Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

whoa, I never said being single meant a person wasn't following God's Will. I just was asking how INTENDING to remain single for the WHOLE of one's life fulfill a Chrisitan vocation?

I know a guy who just got married and he's 38. my friend getting married next month is 28 (almost 29). It just seems that these days it takes a bit longer for marriage in some cases.

also, what about the religious life? how do we know single people are merely rejecting God's call to them in the religious life?

I wasn't being judgmental. not once did I consign anyone to Hell.

Catholictothecore
Posted

I think all he was saying was single life is not one of the traditional vocations in the Church. It is a relatively new way fo life

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Catholictothecore' date='May 20 2005, 03:03 PM'] I think all he was saying was single life is not one of the traditional vocations in the Church. It is a relatively new way fo life [/quote]
Well, Dr. Asci is not the pope, but he very clearly and distinctly stated that there "is no such thing as a vocation to the single life".

I'm not trying to be hurtful or condemning, but my question up above was an honest one. Apart from religious life, what does "singleness" (in adulthood, beyond marrying age) fulfill in Christian life? If God calls us to community, how is this fulfilled to a FULL extent by being "single"... it seems to be antithetical. Religious live in community and take vows/priests are ordained and have a particular grace, etc. that goes along with that. What comes from "singleness"?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='May 20 2005, 02:58 PM'] whoa, I never said being single meant a person wasn't following God's Will. I just was asking how INTENDING to remain single for the WHOLE of one's life fulfill a Chrisitan vocation?

I know a guy who just got married and he's 38.  my friend getting married next month is 28 (almost 29). It just seems that these days it takes a bit longer for marriage in some cases.

also, what about the religious life? how do we know single people are merely rejecting God's call to them in the religious life?

I wasn't being judgmental. not once did I consign anyone to Hell. [/quote]
My post wansn't directly aimed at you. (Norseman seemed even more set against the idea of a "single vocation.')

Some people are doing good in their particular station in life, which would be difficult to do in a religious order. There are many roles in life, and I don't think we can narrowly say what is or isn't the will of God for someone. God can call individuals to many different things.

As long as he is not living a life contrary to God's laws, I don't think we can say any person is not "following his vocation" or is "rejecting God's will for his life."

Edited by Socrates
Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

But... just because I still don't understand...

how would remaining single (intentionally) for the whole of one's life completely fulfill a Christian vocation? What do single people do that married or religious people cannot do?

how does remaining single fulfill "community"? it's to a radically lesser extent than marriage (yet, it's not "for the kingdom of God" as religious do) and they take no vows, no specific sacrament, etc. to that particular state.

It just seems to me that singleness is a temporary state, not a permanent state of life.

Catholictothecore
Posted

I think what it means is someone whose going on God's time. I've read about ordinations and marriages that have happened well beyond youth.

Norseman82
Posted

Socrates, my apologies if any of my posts offended you, my point is not to bash single people who are single for the reasons you stated in your next to last post, but I am directing my remarks at those who do reject marriage and try to criticize those who seek it. This is where I'm coming from: in my own life, it seems that when I express a desire to establish a family (remember, I have none), I get people [i]criticizing me for desiring a family in the first place![/i] And they use the standardized knee-jerk phrases to justify it and to try to shut me up, like how it's God's will for my life (as if they are authorized to speak for God), how it's okay to be single and now how it's an acceptable vocation and that I should concentrate on being a happy single person. When people try to force that agenda on others, they may think they are helping, but they are in fact hurting more than helping. I do not intend to falsely accuse anyone on this site, but I do wish to show how the "single vocation" talk only helps to enable those who hurt others by criticizing desires for a family.

But I do thank you for the following statement:

[quote]As long as he is not living a life contrary to God's laws, I don't think we can say any person is not "following his vocation" or is "rejecting God's will for his life." [/quote]

That sums up the whole "God's will" issue for those who have not received a direct revelation from Him to do otherwise.

But I do maintain that it would be easier on everyone if those eligible to marry would not close the door on marriage completely. It might help increase the chances of finding an interested person of the opposite gender.

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='May 20 2005, 03:19 PM'] But... just because I still don't understand...

how would remaining single (intentionally) for the whole of one's life completely fulfill a Christian vocation? What do single people do that married or religious people cannot do?

how does remaining single fulfill "community"? it's to a radically lesser extent than marriage (yet, it's not "for the kingdom of God" as religious do) and they take no vows, no specific sacrament, etc. to that particular state.

It just seems to me that singleness is a temporary state, not a permanent state of life. [/quote]
I don't think we can ever claim to totally know the will of God.

I have some friends who are in their 30's and 40s who are unmarried, and who throught their jobs are able to do good for other people. Some work for pro-life organizations. One is quite active with the church (teaching CCD and such). There are many ways one can do good in the community besides being married or being a priest or nun. To say otherwise seems narrow thinking.

And are you implying that if one is not married/ordained, etc. at the end of his life, he has rejected or missed God's call for his life?
Obviously if one dies young and unmarried, (say at 20) this statement is absurd.
But what if someone dies unmarried (or ordained, etc.) at 40?
At 50? At 60? At what age can we say that one has "rejected his vocation"? Where do you draw the line?

See how this kind of thinking becomes problematic?

Norseman82
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='May 20 2005, 03:19 PM'] It just seems to me that singleness is a temporary state, not a permanent state of life. [/quote]
That's [i]exactly[/i] how I view it.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

socrates..

the key word was "intentionally" remaining single.

married and religious can work in pro-life organizations and teach CDD, etc.

Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' date='May 20 2005, 03:37 PM'] Socrates, my apologies if any of my posts offended you, my point is not to bash single people who are single for the reasons you stated in your next to last post, but I am directing my remarks at those who do reject marriage and try to criticize those who seek it. This is where I'm coming from: in my own life, it seems that when I express a desire to establish a family (remember, I have none), I get people [i]criticizing me for desiring a family in the first place![/i] And they use the standardized knee-jerk phrases to justify it and to try to shut me up, like how it's God's will for my life (as if they are authorized to speak for God), how it's okay to be single and now how it's an acceptable vocation and that I should concentrate on being a happy single person. When people try to force that agenda on others, they may think they are helping, but they are in fact hurting more than helping. I do not intend to falsely accuse anyone on this site, but I do wish to show how the "single vocation" talk only helps to enable those who hurt others by criticizing desires for a family.

But I do thank you for the following statement:



That sums up the whole "God's will" issue for those who have not received a direct revelation from Him to do otherwise.

But I do maintain that it would be easier on everyone if those eligible to marry would not close the door on marriage completely. It might help increase the chances of finding an interested person of the opposite gender. [/quote]
Sorry, I wasn't really offended. I see where you're coming from. i just get kind of frustrated with the general attitude that those of us who are single are somehow "not doing God's will."

It goes both ways. People have suggested that my lack of luck with the ladies means a religious vocation, and some are kind of generally critical of people being single.
Being single smells of elderberries and can get frustrating. Heck, I'd like a woman, and I've definitely not closed myself to that option.

However, I think constantly being unhappy about single is a bad attitude. I think that's what people are saying.

I don't think people should be judged for either wanting marriage, or not wanting marriage (unless it's a hedonistic I-don't-want-to-get-married-so-I-can-stay-single-and-party-with-the-babes-all-my-life sort of mentality.)

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='May 20 2005, 03:42 PM'] socrates..

the key word was "intentionally" remaining single.

married and religious can work in pro-life organizations and teach CDD, etc. [/quote]
They might not be able to devote as much to their work.

Anyway, most singles do not "set out" to remain single.
How does one know that he has "rejected" his vocation?

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' date='May 20 2005, 03:51 PM'] They might not be able to devote as much to their work.

Anyway, most singles do not "set out" to remain single.
How does one know that he has "rejected" his vocation? [/quote]
I don't know... religious seem pretty devoted to whatever they do. How does a single person teach CCD better than a religious or married person?

I know most do not set out to remain single, but sometimes it seems like people get to a point where they say, "I don't think I'm going to get married" and they claim that they are "called" to the single life (as a permanent state). I don't see how that fits in with the overall Christian vocation to love/become holy... by remaining "single" a person is "rejecting" the sacrament of marriage or holy orders (or the vows that nuns take...). There are "consecrated virgins", but then they taking vows and are thus "religious" (I'm not real sure how consecrated virginity works..). But remaining single for the whole of one's life (and INTENDING to remain as such) seems to reject an opportunity for further grace, and seems to reject an aspect of community.

being single isn't "bad".. I just don't see how it can be considered a permanent state of life for a person.

(fyi, I am single, do not think I'm called to the religious life.. but I don't intend to remain single forever, if I find a upstanding Catholic male, then hopefully he'll propose one day in the future.. but singleness is definitely a temporary state of life)

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='May 20 2005, 03:59 PM'] I don't know... religious seem pretty devoted to whatever they do. How does a single person teach CCD better than a religious or married person?

I know most do not set out to remain single, but sometimes it seems like people get to a point where they say, "I don't think I'm going to get married" and they claim that they are "called" to the single life (as a permanent state). I don't see how that fits in with the overall Christian vocation to love/become holy... by remaining "single" a person is "rejecting" the sacrament of marriage or holy orders (or the vows that nuns take...). There are "consecrated virgins", but then they taking vows and are thus "religious" (I'm not real sure how consecrated virginity works..). But remaining single for the whole of one's life (and INTENDING to remain as such) seems to reject an opportunity for further grace, and seems to reject an aspect of community.

being single isn't "bad".. I just don't see how it can be considered a permanent state of life for a person.

(fyi, I am single, do not think I'm called to the religious life.. but I don't intend to remain single forever, if I find a upstanding Catholic male, then hopefully he'll propose one day in the future.. but singleness is definitely a temporary state of life) [/quote]
And what if someone, through no fault of his own, dies "single" in middle or old age? Would you say he has "rejected his vocation?"

At what point must one "choose" a vocation (ie. "I'm too old to get married - better get to the seminary)?

Is the "intention not to stay single" the important thing?

How much effort must one put into finding a spouse? If he isn't married, does this
mean he "hasn't tried hard enough"?

Is one who dies single after much difficult and unsuccessful struggling to find a spouse necessarily more virtuous than one who dies "happily single"?

And what about those who rush into bad marriages to avoid "staying single"?


See the problems?

missionarybelle
Posted

good guys are rare! but when you find one you appreciate them even more! but they all seem to old for me right now which is okay since I'm not ready to date or anything.

Posted

My cousin just got married for the first time. (my mom's cousin)

she's 50. I think society does alot of the pressure. We are "supposed" to be married, with 4 kids, by the time we are 30. Society doesn't look nicely on you either if your older and you get married. You know how many jokes my cousin took for getting married at her age?

I don't think the problem is us, it's just getting harder and harder to find a good, holy spouse.

I love Mary Beth Bonacci, here's a great article I fully agree with.


[quote][b][u]Is the Single Life a Vocation? by Mary Beth Bonacci [/u][/b]

Well, the first National Catholic Singles Conference was a smashing success.
Nearly 400 people attended, from 30 states. As a single Catholic, there’s nothing quite like the experience of standing in a room with 400 other single Catholics – 400 other people who have experienced what you’ve experienced, 400 people who have also felt like the only single Catholic in the world.
It was awesome.

I’m not the only person who enjoyed the conference. I’ve been getting amazing feedback. It seems that wherever I go in the country now, I run into someone who was there, or who knows someone who was there – someone who was profoundly moved by the experience.

I’m finding it interesting that, literally every time someone talks to me about their experience at the conference, they mention one particular part of the talk I gave there – the part where I spoke about “vocation.”

Specifically, I asked the question, “Is the unconsecrated single life a ‘vocation,’ in the sense that the Church understands vocation?”

It’s a danged good question, if I do say so myself.

We are, of course, all accustomed to feeling invisible within the Catholic parish. But, recently, I’ve noticed a trend emerging. People within the parish who used to talk about the two vocations, marriage and religious life, are now adding a third, the “vocation” to the single life.

I’m grateful that they’re acknowledging us, but from the first time I heard it, something rubbed me wrong about the concept of a single “vocation.”
Reading the Holy Father’s letter on women, Mulieris Dignitatem, reinforced my suspicions. In that document, John Paul II says that God calls all women to give themselves in one of two ways – in motherhood or in consecration to Christ.

No mention of singleness in there.

In fact, I find no mention of an unconsecrated single “vocation” in Church teaching anywhere. As far as the Church is concerned, it doesn’t exist.
Here is the problem: “vocation,” in the sense the Church understands it, means “to give oneself completely.” The Vatican II document Gaudium et Spes says that man finds himself only through a sincere gift of himself. John Paul II, in Mulieris Dignitatem, speaks of the “spousal disposition of women.” We – women and men -- were made to give ourselves, in love, to others. That’s where we find happiness. 

Don’t singles give? Of course we do – often more than most. But vocation doesn’t mean “being a generous person.” It means giving our lives completely to another – either to a spouse in marriage or to God in consecrated virginity. And singleness doesn’t do that. In fact, the single state is defined by the lack of that gift.  We are unattached, un-given.

I wrote a newspaper column about this several months ago. The response was predictable. I received several indignant letters, all from married people who were saying “How dare you make these poor single people feel excluded?” The letters from single people, however, were unanimous. “Thank you for reaffirming what I suspected. This isn’t a vocation. Something is missing.”

So what about us? Why are we in this state? Did God forget about us? Are our lives somehow less worthy because we’re not settled into a vocation?
Most definitely not.

I believe that God has called each and every one of us to either marriage or to consecrated religious life. Unfortunately, the state of the world today has made it very difficult to fulfill that call – especially for those of us who believe we are called to marriage.  Marriage requires a partner. And good, holy, committed partners who share our faith are hard to find these days.

Is that God’s will? Not exactly. It isn’t His will that people are rejecting Him, turning away from His truths. But He allows it. He gave us free will, after all. Each one of us is free to follow Him or to reject Him. These days, a whole lot of people are rejecting Him. That’s called sin, and it has consequences.

One of the consequences of sin in the world is that people who are called to marriage are having a harder time finding suitable partners. The pool is poisoned. 
So where does that leave us? Are we the “sad sacks” who were left behind? Are our lives meaningless? Are we destined for unhappiness?
Goodness, no!

God writes straight with crooked lines. He meets us where we are. When we turn our lives over to Him, he creates something beautiful – beyond our wildest expectations.
That beautiful life will be different for every unique person God touches. But a few threads run consistently.

Singleness gives us an opportunity to turn to God in a profoundly personal way. With no other partner, He becomes partner. And when we turn to Him with that request, He answers.

As singles, we’re more aware that real fulfillment comes from giving. The absence of built-in gift in our lives motivates us to move outside of ourselves and to reach out in love to those around us.

And, for some, singleness gives us the opportunity to stand in a room with 400 other single Catholics, and to begin to live out our single lives together.  [/quote]

[url="http://www.reallove.net/index2.asp?CID=1"]http://www.reallove.net/index2.asp?CID=1[/url]

MissScripture
Posted

I do think there is too much pressure to not be single in society today, without becoming a priest or a nun. And by that I mean pressure to date/marry someone merely so you aren't single.
I was talking to the [b]Faith Formation Coordinator[/b] at my school. She told me she was convinced that I was going to become a nun. I said I had thought about it, but I really wanted to have kids. She told me, "Well, you need a boyfriend first!"
[b]I AM 17 YEARS OLD!! [/b]Its not like I could get married right now anyway!

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' date='May 20 2005, 04:14 PM'] And what if someone, through no fault of his own, dies "single" in middle or old age? Would you say he has "rejected his vocation?"

At what point must one "choose" a vocation (ie. "I'm too old to get married - better get to the seminary)?

Is the "intention not to stay single" the important thing?

How much effort must one put into finding a spouse? If he isn't married, does this
mean he "hasn't tried hard enough"?

Is one who dies single after much difficult and unsuccessful struggling to find a spouse necessarily more virtuous than one who dies "happily single"?

And what about those who rush into bad marriages to avoid "staying single"?


See the problems? [/quote]
There will always be extremists (i.e. rushing into bad marriages).

You keep pointing out "problems" but you still won't answer my question... what do single people do that married and religious can't?

Posted

Yeah, I just turned 20 and have never had a boyfriend. My mom, a cousin and I were eating lunch, when talk turned to my lack of boyfriend. My mom tells my cousin I am seriously considering entering into the religious life! I am like: where did THIS come from? Just because I have had fewer boyfriends than my 15 year old sister does not mean I cannot be called to the married life!

rckllnknny
Posted

FINALLY...a topic i can relate to...first of all...when you find the answer (well woman for me)...let me know!...but through my experince...this is what ive learned...dont hold on to past relationships...keep looking forward to a new one...dont take the first opportunity you get...and dont be discoraged by past relationships that dint work out(dont let jerks make us GOOD guys look bad!)...dont think that some guy is TOO good for you-youd be surprised...you probably pass about 100 acceptable men a day and dont realize it...theres probably a million men for ANY one woman...and most importantly GOD IS trying to help you find someone! i hope this helps you. it helps me....

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...