Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='popestpiusx' date='Feb 1 2005, 06:02 PM'] Give an intellectual defense of Lifteen based on the constant teaching and practice of the Church. Getting defensive does nothing.

[/quote]
are we not allowed to get deffensive?

let me just say, if it weren't for lifeteen, i'd still be an atheist. <_<

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

everyone needs to follow the guidelines and play nice.

Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Feb 1 2005, 06:00 PM'] what? the altar call is gone isn't it? so they need to update their website. [/quote]
oh.....it wasn't in reply to you :P

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

oh and that goes for everyone

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Feb 1 2005, 06:00 PM'] what? the altar call is gone isn't it? so they need to update their website. [/quote]
word.

Posted

[quote name='rachael' date='Feb 1 2005, 07:04 PM'] are we not allowed to get deffensive?

let me just say, if it weren't for lifeteen, i'd still be an atheist. <_< [/quote]
well then it has done some good. But you have to be able to defend Lifeteen with more than emotion.

Posted

[quote name='popestpiusx' date='Feb 1 2005, 08:02 PM'] Dust did not declare the debate over (yet). He said we are not going to get into a debate about which Mass is better (in the sense of Tridentine vs. Novus). There is nothing wrong with debating the merits of Lifeteen or any other movement. You people are getting all touchy about it because it is something you like. Then answer my challenge. Give an intellectual defense of Lifteen based on the constant teaching and practice of the Church. Getting defensive does nothing.

Pius,
Take it easy. I don't want this to get shut down. [/quote]
I'm not going to debate this with you because it's unnecessary. Nothing I say will change your mind and vice-versa.

-Mark

Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Feb 1 2005, 06:13 PM'] well then it has done some good. But you have to be able to defend Lifeteen with more than emotion. [/quote]
why should i have to defend when all you'll do is bash it again? it's a waste of my time.

Posted

OK how would you propose we defend LIFETEEN? It's kind of hard to site any sources you would deem acceptable because there has been no fromal statement from the Vatican.

So let us defend LIFETEEN by its fruits. Several people on this board we brougth closer to Christ in a LIFETEEN program. Millions of teens around the world are doing the same. Many Vocations to the Preisthood are coming out of LIFETTEEN based Cathechesis programs. What more proof are you asking for?

Posted

[quote name='geetarplayer' date='Feb 1 2005, 07:15 PM'] I'm not going to debate this with you because it's unnecessary. Nothing I say will change your mind and vice-versa.

-Mark [/quote]
I've already said that if you can defend it based on the principles of the Church, I will gladly change my mind. Let's not jump to conclusions here.

Posted

[quote name='rachael' date='Feb 1 2005, 07:15 PM'] why should i have to defend when all you'll do is bash it again? it's a waste of my time. [/quote]
i'm not bashing it. these are legitimate questions that you should be asking yourself. If you can't defend it with any Church teachings, then that's an indication it may not be all that.

Posted

What I don't understand is how you would expect us to defend a relational ministry for teenagers with church teaching?

The mass is mass. LIFETEEN mass is the same as any other Mass just different music. Not really conprehending what you want from us here.

Posted

[quote name='Scofizzle' date='Feb 1 2005, 07:19 PM'] OK how would you propose we defend LIFETEEN? It's kind of hard to site any sources you would deem acceptable because there has been no fromal statement from the Vatican.
[/quote]
The Vatican will be using the same Church teachings to make a decision as are available to us both. They have already said that some practices Lifeteen engaged in were wrong. what was the cause of those practices? a prevalent attitude of irreverence may indeed lie at the heart of it. I do not mean that Lifeteen advocates irreverence, but it may encourage it by tailoring the Mass for the teens.

Posted

[quote name='Scofizzle' date='Feb 1 2005, 06:32 PM'] What I don't understand is how you would expect us to defend a relational ministry for teenagers with church teaching?

The mass is mass. LIFETEEN mass is the same as any other Mass just different music. Not really conprehending what you want from us here. [/quote]
my point exactly.

Posted

[quote name='Scofizzle' date='Feb 1 2005, 07:32 PM'] Not really conprehending what you want from us here. [/quote]
I know you're not.

Posted

[quote name='popestpiusx' date='Feb 1 2005, 08:27 PM'] I've already said that if you can defend it based on the principles of the Church, I will gladly change my mind. Let's not jump to conclusions here. [/quote]
Well, I haven't done any research or anything. :rolleyes: Buuuut off the top of my head I can tell you that they enthusiastically promote (in no particular order) the Eucharist, the sacraments, the communion of saints, vocations, the rosary, and the sanctity of life. Also, they frequently exercise charismatic prayer.

-Mark

Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Feb 1 2005, 06:33 PM'] They have already said that some practices Lifeteen engaged in were wrong.  what was the cause of those practices?  a prevalent attitude of irreverence may indeed lie at the heart of it. [/quote]
but they've efforts to change and succeed for the most part, so why can't you drop the issue?

Posted

[quote name='rachael' date='Feb 1 2005, 07:35 PM'] but they've efforts to change and succeed for the most part, so why can't you drop the issue? [/quote]
ok, simply, it's like telling a child not to talk back. He stops. But what made him talk back in the first place? If you figure out what caused his bad behavior, you prevent future bad behavior.

So if you figure out why Lifeteen felt the urge to play with Mass, then you can better understand how to improve it.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Scofizzle' date='Feb 1 2005, 07:19 PM'] OK how would you propose we defend LIFETEEN? It's kind of hard to site any sources you would deem acceptable because there has been no fromal statement from the Vatican.

So let us defend LIFETEEN by its fruits. Several people on this board we brougth closer to Christ in a LIFETEEN program. Millions of teens around the world are doing the same. Many Vocations to the Preisthood are coming out of LIFETTEEN based Cathechesis programs. What more proof are you asking for? [/quote]
I could say the same in each of these categories for the Society of St. Pius X. I hardly think anyone on here is prepared to say they are to be recommended as a result. There are also false apparitions all over the place that often times lead to many conversions (Bayside and Necedah for example). Are we to recommend them to people?

Good Fruits are sometimes a sign of a good thing, but they are not conclusive in themselves. Sometimes good is brought out of these things in spite of them, but not because of them. What we are asking for is to show how Lifeteen conforms to the principles that have been described several times already. We're not asking for magisterial documentation; rather, something much more basic. How is this idea of changing the liturgy to make it more attractive to some specific age group a Catholic idea?

Edited by popestpiusx
Posted
:rolleyes:

this thread has turned into another stupid lifeteen argument. if you like lifeteen, good for you. if you have issues with it, good for you too. lifeteen has changed many people's lives. so drop it.
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...