randy_the_clown Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 LT never went against the GIRM. And before everyone jumps on that with the "WHAT ABOUT THE CHANGES THAT WERE MADE!" you need to understand that at the time LT was seeking, along with the USCCB an indult from the Vatican. This is a common practice. You also need to look up "customs" in Canon Law to find that if a practice exists for 30 years in a an area or in a culture, then it becomes a custom that is included in the liturgy. Besides, to quote the founder of LT: "if our whole ministry is based on having teens around the altar, then we aren't doing a very good job."
rachael Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='randy_the_clown' date='Feb 2 2005, 04:11 PM'] LT never went against the GIRM. And before everyone jumps on that with the "WHAT ABOUT THE CHANGES THAT WERE MADE!" you need to understand that at the time LT was seeking, along with the USCCB an indult from the Vatican. This is a common practice. You also need to look up "customs" in Canon Law to find that if a practice exists for 30 years in a an area or in a culture, then it becomes a custom that is included in the liturgy. Besides, to quote the founder of LT: "if our whole ministry is based on having teens around the altar, then we aren't doing a very good job." [/quote] You, know what? I'm all for Lifeteen (seeing as how I'm a part of it). But, LT isn't perfect. That's what I'm saying. sheesh
randy_the_clown Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 Actually Rachel, most of my posts on this page were geared at MP and Oily, not you... I just wanted to jump on the MORE orthodox statement before they pulled a, "see, even YOU agree it isn't orthodox!" I was really saving you!
rachael Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='randy_the_clown' date='Feb 2 2005, 04:23 PM'] Actually Rachel, most of my posts on this page were geared at MP and Oily, not you... I just wanted to jump on the MORE orthodox statement before they pulled a, "see, even YOU agree it isn't orthodox!" I was really saving you! [/quote] I'm so confused
popestpiusx Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='randy_the_clown' date='Feb 2 2005, 05:11 PM'] LT never went against the GIRM. And before everyone jumps on that with the "WHAT ABOUT THE CHANGES THAT WERE MADE!" you need to understand that at the time LT was seeking, along with the USCCB an indult from the Vatican. This is a common practice. You also need to look up "customs" in Canon Law to find that if a practice exists for 30 years in a an area or in a culture, then it becomes a custom that is included in the liturgy. Besides, to quote the founder of LT: "if our whole ministry is based on having teens around the altar, then we aren't doing a very good job." [/quote] So you are taking the "Employ the abuse long enough and it will become a custom" trick. How very original. The left has been doing this for forty years.
geetarplayer Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 (edited) This thread is getting very annoying. The logic and the semantics are running in circles. The internet is hardly the ideal place for this discussion. NOTHING ABOUT LIFETEEN WILL CHANGE as a result of this thread. Both sides of this argument (leading teens closer to Christ vs. abuses) are right to a degree. I think it's safe to say that neither side will be changing their mind anytime soon. It is only causing further division between us. I have nothing further to contribute here. -Mark Edited February 2, 2005 by geetarplayer
cmotherofpirl Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='randy_the_clown' date='Feb 2 2005, 06:11 PM'] LT never went against the GIRM. And before everyone jumps on that with the "WHAT ABOUT THE CHANGES THAT WERE MADE!" you need to understand that at the time LT was seeking, along with the USCCB an indult from the Vatican. This is a common practice. You also need to look up "customs" in Canon Law to find that if a practice exists for 30 years in a an area or in a culture, then it becomes a custom that is included in the liturgy. [/quote] Of course it did. Nowhere has anybody given permission for teens to gather around the altar. And you need to understand you don't change the Mass and then seek an indult to justify your disobedient behavior.
rachael Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='geetarplayer' date='Feb 2 2005, 04:38 PM'] This thread is getting very annoying. The logic and the semantics are running in circles. The internet is hardly the ideal place for this discussion. NOTHING ABOUT LIFETEEN WILL CHANGE as a result of this thread. Both sides are right to a degree. I think it's safe to say that neither side will be changing their mind anytime soon. It is only causing further division between us. I have nothing further to contribute here. -Mark [/quote] ditto. :leave:
Ora et Labora Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 I do not believe in lifeteen Masses. The music...in my opinion...is very inapropiate for a Mass. And there is clapping... -_- We go to Mass to re-enact the SACRIFICE at Calvery. It wasnt a celebration. Lifeteen Masses are giving teenagers the wrong idea. -_- I go to a Tridentine Mass. My whole family is very traditional.
Ora et Labora Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='geetarplayer' date='Feb 2 2005, 04:38 PM'] This thread is getting very annoying. The logic and the semantics are running in circles. The internet is hardly the ideal place for this discussion. NOTHING ABOUT LIFETEEN WILL CHANGE as a result of this thread. Both sides of this argument (leading teens closer to Christ vs. abuses) are right to a degree. I think it's safe to say that neither side will be changing their mind anytime soon. It is only causing further division between us. I have nothing further to contribute here. -Mark [/quote] On the contrary, Mark. I think it is good for teenagers to learn both sides.
BurkeFan Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='randy_the_clown' date='Feb 2 2005, 04:04 PM'] First of all, the definition of Orthodox means "right practice." [/quote] No, it doesn't. Right practice is orthopraxis. Orthodox means right teaching / thought.
mp15 Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='popestpiusx' date='Feb 2 2005, 03:30 PM'] So you are taking the "Employ the abuse long enough and it will become a custom" trick. How very original. The left has been doing this for forty years. [/quote] Yep, and it has gotten the Roman Rite (more so the American Church) to the point it is today. Don't get me wrong, I do see some encouraging signs in some dioceses, but on the whole it is rotting from within especially in America. Only time will tell however. I hope and pray that the next pontiff is very Orthodox, because if he's not and his tendencies are more liberal then I will be even more concerned about the future of the Church.
mp15 Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Feb 2 2005, 03:38 PM'] Of course it did. Nowhere has anybody given permission for teens to gather around the altar. And you need to understand you don't change the Mass and then seek an indult to justify your disobedient behavior. [/quote] Ditto that Cmom!!
BurkeFan Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='mp15' date='Feb 2 2005, 04:50 PM'] Yep, and it has gotten the Roman Rite (more so the American Church) to the point it is today. Don't get me wrong, I do see some encouraging signs in some dioceses, but on the whole it is rotting from within especially in America. Only time will tell however. I hope and pray that the next pontiff is very Orthodox, because if he's not and his tendencies are more liberal then I will be even more concerned about the future of the Church. [/quote] Have some faith in God about all of this. John XXIII reportedly, I think, used to pray at night, "I did the best I could Lord, but, it's Your Church, goodnight!"
randy_the_clown Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote]Of course it did. Nowhere has anybody given permission for teens to gather around the altar. And you need to understand you don't change the Mass and then seek an indult to justify your disobedient behavior. [/quote] The practice of gathering around the altar for the Eucharistic Prayer is one that dates back to the early church. No where in the GIRM does it forbid such a practice AS THE GIRM EXISTED in 1985 when LT started the tradition at the original parish. Burke... thanks for the correction on doxy vs. praxis... I'm a little rusty. However, his statement made something very clear... LT has always been Orthodox. If I feel that I am following the GIRM (which doesn't prohibit the said practice which is now a non-issue) by inculturation as stated in Paragraph #38 in the Constitution on Sacred Liturgy, how am I going against Orthopraxis? Tridentine Rite. There is nothing wrong with it... until you state that it is superior to the Novus Ordo. Even Ratzinger in the Ratzinger Report circa 1980 stated that to say one is invalid is to invalidate the other. The Church before Vatican II and after are the same Church, it is those who consistently harken to a "I wish is was 1955" that aren't Orthodox. If you discount Vat. II then you discount all.
randy_the_clown Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 (edited) [quote]Yep, and it has gotten the Roman Rite (more so the American Church) to the point it is today. Don't get me wrong, I do see some encouraging signs in some dioceses, but on the whole it is rotting from within especially in America. Only time will tell however. I hope and pray that the next pontiff is very Orthodox, because if he's not and his tendencies are more liberal then I will be even more concerned about the future of the Church.[/quote] How can you be concerned about the future of the Church? Where is your faith? Edited February 2, 2005 by randy_the_clown
goldenchild17 Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 I've asked for someone to present to me what Lifeteen is doing that is against Church teaching. I've asked for someone to present to me in some way how Lifeteen is NOW violating Church law and practice. This has not been done and cannot be done. Lifeteen is doing nothing against the Church. The Lifeteen Mass is just as legit a mass as the Traditional Mass is. Prove me wrong please.
randy_the_clown Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote]And you need to understand you don't change the Mass and then seek an indult to justify your disobedient behavior. [/quote] Mother of Phat, If something is not forbidden, and I do it with the best of intentions, and then am told not to do it and I stop... what is the problem? How is that disobedient? To disobey, you must in fact go against an order, which never happened.
cmotherofpirl Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 [quote name='randy_the_clown' date='Feb 2 2005, 07:09 PM'] The practice of gathering around the altar for the Eucharistic Prayer is one that dates back to the early church. No where in the GIRM does it forbid such a practice AS THE GIRM EXISTED in 1985 when LT started the tradition at the original parish. [/quote] And nowhere in the GIRM was such a practice authorized. As I said before you don't change part of the Mass , and then seek an indult to justify your behavior. Just because the early church did it is no excuse to take matters into your own hands and authority.
goldenchild17 Posted February 2, 2005 Posted February 2, 2005 And this wrong-doing was fixed. What's the problem?
Recommended Posts