argent_paladin Posted May 21, 2005 Posted May 21, 2005 I think that single life can be a true vocation. HOWEVER, I think that modern culture is so anti-life and anti-marriage that I would be very careful about discerning a call. In only a generation, the average age of marriage has increased from about 23 to about 27. More and more people are staying single. And of course more and more are getting divorced. There is a crisis in the vocation of marriage. I don't think that God is suddenly calling fewer people to get married and raise children. I think that it is more likely that many are ignoring the call by focusing on their educations or careers above answering their vocation. And the older you get, the harder it gets. Read WHAT OUR MOTHERS DIDN'T TELL US: Why Happiness Eludes the Modern Woman by Danielle Crittenden. Her thesis is that for biological and psychological reasons, women are generally best served by having children young and a career later. And she says that women tend to unfairly blame men (as this thread does). Women are going against basic biology by seeking a career while young and being sexually active and then desire marriage at about thirty. Generally speaking, women are more physically attractive at 20 rather than 30 and their children will have a greater chance of being born healthier and without complication. Look at it from the average guy's point of view. He can choose to have sex without commitment with 20-year-olds or sex with marriage with 30-year-olds. Given that choice, and basic biology it is not surprising what the average man chooses. If women were chaste and married younger, then the choice wouldn't be so stark. Today, in educated society, it is much more looked down upon to be married at 18 than at 38. And having your first baby at 18 is much less approved of than your first baby at 38. But globally and historically, it wasn't unusual for a woman to be married much younger and to have children much younger. The idea that women are supposed to be "sexually active" by 16 but not married until they have a career (around 30) creates a society of irresponsible men, because women are providing sex with no strings attached for the peak years of their life. Then, after they have wasted their flower of youth on random men and have a solid career (because that is who they are) they decide to get married, because it is expected. We are living in a very sick society and we need to retrieve the vocation to married life. I don't think that there is too much pressure to get married. Rather, there is too little. Feminists and others tell us that women shouldn't marry before graduating from college and even then, if they get married, they shouldn't have kids until they can have a career, and both parents will share the responsibilities of raising the socially responsible two children equally, with government provided day-care and maternity-leave.
Myles Domini Posted May 21, 2005 Posted May 21, 2005 [quote]I think that single life can be a true vocation. HOWEVER, I think that modern culture is so anti-life and anti-marriage that I would be very careful about discerning a call. In only a generation, the average age of marriage has increased from about 23 to about 27. More and more people are staying single. And of course more and more are getting divorced. There is a crisis in the vocation of marriage. I don't think that God is suddenly calling fewer people to get married and raise children. I think that it is more likely that many are ignoring the call by focusing on their educations or careers above answering their vocation. And the older you get, the harder it gets. Read WHAT OUR MOTHERS DIDN'T TELL US: Why Happiness Eludes the Modern Woman by Danielle Crittenden. Her thesis is that for biological and psychological reasons, women are generally best served by having children young and a career later. And she says that women tend to unfairly blame men (as this thread does). Women are going against basic biology by seeking a career while young and being sexually active and then desire marriage at about thirty. Generally speaking, women are more physically attractive at 20 rather than 30 and their children will have a greater chance of being born healthier and without complication. Look at it from the average guy's point of view. He can choose to have sex without commitment with 20-year-olds or sex with marriage with 30-year-olds. Given that choice, and basic biology it is not surprising what the average man chooses. If women were chaste and married younger, then the choice wouldn't be so stark. Today, in educated society, it is much more looked down upon to be married at 18 than at 38. And having your first baby at 18 is much less approved of than your first baby at 38. But globally and historically, it wasn't unusual for a woman to be married much younger and to have children much younger. The idea that women are supposed to be "sexually active" by 16 but not married until they have a career (around 30) creates a society of irresponsible men, because women are providing sex with no strings attached for the peak years of their life. Then, after they have wasted their flower of youth on random men and have a solid career (because that is who they are) they decide to get married, because it is expected. We are living in a very sick society and we need to retrieve the vocation to married life. I don't think that there is too much pressure to get married. Rather, there is too little. Feminists and others tell us that women shouldn't marry before graduating from college and even then, if they get married, they shouldn't have kids until they can have a career, and both parents will share the responsibilities of raising the socially responsible two children equally, with government provided day-care and maternity-leave.[/quote] The only words I've read today that have been more true are found in Sacred Scripture. God Bless you Argent
Fides_et_Ratio Posted May 21, 2005 Posted May 21, 2005 How can the single life be a "true" vocation? God calls someone to live outside of community without being a religious? It just doesn't seem to make sense. What do single laypeople do that religious cannot? Singleness CAN be a vocation... but it is TEMPORARY one. I still haven't seen any reasons why one should consider it to be a permanent vocation? I'm not anti-single. I myself am single... I've gone on a few dates, but not had a steady boyfriend (well, since I've been a practicing Catholic, I haven't gone on any dates), never been kissed, etc. and I'm 20. I don't think I'm called to the religious life. At all. But if it got to a certain point in my life where I'm not married, not dating, etc. then perhaps I ought to go back and reconsider the religious life. I'm not an expert discerner, so I might need to eventually go back and have another, closer look. But I don't think singleness is a way to truly fulfill a Christian vocation to holiness and love. Community is an important aspect of love, it's found in marriage, and, in a different way, in the religious life. Single life takes no vows, no particular Sacraments, etc. -- It's just not permanent. It's a temporary state of life.
Skylark Posted May 21, 2005 Posted May 21, 2005 [quote name='MichaelFilo' date='May 17 2005, 09:56 PM']Personally, the best standards you should shoot for (really, the only one) is to find someone who tries to live out the Catholic Faith. I say try, because we fail at times, but trying is a sign we will it. God bless, Mikey[/quote] Thanks, Mikey. You didn't write this advice to me, but it opened my eyes too. :married:
Skylark Posted May 21, 2005 Posted May 21, 2005 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='May 21 2005, 10:54 AM'] How can the single life be a "true" vocation? God calls someone to live outside of community without being a religious? It just doesn't seem to make sense. What do single laypeople do that religious cannot? [/quote] Well, I don't know how it is in US, but in my country (ex-communist country) there are MANY things that a religious cannot do, while a lay-single can (starting from being a teacher in a school...) The next thing is that there are people who are so mentally or physically disabled that they are not able to marry or they simply cannot get anybody who would wish to marry with them. Do you really think that they cannot live a good Christian/Catholic life? And that God thinks that they are doing wrong when they are single? And what about homosexuals? As long as they feel those homosexualls desires they are not ready to marry - and some cannot change. But to choose a religious life because of that..??? For marriage you choose your wife/husband. But for religious life, God chooses you. And as Jesus said - not everybody gets married - some because they were born like that (not able), some were made that way by people and SOME because of kingdom of God.
Noel's angel Posted May 21, 2005 Posted May 21, 2005 So, if you are single and don't want to get married, you have to rush off and join the priesthood or become a nun? Doesn't seem right to me-surely it's better to have a few priests and nuns who have felt a strong calling, than lots who think 'hey, being single isn't a vocation and I don't want to get married, so this is my only option'
Fides_et_Ratio Posted May 21, 2005 Posted May 21, 2005 those are all good points, but they still don't answer my question... how does a vocation to the single life FULFILL the ultimate Christian vocation to love and holiness, when singleness by its very nature rejects an aspect of community-- an important facet of love?
Socrates Posted May 22, 2005 Posted May 22, 2005 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='May 21 2005, 05:45 PM'] those are all good points, but they still don't answer my question... how does a vocation to the single life FULFILL the ultimate Christian vocation to love and holiness, when singleness by its very nature rejects an aspect of community-- an important facet of love? [/quote] Being single is not necessarily a rejection of community (and remember some saints have been hermits -are THEY doing evil by "rejecting community"). Many single people are quite involved with their communities. Love and holiness can be fulfilled in many ways outside of marriage or religious life/holy orders. And this in no way denigrates those calling. There are many different ways to live a godly life!
Fides_et_Ratio Posted May 22, 2005 Posted May 22, 2005 [quote name='Socrates' date='May 21 2005, 07:14 PM'] Being single is not necessarily a rejection of community (and remember some saints have been hermits -are THEY doing evil by "rejecting community"). Many single people are quite involved with their communities. Love and holiness can be fulfilled in many ways outside of marriage or religious life/holy orders. And this in no way denigrates those calling. There are many different ways to live a godly life! [/quote] but weren't hermits religious? I can't think of a hermit that was hadn't taken vows of some sort... I didn't say single people were like their own little islands and uninvolved in their communities.. but they do not have a communal relationship like a married couple do, or a communal relationship like those in the religious life. No Sacrament, no vows. HOW can love be FULFILLED in the single life? It is radically different from both married and religious life. HOW is the single life a permanent state of life rather than a temporary one?
Catholictothecore Posted May 22, 2005 Posted May 22, 2005 Argent_Paladin makes a very good point. I think that part of CCD, perhaps, should be to instruct that a family is a career, for both. I firmly believe the traditional "roles" of the family, perhaps with the father a little more in play. It's like, I'd love to be a lawyer if I dn't become a priest. That's a very demanding job. I would quit before I really let anyone dictate to me that I was expected to give more attention to a case than my family.
journeyman Posted May 22, 2005 Posted May 22, 2005 Isn't this "sort of" the reason for some of the third orders? People were called to ministry, but not to ordination or vows? There were some "orders" which never received official sanction, but operated as communities, with and without diocesan support . . . until they were officially disapproved (the Beguines?) Catholictothecore . . . part of the problem with quitting before putting the client ahead of family is that it leaves the client in the lurch . . . and bar associations love to yank licenses when clients interests are harmed . . . you need to either be extremely well organized - so there are no "crisis" situations - or extremely flexible (because a client crisis is rarely something that can be scheduled) - or a lawyer whose practice has no deadlines . . . if you can find the latter, please post
Ash Wednesday Posted May 22, 2005 Posted May 22, 2005 If being single was an unacceptable permanent state or calling, then what about people who are emotionally or mentally unfit to be a spouse, or, a priest or sister? All of these vocations are certainly not cakewalks. Some people are simply not mentally or emotionally cut out to share a life with another, and it is difficult for them to be in a community on a regular basis outside of the mass. I know of people that are like this. They have crosses that they must bear every day.
Norseman82 Posted May 23, 2005 Posted May 23, 2005 [quote name='argent_paladin' date='May 21 2005, 02:42 AM'] I think that single life can be a true vocation. HOWEVER, I think that modern culture is so anti-life and anti-marriage that I would be very careful about discerning a call. In only a generation, the average age of marriage has increased from about 23 to about 27. More and more people are staying single. And of course more and more are getting divorced. There is a crisis in the vocation of marriage. I don't think that God is suddenly calling fewer people to get married and raise children. I think that it is more likely that many are ignoring the call by focusing on their educations or careers above answering their vocation. And the older you get, the harder it gets. Read WHAT OUR MOTHERS DIDN'T TELL US: Why Happiness Eludes the Modern Woman by Danielle Crittenden. Her thesis is that for biological and psychological reasons, women are generally best served by having children young and a career later. And she says that women tend to unfairly blame men (as this thread does). Women are going against basic biology by seeking a career while young and being sexually active and then desire marriage at about thirty. Generally speaking, women are more physically attractive at 20 rather than 30 and their children will have a greater chance of being born healthier and without complication. Look at it from the average guy's point of view. He can choose to have sex without commitment with 20-year-olds or sex with marriage with 30-year-olds. Given that choice, and basic biology it is not surprising what the average man chooses. If women were chaste and married younger, then the choice wouldn't be so stark. Today, in educated society, it is much more looked down upon to be married at 18 than at 38. And having your first baby at 18 is much less approved of than your first baby at 38. But globally and historically, it wasn't unusual for a woman to be married much younger and to have children much younger. The idea that women are supposed to be "sexually active" by 16 but not married until they have a career (around 30) creates a society of irresponsible men, because women are providing sex with no strings attached for the peak years of their life. Then, after they have wasted their flower of youth on random men and have a solid career (because that is who they are) they decide to get married, because it is expected. We are living in a very sick society and we need to retrieve the vocation to married life. I don't think that there is too much pressure to get married. Rather, there is too little. Feminists and others tell us that women shouldn't marry before graduating from college and even then, if they get married, they shouldn't have kids until they can have a career, and both parents will share the responsibilities of raising the socially responsible two children equally, with government provided day-care and maternity-leave. [/quote] Excellent post, argent. Cohabitation is another reason people don't marry.
Norseman82 Posted May 23, 2005 Posted May 23, 2005 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' date='May 22 2005, 02:49 PM'] If being single was an unacceptable permanent state or calling, then what about people who are emotionally or mentally unfit to be a spouse, or, a priest or sister? All of these vocations are certainly not cakewalks. Some people are simply not mentally or emotionally cut out to share a life with another, and it is difficult for them to be in a community on a regular basis outside of the mass. I know of people that are like this. They have crosses that they must bear every day. [/quote] Unfortunately, in todays's "culture of therapy" where the twelve steps have replaced the Ten Commandments, it seems just about anybody can be ruled emotionally unfit!
Socrates Posted May 23, 2005 Posted May 23, 2005 [quote name='Norseman82' date='May 22 2005, 10:02 PM'] Unfortunately, in todays's "culture of therapy" where the twelve steps have replaced the Ten Commandments, it seems just about anybody can be ruled emotionally unfit! [/quote] True, but would you really want to be married to a raving psychotic? I know I don't!
master_alterserver Posted May 24, 2005 Posted May 24, 2005 I don't get this...I try my hardest to be a real gentlemen. I open doors for girls. I look away when girls are wearing low-cut shirts or short skirts. But it seems like all the girlsgo with the guys who try and look up their skirts or who grab their butt when they walk by. Even the girls at school who claim to be Catholic. I am not trying to get a date (becasue I am discerning my vocation to the priesthood) but I think it stinks that the jerks at school get rewarded for being jerks. I get ignored.
missionarybelle Posted May 24, 2005 Posted May 24, 2005 then those girls are jerks too!! I promise good girls NOTICE when guys do that!!! Seriously I was in Mass the other day and I noticed this one guy who sang, let his sis go first etc etc and I TOTALLY noticed!
Luthien Posted May 24, 2005 Posted May 24, 2005 [quote name='master_alterserver' date='May 24 2005, 06:39 AM'] I don't get this...I try my hardest to be a real gentlemen. I open doors for girls. I look away when girls are wearing low-cut shirts or short skirts. But it seems like all the girlsgo with the guys who try and look up their skirts or who grab their butt when they walk by. Even the girls at school who claim to be Catholic. I am not trying to get a date (becasue I am discerning my vocation to the priesthood) but I think it stinks that the jerks at school get rewarded for being jerks. I get ignored. [/quote] ...you know what? This is so familiar. I always feel like guys are looking ay girls in lowcut tops and shirt skirts, and ignoring me because I wear modest clothing. It certainly goes both ways.
Norseman82 Posted May 24, 2005 Posted May 24, 2005 [quote name='Socrates' date='May 23 2005, 06:19 PM'] True, but would you really want to be married to a raving psychotic? I know I don't! [/quote] What I'm referring to are not the true cases of mental illness. I'm referring to the refusal of cliquish snobs who are stuck in a high-school clique mentality to accept people who may have come from the proverbial "wrong side of the tracks" whether it be due to family (or lack thereof) or class background and just to get rid of them want to wall them off into their own little "ghetto". I've heard remarks of "He's a good Catholic but comes from a dysfunctional family, so stay away from him" (earth to snottie, earth to snottie, what family is perfectly functional?). And yes, I've run into these types at Catholic events - including the Opus Dei parish, so this is not limited to groups whose fidelity to Rome is suspect. Catholic dating needs to get cleaned up big time.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now