Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Marijuana Is Safer Than Alcohol


Recommended Posts

Posted

Why dont they say "The use of drugs (Except alcohol cause Jesus drank it) inflicts very grave damage on human health and life". That would be more clear.

 

Alcohol is a drug too....and its terrible long term health effects...but I suppose its not considered "grave damage on human health and life" even though 40% of crimes are alcohol related.

 

Does this make sense to you? It doesnt make sense to me. 

Posted

So let me just get something straight, when the catechism talks about mind altering substances that are sinful, you think that involves everything that affects your mind in any way such as caffeine, chocolate, food that tastes good, tv, water, alcohol, sugar, any substance that can be eaten or inhaled or so on.  So your under the assumption this is all sinful since it alters your mind in the most technical terms.  You think the church actually meant it like you think?

Of course not. That would be silly.

Posted (edited)

Why dont they say "The use of drugs (Except alcohol cause Jesus drank it) inflicts very grave damage on human health and life". That would be more clear.

 

Alcohol is a drug too....and its terrible long term health effects...but I suppose its not considered "grave damage on human health and life" even though 40% of crimes are alcohol related.

 

Does this make sense to you? It doesnt make sense to me. 

No no no, you messed it all up. It goes "The use of drugs (Except alcohol because Jesus drank it, and except caffeine because c'mon, how else are we going to make it out of the house on time, and nicotine as well because... well, just because...)......". "rolleyes:

Edited by Nihil Obstat
Posted

No no no, you messed it all up. It goes "The use of drugs (Except alcohol because Jesus drank it, and except caffeine because c'mon, how else are we going to make it out of the house on time, and nicotine as well because... well, just because...)......". "rolleyes:

 

But...what about poptarts??????????????????  :cry:

Posted

But...what about poptarts??????????????????  :cry:

Not sure. According to Havok they are as mind-altering as caffeine, so I guess they need to go on the list too.

Posted

Crab apples

Posted

So it's just that people are threatened with assault, battery, and kidnapping for using marijuana, and that if they resist this, the people committing these crimes may kill the user or possessor of unapproved plants. Because marijuana is (supposedly) sinful for use.

 

It's also sinful to masturbate. Guess we've found another job for the ATF.

 

Posted

Crab apples

 

Jesus didn't eat those either, and they give you a sugar high! 

Posted

I could twist this to say that consuming the Eucharist itself is a sin if I wanted to.

 

I may not be Catholic, but I doubt the Church had the same strict interpretation you have when they wrote this.

 

 

you could twist the eucharist being a sin is some delusional fantasy world.  no sane person could interpret this to mean the eucharist is sinful.  this has now jumped the shark.

Posted

you could twist the eucharist being a sin is some delusional fantasy world.  no sane person could interpret this to mean the eucharist is sinful.  this has now jumped the shark.

 

You first.

Posted

Why dont they say "The use of drugs (Except alcohol cause Jesus drank it) inflicts very grave damage on human health and life". That would be more clear.

 

Alcohol is a drug too....and its terrible long term health effects...but I suppose its not considered "grave damage on human health and life" even though 40% of crimes are alcohol related.

 

Does this make sense to you? It doesnt make sense to me. 

 

 

it makes complete sense to me.  wine which is alcohol is the only thing church approved to use for the blood of Christ.  so because of this, alcohol in of itself can never be sinful.

 

so do you disagree with the catechism?

PhuturePriest
Posted

So it's just that people are threatened with assault, battery, and kidnapping for using marijuana, and that if they resist this, the people committing these crimes may kill the user or possessor of unapproved plants. Because marijuana is (supposedly) sinful for use.

 

It's also sinful to masturbate. Guess we've found another job for the ATF.

 

That would be a very interesting job.

 

I would like to hereby come out of the closet as a libertarian.

Posted (edited)
 

it makes complete sense to me.  wine which is alcohol is the only thing church approved to use for the blood of Christ.  so because of this, alcohol in of itself can never be sinful.

 

so do you disagree with the catechism?

 

 

I do not. 

Everything in moderation my friend! If you drink alcohol to get drunk and alter your mind...sure its a sin. Same goes for marijuana. 

But the key is that you DONT have to smoke that much, you can smoke a tiny  bit and the result is the same thing as a tiny bit of alcohol...you just dont erode your liver in the process. Which is nice. I like my liver.

 

I dont think any of these substances in themselves are evil, just depends on how you use them and what your purpose is.

Edited by CrossCuT
Posted

 

 

 

I do not. 

Everything in moderation my friend! If you drink alcohol to get drunk and alter your mind...sure its a sin. Same goes for marijuana. 

But the key is that you DONT have to smoke that much, you can smoke a tiny  bit and the result is the same thing as a tiny bit of alcohol...you just dont erode your liver in the process. Which is nice. I like my liver.

 

I dont think any of these substances in themselves are evil, just depends on how you use them and what your purpose is.

 

 

So it's clear you like your pot. I think that marijuana should be legal, especially for medical purposes - anything that can help the terminally or chronically ill suffer less.

 

I also think it should be legal in that it helps weed people out. You may not know anyone who has ruined their life with pot but I do.

 

I'm sure this may be the result of a childhood spent in our alcoholic home, but I've never been able to understand the desire to get "buzzed." Like Lilllabettt, I associate it with mental weakness, or more specifically with an obese, greasy, debauched mind. Not that the people are necessarily obese but their brains seem to be.

 

Have you ever read Brave New World - it's like those people swallowing their soma. Or the people in Farenheit 451 - most people in that world get their pleasure from tv and only a few get their pleasure from real life, from nature, from books.

 

This is completely outside the question of whether it's a sin or not. But I could never be a soma-eater. And yes I read this with a glass of cab in hand, but that's not because I am trying to get buzzed off the wine...

Posted (edited)

So what other outdated stereotypes do you buy into so wholly?

Also, in reference to how you answered Zabbazooey earlier, you agree that marijuana does not harm your health however you defend your stance by promoting a stereotype and follow it up what appear to be excerpts from corny video games? "Life is something you dominate, if you're any good."

 

Do you feel this strongly with Alcohol too?

 

Yes I do. I don't drink. I think people who do are leaving the barn door open. But to each his own. I am not at stage of life where I can risk any disadvantage vs. the competition.

 

"Life is something you dominate, if you're any good" is not from a video game.

It is from F. Scott Fitzgerald, author of classic American literature.

More reading less smoking.

 

eta: http://www.pbs.org/wnet/americanmasters/episodes/f-scott-fitzgerald/essay-the-crack-up/1028/
 

Edited by Lilllabettt
Posted

 

I also think it should be legal in that it helps weed people out. 

 

haha! :hehe: 

Posted

So it's clear you like your pot. I think that marijuana should be legal, especially for medical purposes - anything that can help the terminally or chronically ill suffer less.

 

I also think it should be legal in that it helps weed people out. You may not know anyone who has ruined their life with pot but I do.

 

I'm sure this may be the result of a childhood spent in our alcoholic home, but I've never been able to understand the desire to get "buzzed." Like Lilllabettt, I associate it with mental weakness, or more specifically with an obese, greasy, debauched mind. Not that the people are necessarily obese but their brains seem to be.

 

Have you ever read Brave New World - it's like those people swallowing their soma. Or the people in Farenheit 451 - most people in that world get their pleasure from tv and only a few get their pleasure from real life, from nature, from books.

 

This is completely outside the question of whether it's a sin or not. But I could never be a soma-eater. And yes I read this with a glass of cab in hand, but that's not because I am trying to get buzzed off the wine...

Ive never claimed people havent been susceptible to people allowing marijuana to ruin their lives but in the case of alcohol it happens all the time however people dont freak out over that.

All I am saying is that while each experience is unique on its own, we need to look at the bigger picture. 

 

Yes I do. I don't drink. I think people who do are leaving the barn door open. But to each his own. I am not at stage of life where I can risk any disadvantage vs. the competition.

 

"Life is something you dominate, if you're any good" is not from a video game.

It is from F. Scott Fitzgerald, author of classic American literature.

More reading less smoking.

 

eta: http://www.pbs.org/wnet/americanmasters/episodes/f-scott-fitzgerald/essay-the-crack-up/1028/
 

 

Your view of the world seems very bleak. :(

Posted

just cuz I don't smoke, dont drink and don't suffer no fools don't mean my vision of life is bleak.

being sober in a drunk world is on another level.

Posted

:dance: I dont smoke either

But I do like moscato a lot

Posted

 

 

I also think it should be legal in that it helps weed people out.

 

 

haha! :hehe:

 

 

I didn't even realize I did that!!! :winner:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...