toledo_jesus Posted February 1, 2005 Posted February 1, 2005 [quote name='rachael' date='Feb 1 2005, 07:41 PM'] this thread has turned into another stupid lifeteen argument. if you like lifeteen, good for you. if you have issues with it, good for you too. lifeteen has changed many people's lives. so drop it. [/quote] if it does damage to the Faith then it is not something to just drop.
popestpiusx Posted February 1, 2005 Posted February 1, 2005 Rachael, with all due respect, that's a copout. If it is so obvious, and if it is so very stupid to discuss it, then by all means enlighten those of us who are ignorant. I already said that I will change my mind as soon as someone can give a Catholic answer. All we have seen so far is a bunch of people getting hot and bothered, but refusing to address any of the problems or questions. Please, for the sake of us who do not understand, explain it.
rachael Posted February 1, 2005 Posted February 1, 2005 [quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Feb 1 2005, 06:43 PM'] if it does damage to the Faith then it is not something to just drop. [/quote] how is it doing damaging to the faith? by bringing people into the faith?
rachael Posted February 1, 2005 Posted February 1, 2005 look, i still don't know what issues you guys seem to have with it. you just keep on telling us it's wrong. how can we defend ourselves upon that?
popestpiusx Posted February 1, 2005 Posted February 1, 2005 I think you need to re-read what's been posted. We have pointed out several things.
rachael Posted February 1, 2005 Posted February 1, 2005 [quote name='BurkeFan' date='Jan 31 2005, 08:11 PM'] Question: (and i mean this in a nonconfrontary manner) Do you lifeteeners ever see moving beyond Lifeteen Masses? I mean, what kind of Mass do you see yourself attending in college? After college? [/quote] i go to regular masses too
rachael Posted February 1, 2005 Posted February 1, 2005 [quote name='popestpiusx' date='Feb 1 2005, 06:53 PM'] I think you need to re-read what's been posted. We have pointed out several things. [/quote] i see that you guys have problems with moderinity and the music. the only thing i see modern about it is the music.... (at least in my church) now, i could defend this all i want, but you are still going to disagree with me and that's why it's a waste of my time. so let's just agree to disagree. ok? -_-
musturde Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Feb 1 2005, 06:43 PM'] if it does damage to the Faith then it is not something to just drop. [/quote] I don't think the Pope would bless it if it did that.
Scofizzle Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 (edited) [quote name='popestpiusx' date='Feb 1 2005, 06:40 PM'] How is this idea of changing the liturgy to make it more attractive to some specific age group a Catholic idea? [/quote] the idea of changing the Mass is wrong. Life Teens HQ in Arizona has corrected their mistake. (Which our program never really participated in the first place.) The only differences between a mass the is labeled a Life Teen mass and any other Mass are: 1) The Music 2) The Focus of the homily 1) The music that is selected for any mass is based on (or should be based on) the need of the community. The music in Mass is not for entertainment’s sake. It is used as an aide in prayer. This is why a Life Teen Mass (for example) usually incorporates more contemporary music. Not because it sounds cooler, but because the community chooses to worship in that particular way. Many teens while in search of the Truth choose to use Praise and Worship as a form of prayer. For many of them this is a very easy way for them to pray and something they understand. This is why many Life Teen Masses incorporate praise and worship music. At my parish for example, Music is selected in accordance with the themes for the readings in the mass. i.e. mercy, love, compassion, trust...whatever. It's all about prayer. 2) At my parish the pastor and assistant pastor do 5 masses on Sundays between the two of them. The same homily is given at each mass with the same facts and same teaching. At the 7:00 AM mass (which tends to be older parishioners) the homily if focused on the concerns of that community. At the 8:00 Spanish Mass the homily is given to address that communities needs. At the 9:45 mass the homily is given in a more "family friendly" approach. At the 11:00 mass the Homily is more watered down and basic. At the 5:00 Life Teen Mass the homily addresses the needs of the community. Just like at every other mass. Again waht I'm am trying to stress is there is no Liturgical differences in the Mass. I guess a Life Teen Mass goer simply prefers a guitar to an organ. Edited February 2, 2005 by Scofizzle
geetarplayer Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='BurkeFan' date='Feb 1 2005, 01:09 AM']He and I have talked on this before, and his opinion (from which I got my opinion, since I kind of skipped the Life Teen phase) was that Life Teen can be a useful stepping stone into the more traditional forms of worship. I can ask him a bit more indepth, if you'd like, but that's about the best summary that I can come up with. Basically, Life Teen should be seen as a transition into the standard / traditional Mass instead of as an end in itself.[/quote] Out of all the posts in this topic, this one makes the most sense to me. And I'd like to think that this is an accurate description of LifeTeen at its present state. I can say this with confidence now that there are less abuses in the LifeTeen mass. As I was saying in an AIM conversation with rachael, I think LifeTeen is about bringing teens further into the Church and pointing them in the right direction; namely, towards Scripture, tradition, the Eucharist, and the Church's teachings on morality, just to name a few. There is a lot of good that LifeTeen can do and does do regularly for teens who don't know their faith. For those who already have a strong faith--teen and nonteen alike--LifeTeen may not seem so spectacular. For example, I have a friend who is 15 years old. She has a large Catholic family. She is very orthodox. She said that she doesn't go to LifeTeen because she isn't comfortable with charismatic prayer. That doesn't bother me, though, because she goes to Mass every week and prays the rosary every night with her whole family. Anyway, I think LifeTeen does a good job in doing what they say they do: leading teens closer to Christ. As for the music... as a liturgical musician, it is hard for me to think that all the prayerful music ceased to be written ten or twenty years ago. -Mark
rachael Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='geetarplayer' date='Feb 1 2005, 07:19 PM'] As for the music... as a liturgical musician, it is hard for me to think that all the prayerful music ceased to be written ten or twenty years ago. -Mark [/quote]
Scofizzle Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='geetarplayer' date='Feb 1 2005, 07:19 PM'] As for the music... as a liturgical musician, it is hard for me to think that all the prayerful music ceased to be written ten or twenty years ago. -Mark [/quote] well said
popestpiusx Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='geetarplayer' date='Feb 1 2005, 08:19 PM'] As for the music... as a liturgical musician, it is hard for me to think that all the prayerful music ceased to be written ten or twenty years ago. [/quote] I don't recall anyone suggesting that it had.
toledo_jesus Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='popestpiusx' date='Feb 1 2005, 11:23 PM'] I don't recall anyone suggesting that it had. [/quote] i'll suggest that the quality has gone down a great deal. If I never hear another song by David Haas or Marty Haugen, it'll be too soon.
goldenchild17 Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 (edited) [quote name='geetarplayer' date='Feb 1 2005, 07:19 PM'] Out of all the posts in this topic, this one makes the most sense to me. And I'd like to think that this is an accurate description of LifeTeen at its present state. [/quote] Why is it a stepping stone? Why is it appropriate in forming the faith of teens but not adults? If it is not good enough for the adult community, then it shouldn't be good enough for the teenage community. You can't have it both ways. If it is a legit mass, and they have fixed their problems and the Pope has blessed it, then I can't see any reason why their is a problem with it. Again, the Church herself has been through some rough times, we've seen Pope committing all sorts of grave sins, and these were horribly wrong. Does this condemn the Papacy? I would think not. The Papacy had abuses that needed fixed. They were fixed, and we have(hopefully) moved on. Do we hold the current Pope accountable for actions committed in the past? Of course not. Why do you use a double standard with a practice within the Church, that has done much good in bringing people to the Church? and to what Toledo Jesus said: [quote]The Vatican will be using the same Church teachings to make a decision as are available to us both. They have already said that some practices Lifeteen engaged in were wrong. what was the cause of those practices? a prevalent attitude of irreverence may indeed lie at the heart of it. I do not mean that Lifeteen advocates irreverence, but it may encourage it by tailoring the Mass for the teens.[/quote] So, using the same logic, there is something at the heart of the Papacy that must be wrong? After all, they did some pretty bad stuff. What was the cause of those practices? Do they exist today in the Papacy? If not, then why do you use a double standard? Edited February 2, 2005 by goldenchild17
jmjtina Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 (edited) No matter what youth program you have, it depends on the people who run it. It can be a "click" for some. A loving faithful community for others. Lifteen or CYO, pray for your youth group because every youth group needs your prayers. As far as music wise, alot of contempary music does have us singing during Mass about eating bread and wine......yeah great theology.....if your Protestant. Personally, some people like that stuff during Mass, but since I hear it on the radio enough already, it makes it less sacred....IMHO. All that's missing is John and Cherry...... Some people will like it, some people won't. But understand why they don't like it. It's not because they hate the youth. In fact, it's concern for the youth that propels most people to be so vocal about it, since the altar calls were stopped recently by a statement from Rome. As long as the altar calls stopped, and obidence to the Church is emphasized, along with the Eucharist, I no longer have a problem with lifeteen. I do have a problem with ANY youth program that caters soley to the needs of the youth during the Mass rather than educating them on the faith and teaching them to love the Mass as it is. It's not Burger King, you don't get it your way. It's the Catholic Church. Pax. Edited February 2, 2005 by jmjtina
missionarybelle Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 At our Church we don't have Life Teen but our Church is on a college campus so our 6 pm Mass Is more upbeat and has some of my favrite worship songs. This past Sunday, was the closing Mass for a huge Catholic college student confrence and it was one of the most beautiful Masses I have ever been to! It was amazing to see almost 300 students praising God!! the music was very upbeat, but the Mass itself was EXACTLY the same! We had some visiting priests so we were able to have 3 priests celebrating Mass plus we had three guy students alter serve and so it was extremly Catholic and like its always been except that the music was a little more upbeat than usual. having the music so charismatic helped charge me up and make me on fire for God and pumped!
FiZzGiG Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 I'm gonna put in a word [quote]Why is it a stepping stone? Why is it appropriate in forming the faith of teens but not adults? If it is not good enough for the adult community, then it shouldn't be good enough for the teenage community. You can't have it both ways.[/quote] Well, I will answer your question with a question. How do you know that adults don't use LIFETEEN as a stepping stone as well? I was just thinking... could Protestant converts, (many are so used to the praise and worship type-prayer), use the LIFETEEN mass as a transition (stepping stone) to the traditional mass? Or perhaps not just Protestants. Maybe even adults who had left the faith, but now wished to return. Perhaps, LIFETEEN can ease them back in to what was lost to them for so long. Just a thought. I agree with Scofizzle's post earlier. The differences are the music and the homilies (now that the abuses have been corrected, halleluia), and the music, as he said, is directed more towards praise-and-worship. It's more charismatic. But, I also agree that LIFETEEN is a stepping stone. I've been attending it, and now I am fully present and reverent at all kinds of masses (i love em all!). In fact, since I go to a Catholic school, I go to masses every Tuesday at lunch, where there is no music at all. But it's just as beautiful! :wub:
kateri05 Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 (edited) in response to Fizzgig about stepping stones for adults as well: i wholeheartedly agree. i've had multiple catholic converts or catholic reverts at my new lifeteen parish say that LIFETEEN is the reason that they converted/came back. however, the problem is that these same people talk about how the Mass makes them feel, including the altar call which they "voted" to reinstitute because our cardinal said that they can do (fortunately we haven't started doing it again and i'm praying it stays that way!). but the whole feeling element that is emphasized i have a real problem with. as a youth minister, i know that if the kids (OR adults) come to LIFEnights, etc, they get good teaching and learn to love the Mass for what it is, not what it does but what about all those people who come to LIFETEEN mass cuz it makes them feel good and its "upbeat" and thats it? what happens when that Mass goes away or they move to a non-LIFETEEN parish or they go on vacation. if mass doens't feel good, they won't go. i'm not anti-LIFETEEN (im a LT YM) i'm just wary of the LT approach to liturgy because the heart of liturgy: reverent worship of God, gets lost in too much feel good, touchy feely, hands-open stuff (and all the LT adults, even in Mesa, do that, so i don't think its something they "outgrow"). although i guess you could argue that its charasmatic.... i don't know. it just doesn't match my concept of reverence or wonder and awe. lol although really, what is "my concept" really worth? lol, too many quotations in this post Edited February 2, 2005 by kateri05
goldenchild17 Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote]Well, I will answer your question with a question. How do you know that adults don't use LIFETEEN as a stepping stone as well?[/quote] I never said they didn't. [quote]I was just thinking... could Protestant converts, (many are so used to the praise and worship type-prayer), use the LIFETEEN mass as a transition (stepping stone) to the traditional mass? Or perhaps not just Protestants. Maybe even adults who had left the faith, but now wished to return. Perhaps, LIFETEEN can ease them back in to what was lost to them for so long.[/quote] My point is, is the thought of this Mass being just a stepping stone is using an attitude that portrays that you don't believe the Lifeteen Mass to be as good of a Mass as a traditional one. Why is the Traditional Mass any better? If they are both in accordance with the Church, then what would make one better than the other? Sure it can and should be used as a stepping stone and make one love the other masses more. But why can't a person stay on the stone? If one finds the Lifeteen Mass to be their favorite, most beautiful Mass, then why should they be obligated to "move on" to something more "better"?
Recommended Posts