mommas_boy Posted May 9, 2010 Posted May 9, 2010 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' date='09 May 2010 - 01:42 AM' timestamp='1273383735' post='2107539'] Eagle_Eye is helping me out. We're setting up a Yahoo group to start really coordinating this. Then we can start hitting hard with our responses. As soon as we get a certain number of points, which should take a few weeks, we can start giving positive and negative votes to answers. The idea, obviously, is that all of us will answer, then all of us will up-vote each other's answers, and down-vote wrong ones. [/quote] Creating a Yahoo group for the purpose of coordinating where our points go (esp. "Hey, Momma's Boy just posted. Vote him up!") might violate their terms of service: http://help.yahoo.com/l/us/yahoo/answers/abuse/guidelines-12.html;_ylt=AiNkIZz1Gzvk01rUHjPzCT9ujSN4 I think it's a type of "point-gaming". It'd be a thin line ...
Nihil Obstat Posted May 9, 2010 Author Posted May 9, 2010 [quote name='mommas_boy' date='09 May 2010 - 12:52 AM' timestamp='1273384349' post='2107546'] Creating a Yahoo group for the purpose of coordinating where our points go (esp. "Hey, Momma's Boy just posted. Vote him up!") might violate their terms of service: http://help.yahoo.com/l/us/yahoo/answers/abuse/guidelines-12.html;_ylt=AiNkIZz1Gzvk01rUHjPzCT9ujSN4 I think it's a type of "point-gaming". It'd be a thin line ... [/quote] You're probably right. In that case we'll need to be really careful about how we go about it.
Maximilianus Posted May 9, 2010 Posted May 9, 2010 The FBCrusaders should use St. Bernard as their patron.
Nihil Obstat Posted May 9, 2010 Author Posted May 9, 2010 On the other hand, they don't mention point-cabals anywhere so far.
mommas_boy Posted May 9, 2010 Posted May 9, 2010 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' date='09 May 2010 - 02:08 AM' timestamp='1273385290' post='2107553'] On the other hand, they don't mention point-cabals anywhere so far. [/quote] True, that's why I'm torn. Plus, I've always wanted to be a cabalist. I figure that if they will punish one person having multiple accounts, then they ought to punish one "group" with multiple accounts. That group is still directed with one single intention, the way that one person is directed with one intention. Basically, despite our best intentions, I think we would have a hard time defending why everyone in our "group" always votes for everyone else in our group. It would appear as though we were all the same person. Having a Yahoo group to coordinate things simply documents all the evidence on their servers, too.
Nihil Obstat Posted May 9, 2010 Author Posted May 9, 2010 [quote name='mommas_boy' date='09 May 2010 - 01:19 AM' timestamp='1273385996' post='2107563'] True, that's why I'm torn. Plus, I've always wanted to be a cabalist. I figure that if they will punish one person having multiple accounts, then they ought to punish one "group" with multiple accounts. That group is still directed with one single intention, the way that one person is directed with one intention. Basically, despite our best intentions, I think we would have a hard time defending why everyone in our "group" always votes for everyone else in our group. It would appear as though we were all the same person. Having a Yahoo group to coordinate things simply documents all the evidence on their servers, too. [/quote] It certainly could look like a single person. Although they'll be able to see IP addresses and can tell that we're definitely different people. It depends how strictly they plan on moderating. After all, our plan is just the free use of points that they gave us. There's no official conditions on those points, besides that you can't post specifically asking for them. The way I see it, we might as well give it a try, and stop if they tell us to.
mommas_boy Posted May 9, 2010 Posted May 9, 2010 (edited) [quote name='Nihil Obstat' date='09 May 2010 - 02:24 AM' timestamp='1273386244' post='2107569'] It certainly could look like a single person. Although they'll be able to see IP addresses and can tell that we're definitely different people. It depends how strictly they plan on moderating. After all, our plan is just the free use of points that they gave us. There's no official conditions on those points, besides that you can't post specifically asking for them. The way I see it, we might as well give it a try, and stop if they tell us to. [/quote] They could claim that we were using a proxy server to mask our IP addresses. Plus, IP addresses are not static things to begin with, and are not useful in establishing identity. EDIT: Go to a coffee shop, or simply reboot your modem ... bingo! You have a new IP. Edited May 9, 2010 by mommas_boy
Gregorius Posted May 9, 2010 Posted May 9, 2010 I'm browsing the Christian forums right now. . . There's a whole sub-forum on Liberal Catholics. Looks like Conversion material. That Guy JimR-OCDS is over there.
Archaeology cat Posted May 9, 2010 Posted May 9, 2010 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' date='09 May 2010 - 04:19 AM' timestamp='1273375176' post='2107418'] After it's squished, would you skin it and make a yummy dinner? [/quote] I have a dream of making Easter Bunny Fricasee someday.
HisChildForever Posted May 9, 2010 Posted May 9, 2010 I just want to point out that a lot of people will cry foul for no reason. I have only ever engaged with Protestants (i.e. Christian Teen Forums) and I cannot count the number of times they called me rude, pompous, uncharitable, self-righteous, etc. - ironically not even realizing that name-calling falls under some (if not all) of those categories. I would read over my posts and I swear I could not find a single thing that would have personally targeted their person. All I would do was defend the Church and provide Scriptures or history to counter their senseless accusations. For example, instead of saying "Oh well, the Church has the fullness of Truth, not my problem you accept your heresy" which would be uncharitable of course, I would say "The Catholic Church professes to hold the fullness of Truth" and I would be called self-righteous for that. Someone actually called me cruel. Sometimes I wondered if they actually read my posts, because I would make a point and someone would respond to it as if I had written something completely different.
eagle_eye222001 Posted May 9, 2010 Posted May 9, 2010 [quote name='HisChildForever' date='09 May 2010 - 11:52 AM' timestamp='1273420324' post='2107672'] I just want to point out that a lot of people will cry foul for no reason... [/quote] Oh they have a reason. They know they are wrong, and they feel very threatened. So they lash out illogically to mask their weakness and convince themselves they are still right.
Laudate_Dominum Posted May 9, 2010 Posted May 9, 2010 [quote name='HisChildForever' date='09 May 2010 - 11:52 AM' timestamp='1273420324' post='2107672'] I just want to point out that a lot of people will cry foul for no reason. I have only ever engaged with Protestants (i.e. Christian Teen Forums) and I cannot count the number of times they called me rude, pompous, uncharitable, self-righteous, etc. - ironically not even realizing that name-calling falls under some (if not all) of those categories. I would read over my posts and I swear I could not find a single thing that would have personally targeted their person. All I would do was defend the Church and provide Scriptures or history to counter their senseless accusations. For example, instead of saying "Oh well, the Church has the fullness of Truth, not my problem you accept your heresy" which would be uncharitable of course, I would say "The Catholic Church professes to hold the fullness of Truth" and I would be called self-righteous for that. Someone actually called me cruel. Sometimes I wondered if they actually read my posts, because I would make a point and someone would respond to it as if I had written something completely different. [/quote] The classic [i]argumentum ad hominem[/i], Christian style. In debates with Protestants (as well as in Catholic vs. Catholic debates) it seems that many will conveniently decide that an "uncharitable" messenger cannot be speaking God's truth (unless that messenger happens to be supporting their pov). Coming from a Christian it often indicates that they're disposed to write you off. I suppose it isn't hard to assume malice in a person's post. For a little while I would post on a militant atheist board where people would sideline and ridicule you if you could not play the flame war game with some intensity. It was as though searing rhetoric were the main indicator of credibility.
Archaeology cat Posted May 9, 2010 Posted May 9, 2010 [quote name='HisChildForever' date='09 May 2010 - 04:52 PM' timestamp='1273420324' post='2107672'] I just want to point out that a lot of people will cry foul for no reason. I have only ever engaged with Protestants (i.e. Christian Teen Forums) and I cannot count the number of times they called me rude, pompous, uncharitable, self-righteous, etc. - ironically not even realizing that name-calling falls under some (if not all) of those categories. I would read over my posts and I swear I could not find a single thing that would have personally targeted their person. All I would do was defend the Church and provide Scriptures or history to counter their senseless accusations. For example, instead of saying "Oh well, the Church has the fullness of Truth, not my problem you accept your heresy" which would be uncharitable of course, I would say "The Catholic Church professes to hold the fullness of Truth" and I would be called self-righteous for that. Someone actually called me cruel. Sometimes I wondered if they actually read my posts, because I would make a point and someone would respond to it as if I had written something completely different. [/quote] I've experienced something similar. And I'm fairly certain the other person didn't read the post, because the response made little sense with what had been written. And so I continue to ask for Our Lady's and St Monica's intercession.
goldenchild17 Posted May 9, 2010 Posted May 9, 2010 (edited) I don't really have any intention of joining again. It was fun while I was in, but I don't think I know enough as I thought I did back when I was a part of it. I was just going to say that it might be interesting if the FBC at least considered taking a different approach this time, maybe on a trial basis. When the FBC was in action before it divided people into teams to take up residence on different non-Catholic message boards. And this was good, and probably had good results for some people. But maybe the group might consider trying a different audience this time? An audience that isn't focused on apologetics (such as one would see on protestant message boards where people join simply to debate theological issues. Maybe join news sites and be actively involved on commenting on news stories, correcting the many errors people usually post there. Or join youtube and have a team work on posting Catholic videos. Or twitter and have a team post things there. Same with facebook and myspace or wherever else. Doing what was done last time would still be good, but I wonder if this new approach would be seen by more people (being far bigger sites) and be seen by people who are not as militant in their anti-Catholicism and thus be more open to accepting Catholicism. just a thought about something I was thinking about starting at some point. Edited May 9, 2010 by goldenchild17
Vincent Vega Posted May 9, 2010 Posted May 9, 2010 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' date='08 May 2010 - 11:43 PM' timestamp='1273376617' post='2107444'] [img]http://i.somethingawful.com/inserts/articlepics/photoshop/ww2propaganda/example-canadian.jpg[/img] [/quote] [img]http://rlv.zcache.com/ww1_collectors_card_1914_canada_propaganda_postcard-p239195880896162913trdg_400.jpg[/img]
HisChildForever Posted May 9, 2010 Posted May 9, 2010 [quote name='goldenchild17' date='09 May 2010 - 02:22 PM' timestamp='1273429328' post='2107702'] I don't really have any intention of joining again. It was fun while I was in, but I don't think I know enough as I thought I did back when I was a part of it. I was just going to say that it might be interesting if the FBC at least considered taking a different approach this time, maybe on a trial basis. When the FBC was in action before it divided people into teams to take up residence on different non-Catholic message boards. And this was good, and probably had good results for some people. But maybe the group might consider trying a different audience this time? An audience that isn't focused on apologetics (such as one would see on protestant message boards where people join simply to debate theological issues. Maybe join news sites and be actively involved on commenting on news stories, correcting the many errors people usually post there. Or join youtube and have a team work on posting Catholic videos. Or twitter and have a team post things there. Same with facebook and myspace or wherever else. Doing what was done last time would still be good, but I wonder if this new approach would be seen by more people (being far bigger sites) and be seen by people who are not as militant in their anti-Catholicism and thus be more open to accepting Catholicism. just a thought about something I was thinking about starting at some point. [/quote] I firmly believe that forums are the best place, because most people who join are there for a purpose (save trolls and spammers) and want to be involved in an online community. Trying to evangelize or inform on YouTube would be an absolute waste of time, because no one takes those comments seriously.
goldenchild17 Posted May 9, 2010 Posted May 9, 2010 [quote name='HisChildForever' date='09 May 2010 - 01:05 PM' timestamp='1273431954' post='2107718'] I firmly believe that forums are the best place, because most people who join are there for a purpose (save trolls and spammers) and want to be involved in an online community. Trying to evangelize or inform on YouTube would be an absolute waste of time, because no one takes those comments seriously. [/quote] fair enough. Forums can be a fine place to work with. It's just not for me anymore. I've seen far more success in more public, more popular places, but maybe that's just because I spend more time in places like that. And just for clarification, I wasn't talking about just comments on youtube, I was talking about a team here making videos to put on youtube. But yes I get your point.
HisChildForever Posted May 9, 2010 Posted May 9, 2010 [quote name='goldenchild17' date='09 May 2010 - 03:23 PM' timestamp='1273432988' post='2107722'] fair enough. Forums can be a fine place to work with. It's just not for me anymore. I've seen far more success in more public, more popular places, but maybe that's just because I spend more time in places like that. And just for clarification, I wasn't talking about just comments on youtube, I was talking about a team here making videos to put on youtube. But yes I get your point. [/quote]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now