyed the local. According to Canon, THIS is the proper way for resolving disputes in liturgy and from day one, LT has ALWAYS maintained that no matter what, follow the guide of your local Bishop who has the authority on the celebration of the liturgy. That means, Mother, MP, and everyone else, that in order for a "liturgical abuse" to take place, it would have to fly in the face of the guide of the local bishop who is responsible for catechesis and distribution of the GIRM. In THIS situation, you CANNOT say that LT is either 1. Non-Orthodox or 2. Non-Orthopraxis. You cannot even say that they are culpable for "abuses" pre-2003 due to the fact that they ALWAYS required submission to the authority of the local ordinary, even their own. It was that THEIR invitation that Bishop Moroney came in. It was at THEIR invitation that Cardinal Arinze took a look at what they were doing. It was at THEIR request that Bishop Olmstead review what they were doing when he took the seat in Phoenix. And just because you are asked to change, doesn't mean that what you were doing before was wrong. It was permitted by the ordinary. Now, one may ask, why didn't they go to the Vatican or USCCB in 1985? Because, quite simply, they were one parish until 1989. Even then, they simply asked people to submit to the ordinary, but this is what they were doing at St. Timothy's. Check Canon Law. Check the GIRM from the time. Finally, I submit to you that LT has been Orthodox and Orthopraxis from THE BEGINNING and if you are going to continue to debate this fact in this thread, then you better start offering some hard evidence other than a self-biased, righteous opinion based on hearsay. Edited February 3, 2005 by randy_the_clown
popestpiusx Posted February 3, 2005 Posted February 3, 2005 A few quick points: 1)There is no evidence that the early Church gathered around the altar during the consecration. That is a lie spread my modernist liturgists who have been pushing their agenda for several decades with great success. 2)The Church is guranteed never to fail in the sense that it will never cease to exist somewhere. It is not guranteed to exist everywhere. The Church in the US (or anywhere else for that matter) could cease to exist. History shows this quite clearly to be the case. 3)The health of the Church is not weighed entirely by quantity, but by quality. In this sense, the Church in this country is dying, though one could argue that the bleeding has been slowed to some extent in the last 10 years or so. 4)The Pope is not The Church. He is the visible head of the Church. But that does not take away his personal freedom to hold heretical positions or "lean left" on any number of issues. He is simply prevented from formally teaching heresy and from doing anything that would lead to the total destruction of the Church. The Church is the mystical Body of Christ, perfect and spotless. The Pope is not the Mystical Body of Christ, nor is he perfect or spotless (which the current Holy Father would be the first to admit, humble man that he is.) 5)#38 of the Constitution on the Liturgy has been used by every group and movement that wants to push some novelty. It doesn't work that way. The constitution laid a framework for the reform. (Whether that reform stayed within the framework is an interesting topic but one which we shall not here discuss). It was not a "personal guide to creating liturgy". The reform was to be enacted by the Church, not on personal initiative. To go further than the reform, without expressed permission in the form of an indult, is a violation of liturgical law, no matter how strongly one "feels" about it.
popestpiusx Posted February 3, 2005 Posted February 3, 2005 And one more point: The Bishop of a diocese is the guardian of doctrine and liturgy, not the creator. He only has authority to alter the liturgy insofar as that authority has been given to him. He can only order you to do (or permit you to do) what he has the authority to order or pemit. His authority does not trump the Girm. So, for instance, when the Bishop tells me that I must stand for Communion, and Rome (specifically Cardinal Arinze, who was rather upset with the situation) tells me that I may kneel for Communion, I do not have to obey the bishop. I will obey Rome.
jgirl Posted February 3, 2005 Posted February 3, 2005 My final comments before I bow out: *Somebody mentioned that nowehere else will you find teens flocking to a Church except in the US. It's interesting to note that Life Teen has caught on in the [url="http://www.life-teen.nl/"]Netherlands[/url] (a country where religion is practically dead, along with all the sick people from euthanasia on demand). It's even more interesting to note that it is promoted by the Carmelites of the Divine Heart of Jesus who are [b]very[/b] POD. * The only issue anybody can bring up is the music. Life Teen fixed the problems, which weren't even occuring everywhere (one parish where I was on core, there was no altar gathering and the ending was always the same). So music is the main issue. *Why do teenagers need their own thing. 1) Catholic schools can't be counted on to teach the faith 2) The parents of current teens were educated post Vatican II, so lots of them don't necessarily know the faith 3) It's kind of like Young Life; It reaches out to the unchurched. Teens who might not know anything about the faith come, and they are drawn to it. While I was a teen, two other teens converted to Catholicism (and one of them is discerning the priesthood). 4) For those teens who know the faith, the program offers them an environment where they are challenged to do more, to go deeper, and to learn more about the faith 5) It's an environment that isn't hostile to them. The secular world is pretty hostile. We have companies like Abercrombie that advertise for their clothes with nearly naked men standing outside the store and teen/fashion magazines telling us we are fat if we weigh over 100 pounds. Life Teen is a support network. I have an awesome group of friends from Life Teen who I still hang out with five years later. *Life Teen is centered around the Eucharist. The programs only work if there is a regular Mass. We have adoration after a lot of our life nights, and the teens appreciate it! We have our own Life Teen holy hour on the First Fridays (which is pretty POD for teens to look forward to First Friday devotions). It's not purely emotional. I would say that very few of you have attended a Life Night. They are 100% in line with Church teaching, and they help the teens realize why we believe what we believe, why we do the things we do, and how to approach daily life with its joys and struggles to live an authentically Catholic life. If you don't like the Life Teen music, then don't go to the Mass. It's pretty simple. Don't knock it though. It's probably one of the major contributors to the increased interest in vocations. The parish where I was a teen has had one girl enter the religious life, at least 6 guys go to the seminary, and one to the Jesuits. I'm in the process of applying to enter a religious order when my loans are paid off. At the parish where I am currently on Life Teen core, we have one guy starting seminary this summer, two more who are younger who are seriously thinking about the priesthood (one sophomore is looking at being a religious priest), and a few girls who are showing interest in the religious life. I would hardly call that causing harm to the Church.
toledo_jesus Posted February 3, 2005 Posted February 3, 2005 from another thread: In his book, The Spirit of the Liturgy (Ignatius Press, 2000), Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger states clearly that popular music does not belong at Mass. Indeed, it's part of "a cult of the banal," and "rock" plainly stands "in opposition to Christian worship." trust a churchman to come up with the right word: banal.
Scofizzle Posted February 3, 2005 Posted February 3, 2005 [quote name='mp15' date='Feb 2 2005, 08:49 PM'] I'm sorry if you think that I wasn't being civil. I can assure you that I was. You haven't been around this board long enough to see the other side of my civility. Hopefully that will never rear it's ugly head again. [/quote] Ok then....i just think some of the language has become confusing and may seem a little harsh at times b/c this is not the spoken word but the written. As long as there are no hard feelings.
Scofizzle Posted February 3, 2005 Posted February 3, 2005 (edited) [quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Feb 3 2005, 01:13 AM'] from another thread: In his book, The Spirit of the Liturgy (Ignatius Press, 2000), Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger states clearly that popular music does not belong at Mass. Indeed, it's part of "a cult of the banal," and "rock" plainly stands "in opposition to Christian worship." trust a churchman to come up with the right word: banal. [/quote] Correct Cardinal Ratzinger is an amazing man. That is why Life Teen does use "rock" or "popular music." Edited February 3, 2005 by Scofizzle
Scofizzle Posted February 3, 2005 Posted February 3, 2005 Difference of opinion does not always equate to a division in the Chruch.
Recommended Posts